Throwback Music Mafia [Game Thread]

[Evans]

Why?

If it's a fake claim, he came up with it pretty quick. If it's his real role, it doesn't tell us a lot as it can be either alignment.

I probably would claim immediately as well if someone pitted me in a duel with them, just because I expect most players not to fake it.

It’s a meta read based on Barry’s previous reluctance to claim previously.

I understand your point re: quick to claim. I don’t think it’s beyond the realm of possibility that Barry could be an investigative scum role and watcher is a fakeable claim.

I disagree about claiming immediately, the duel wasn’t even confirmed. Nor as my pal (are we pals?) @Tweet pointed out - it isn’t a guaranteed kill on Barry. So why the anger or panic?

I look God awful on this duel, I don’t think it’s a natural town reaction, nor does it track with town Barry who I think would hit me with a heston and be patronising about how wrong I apparently am (in a fun way ofc)

 

[Evans]

To add to that last paragraph as I’m a blueberry who sent too early - I look god awful on this duel. I don’t see scum being flapped by it like Barry appears to be.

 

[Smart Marx]

Duel Barry

@Poyser @The Great One



like this is how sure I am

Barry has been challenged to a duel and he cannot decline. This runs alongside the lynch. Please vote for who you want to win.

The person who has the most votes at the end of the day will win and the loser will die. In the event of a tie, Chevy will win.

 

[Evans]

@The Great One will earlier duel votes count or will they need to revote?

 

[Curry]

Welp. Don't have huge leans either way but T/T seems likeliest so saving the Watcher.

Vote Barry to win the duel

 

[Smart Marx]

@The Great One will earlier duel votes count or will they need to revote?

I'll count them as I do my vote count update next.

 

[Evans]

Welp. Don't have huge leans either way but T/T seems likeliest so saving the Watcher.

Vote Barry to win the duel

Fancy a read? (As in for you to read, I’m not giving you a game read)

 

[Evans]

I didn't say any specific game, I was referring to his meta as town.



No, it is not more bold to fake info as scum than it is to fake info as town.

Scum you are working with a team and are faking for a logical reason.

When Flay fakes its because "lol i think person x is scum so let me get them lynched by faking info and if they're town then woops"

Faking information as scum is the name of the game though. God knows I've been a victim of town Flay faking info.

It's not *bold* to fake info as scum. It's a calculated move that has inherent risk.

Town Flay would happily bury another player with fake information just to continue his agenda and not even blink twice about it. Essentially, Scum Flay is far more often telling the truth while Town Flay will inherently lie to push narratives and get his man.

Interesting!

 

[Curry]

Fancy a read? (As in for you to read, I’m not giving you a game read)

Don't think I understand the question here

 

[Smart Marx]

I’m not lynching a watcher

vote Barry to win

Vote Barry to win

vote Grim to win.

I don't know if this will count or we'll have to re-vote again but I guess I might as well do it for now.

Welp. Don't have huge leans either way but T/T seems likeliest so saving the Watcher.

Vote Barry to win the duel

Day 1 Vote Count

Ace (6) - Odo, Curry, T-Pein, The Fourth Wall, Alco, PHEN0M
The Fourth Wall (1) - Flay
T-Pein (1) - Lethal Banks
Doddsy (1) - Tweet
Rugrat (2) - CraigPelton, Grimus Augustus

With 17 alive, it’s 9 to lynch.

Duel Standings on Who's Winning

Barry (4) - Odo, Rugrat, The Fourth Wall, Curry

​

 

[Evans]

I've mentioned that I'm fine with a Rugrat wagon so I'll join the cause and help out.

unvote

Vote: Rugrat

As I mentioned yesterday, there isn't a reason to have Blaine as town, but Rugrat definitely feels scummy to me so that could help my read on the lad.

Why are you reading Blaine town off so little? There's literally zero reason to be reading him town, at all. role soft or not, Blaine does that as either alignment.




It hasn't though? Most of the thread don't know how to read him at the moment and nobody feels comfortable with him at all.

I've also been reading Blaine town off of very little, why are we pushing Rugrat and not me?

Did you vote him and then "lol he's town" and unvote?

Why would voting a player and gaining their reaction for a read be scummy? But Tweet not voting isn’t.

Peculiar!

 

[Tweet]

Sure we're pals

I'm still not lynching the claimed Watcher d1

 

[Tweet]

vote Barry to win

 

[Evans]

Sure we're pals

I'm still not lynching the claimed Watcher d1

Of course I’d never ask you to just vote with me because of that! I just wanted to know

 

[Evans]

Don't think I understand the question here

Are you up for reading some old posts to try and understand my point of view for why Barry is 92% scum?