Dungeon & Dragons Mafia - Game Thread [GAME OVER]

[Hidden Blaze]

Is it really that smart though? Let's consider that if you show your hand too soon, you won't earn anyone's trust, and gunning for one of the best players in the game via vote isn't really as good a play as I think you think it is. Most of the time mafia will target the better players at night, so to cut the head off of town early.

Fair enough, I guess that’s a pretty good point. But at the same time, I’ve seen dumb plays actually work as well because of the fact people didn’t think someone would be so dumb to actually try it. Just something to keep in the back of your mind I suppose. I wouldn’t write it off.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Fair enough, I guess that’s a pretty good point. But at the same time, I’ve seen dumb plays actually work as well because of the fact people didn’t think someone would be so dumb to actually try it. Just something to keep in the back of your mind I suppose. I wouldn’t write it off.

Oh trust me, I'm not writing it off completely, just taking into consideration that it's Lethal and SA, two very experienced members of Mafia.

WIFOM this early in the game tho.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I always put more sus on the hanger-ons that the starters, fwiw. I'm not sure scum would actively try to take me out on day one, it's much easier to dirty strong players up with info or just kill them at night. That's usually my philosophy as scum unless a strong player slips and you can pile on the opportunity. If Lethal is scum (hypothetically) I think he just started the wagon for effect and had no intention on actually pushing it.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

which is why I was prying him to see if he would actually try to push that he had a concrete plan, because I would have followed up by calling him a liar had he said yes lol

 

[SupineSnake]

It's not fully a joke though is it? Lethal admitted that there was a purpose, namely to get the game active and serious early

And then said he had no real plan. Was obviously a spam vote. I don't see how a no context vote in the very first post of the game can be considered anything other than a joke.

 

[Ultra]

[Vote lynch Mando]

I have unfinished business with this sussy little slot

 

[Sky]

Yeah that Abigail vote looks awful, latching on to a no-reason D1 vote as if it's a real wagon

 

[SupineSnake]

so if you don't think it was a bit, do you like or dislike Pendex for saying it

Could be leaping on to make something out of nothing, or just misreading the intention. Don't know Pendex enough to say. Will be more interesting/useful after I've seen more of their posts, I'm sure.

 

[Sky]

@Sister Abigail could you clarify your raisins

 

[Sky]

And then said he had no real plan. Was obviously a spam vote. I don't see how a no context vote in the very first post of the game can be considered anything other than a joke.

If your idea is to drag the game out of fluff phase by voting the most active player (like Lethal said), isn't that itself a plan?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

@Sister Abigail could you clarify your raisins

clarify? how about simply providing ANY

 

[Sky]

Idea creeping into my head that this is a really weird scum play with Jeff and SA but I don't feel like being that paranoid atm

 

[Canadian Dragon]

If your idea is to drag the game out of fluff phase by voting the most active player (like Lethal said), isn't that itself a plan?

I feel like you are kind of both arguing over semantics a bit here

 

[Ultra]

on the plus side, Lethal is actually trying to do something, probably more than he's done in the entirety of last game. let's see how he continues to play, Cotton

I like this post, since Jeff has already identified an angle he can attack Lethal's posts from but steps back and evaluates his behavior from another standpoint as well.

trying to work out if pendex' first posts are a bit or not.

What did he mean by this

 

[SupineSnake]

If your idea is to drag the game out of fluff phase by voting the most active player (like Lethal said), isn't that itself a plan?

The most active player? In the first post of the game? :/

Lethal wasn't active at all last game so I'm unaware of their general activity.