Dungeon & Dragons Mafia - Game Thread [GAME OVER]

[SupineSnake]

I feel like you are kind of both arguing over semantics a bit here

For sure. Does feel like you're trying to bog me down in nothing, Sky.

Tbh where I've historically played two votes like that would usually just be people trying to be comedians. Reading everyone analyse two nothing votes felt weird to me. Obviously the meta here is different.

I guess what I'm saying is naturally I'm more inclined to be suspect of those overanalyzing the two votes than those making them.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I feel like you are kind of both arguing over semantics a bit here

Probably. I could just as easily go into the weird contradiction of Lethal saying he doesn't have a plan while clearly having a plan but maybe that's semantics too

 

[Ultra]

Tbh, voting Jeff would be a smart move for scum, since he’s one of the best players. I agree that lethal and SA probably aren’t aligned, but I definitely think one of them are scum. You want to get the best at scum hunting out of the game as quickly as possible to avoid being detected. Now the question is, which one is scum and which one just voted for him to do so.

This post doesn't make any sense - if Jeff is such a strong player he can be eliminated at night. Furthermore, this feels like a delayed reaction, Blaze doesn't take issue with Lethal's vote until others start talking about it

 

[Leon TrotSky]

The most active player? In the first post of the game? :/

Lethal wasn't active at all last game so I'm unaware of their general activity.

One of the more active players when he's on (but he rarely is because just Australia things).

And yes in the first post of the game, Jeff is active constantly on these games when he's playing

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Furthermore, this feels like a delayed reaction, Blaze doesn't take issue with Lethal's vote until others start talking about it

Will be nice to see what you think of Blaze in the future

 

[SupineSnake]

The most active player? In the first post of the game? :/

Lethal wasn't active at all last game so I'm unaware of their general activity.

My b here - was Lethal voting Jeff, mixed if up. Don't know Jeff either, obviously.

 

[Ultra]

How often are opening post votes actually ever anything in the end? Would you say that more times than not the person is scum? Or would you say it’s them hoping to get a reaction to see if they can get someone to slip up?

I can definitely see that. Definitely the reason behind such a quick vote can tell you a little or a lot about a person. I think it’s probably something to keep tucked away in the back of your mind, but it’s not something strong enough on it’s own.

Tbh, voting Jeff would be a smart move for scum, since he’s one of the best players. I agree that lethal and SA probably aren’t aligned, but I definitely think one of them are scum. You want to get the best at scum hunting out of the game as quickly as possible to avoid being detected. Now the question is, which one is scum and which one just voted for him to do so.

^

Brandon seems to be asking Jeff how he should interpret Lethal's posts and asking permission to suspect him, does a lot of hedging and indirectly suggests openers are NAI but then pivots to saying Lethal/SA are scummy when others are talking about it. Don't like.

[Vote lynch Brandon Blaze]

 

[Ultra]

There's a lot of talk about SA being suspect but nobody but Jeff has casted their vote there yet - wonder why?

 

[CakeWalker]

DAY ONE - VOTE COUNT #1

Jeff Valley Driver [2] - Lethal, Sister Abigail
Sister Abigail [1] - Jeff Valley Driver
Blaze [1] - Ultra

WITH TWELVE ALIVE - IT WILL REQUIRE SEVEN VOTES FOR A LYNCH TO OCCUR.

TIME LEFT OF DAY ONE

Counting time since Jul 24, 2023 11:00 am. Showing days, hours, minutes and seconds counting up

www.timeanddate.com

​

 

[Ultra]

For sure. Does feel like you're trying to bog me down in nothing, Sky.

Tbh where I've historically played two votes like that would usually just be people trying to be comedians. Reading everyone analyse two nothing votes felt weird to me. Obviously the meta here is different.

I guess what I'm saying is naturally I'm more inclined to be suspect of those overanalyzing the two votes than those making them.

So where does this leave you?

 

[Comrade Khan]

I like this Ultra guy

 

[Comrade Khan]

For sure. Does feel like you're trying to bog me down in nothing, Sky.

Tbh where I've historically played two votes like that would usually just be people trying to be comedians. Reading everyone analyse two nothing votes felt weird to me. Obviously the meta here is different.

I guess what I'm saying is naturally I'm more inclined to be suspect of those overanalyzing the two votes than those making them.

the two votes on me? why would it be more worrisome to attempt to analyze either votes than making them (especially that one had literally no context)

 

[Hidden Blaze]

This post doesn't make any sense - if Jeff is such a strong player he can be eliminated at night. Furthermore, this feels like a delayed reaction, Blaze doesn't take issue with Lethal's vote until others start talking about it

By the time I woke up people was already questioning it, I can’t take issue if I’m not here

 

[Leon TrotSky]

^

Brandon seems to be asking Jeff how he should interpret Lethal's posts and asking permission to suspect him, does a lot of hedging and indirectly suggests openers are NAI but then pivots to saying Lethal/SA are scummy when others are talking about it. Don't like.

[Vote lynch Brandon Blaze]

Now that you put this together, I really don't like Blaze right now, this is how I feel scum talks around a town player they believe is better than them.

Vote Blaze

 

[Hidden Blaze]

^

Brandon seems to be asking Jeff how he should interpret Lethal's posts and asking permission to suspect him, does a lot of hedging and indirectly suggests openers are NAI but then pivots to saying Lethal/SA are scummy when others are talking about it. Don't like.

[Vote lynch Brandon Blaze]

Yes, but once two people both do it, that’s a little bit sus imo. Maybe more so SA when they came in and saw Lethal already voting for Jeff. I mean yeah it could be nothing, which is why I don’t want to put a vote down for anyone because I’m just building up a case right now and looking for anything that COULD be something