Welcome to the Hamptons: Revenge Mafia Game Thread

[RDK]

thanks, just fyi im currently reading back (on page 20 now, dis gon take a bit).

id like to know :

why poyser in your top 3 (i can deduce myself and juice)

also why odo in your own words.

edit: and tweet duh. apologies if you mentioned it in another post but if you can indulge me that be rad.

Poyser A) pointed out char claiming wasn't allowed very early which I think is a townish thing to say in Game Thread, if ur scum I think u just let ur QT know and hope a towny will

I might be giving this too much credit for the reason that I definitely wouldn't have known char claiming wasn't allowed before he said it lol and probably would have full claimed with my duel and been modkilled

Further, I think he was the first to point out that despite Juice being scummy she was showing vast similarities to last game (where she was town), don't think he necessarily does this as scum (I guess unless Juice is also scum but I don't think she is. )

 

[Evans]

Anyways, as one of my confirmed townies, lets catch scum eh~!

pls how be confirmed

 

[Evans]

I agree with the Poyser points too, his push on me has felt natural rather than trying to get a mislynch

 

[Evans]

I disagree that Odo is scum. I think he'd definitely have done something with Juice as a scum team mate.

I believe it was Star Wars mafia, me and Barry were gettin' into a good ole multi page debate and Odo as scum mate intervened for Barry. I think he'd do the same here.

 

[RDK]

pls how be confirmed

I could caption about 10-20 of her posts of even more with the word "clueless" and I generally associate cluelessness with town because a game is hard to understand as town.

The flip definitely clouds that a little but not enough to change my mind on her.

Also agree with what someone said about her probably being reigned in by a team as scum.

She also just vibes too much like last game for me to doubt she is town

 

[Odo]

Likeliest town, I’d say Jeff, Tweet, and juice. Can’t imagine juice being scum and I find reading good active players very easy, neither of you have pinged me at all so

likeliest scum, I’d say Joe, and then CPs posts look designedto incite other people than actually do anything himself. I’ve still got my hunch on Chris too, and I think he’s doing just enough to skate by. This is why evans and juice constantly ranting is a problem cause it gives scum plenty of cloud cover

 

[Odo]

I don’t really care about being sussed per se but I’m really struggling to see how you think my play in this game resembles any scum game I have on record lmao

 

[RDK]

I disagree that Odo is scum. I think he'd definitely have done something with Juice as a scum team mate.

I believe it was Star Wars mafia, me and Barry were gettin' into a good ole multi page debate and Odo as scum mate intervened for Barry. I think he'd do the same here.

Agree on Odo but he along with me should take most responsibility for that flip and I'm not going to scum read myself

 

[Evans]

Chris - Pretty happy still with my Chris town read from earlier on, his additional posts since then haven't changed anything for me.
CraigPelton - Baity, TMI posts about me being right, it's happened before. This is definitely a gut/meta read.
JoeExotic - With Juice's scum flip inevitable, I think this makes Joe more likely to be town from her posts
Juice - Inconsistencies, TMI with 100% town reads, not scum hunting as much as last game, more concerned about setting JoeExotic for a lynch.
Hank
Odo - pretty confident this is town Odo, the cause for light blue to dark blue change is because of my post above re: Star Wars mafia with Barry
Poyser - agree with points above + his pushes and posts have felt natural to me, plus he's been mean to me, normally sign of a town Poyser
Alco - pretty confident Alco is town, not much else to add from my previous reads list.
Raidokken - same as before, feels like town Haza, the previous points made about the duel I still stand by
Death Meta Knight - not much has changed here, the post about not giving a free pass turned this from light blue to dark for me.

I think likely scum team then will be in:
Phenom
MyPrerogative
Doddsy
Tweet
Lethal Banks
Carter
Rugrat
Kajuh

 

[Evans]

NINJA'd, I'm gonna edit the above post to reflect my town lean as Haza answered my question as I was typing that out ^

 

[Evans]

Also agree with what someone said about her probably being reigned in by a team as scum.

I can see your points and 0 point in debating any further to try and change your mind.

But this part of the post here:
What if her scum team are inactives?

How does that change your thinking?

 

[RDK]

I can see your points and 0 point in debating any further to try and change your mind.

But this part of the post here:
What if her scum team are inactives?

How does that change your thinking?

Kind of a stupid question lol, it would obviously moot the point

 

[Odo]

Agree on Odo but he along with me should take most responsibility for that flip and I'm not going to scum read myself

why would being wrong on a player lead to a scum read?

 

[Evans]

sigh.

 

[Odo]

I’d like folks to elaborate on Poyser too. I’m getting a very strange, almost indy vibe. I don’t really want to explain it just yet, but I want it on record