The best Movie in your opinion , which no one agrees on .

[Mr.Mayhem]

hello

I am kinda new here , so pardon me if there are posts with same subject .


In my opinion . Fight Club is one of the most intelligent , clever , dark movie with an ending which will turn you upside down . But the main thing which sticks out is its message . It shows the truth of our materialistic society which blindly follow what we are told too .

Anyway thats my opinion . What do you y'll think .

 

[Kiffy Lube]

Children of the Corn 5: Fields of Terror.

You said that no one agrees with so I went with this. I know tons of people that love Fight Club. I could have went with the first Children of the Corn but decided to dig deeper.

 

[Mr.Mayhem]

Children of the Corn 5: Fields of Terror.

You said that no one agrees with so I went with this. I know tons of people that love Fight Club. I could have went with the first Children of the Corn but decided to dig deeper.

there is a reason , they call fight club a " a cult classic ".

A lot of people like it . But dont really consider it as one of the best of all time

 

[Dademo]

American Beauty. I think it's one of the top 5 films ever made. Most people agree with me that it's a great film, but that it's not even top 20.

 

[Crippler]

DIE HARD

 

[Pete]

City of God
Slumdog Millionaire
Brokeback Mountain

 

[Keith]

1. The flaw with Fight Club is with the twist, maybe it works better in the novel, but it is just much to buy in the film. But yeah I think it is a great film, just such a radical piece of filmmaking.

2. Everyone loves Die Hard, so I don't get that one?

3. Slumdog is def overated, the other two also, but maybe less so.

American Beauty is a wonderful film, not least because it was the directors debut (doubt he will ever better it), however top five best ever it isn't.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

No thoughts on Children of the Corn 5?

 

[Keith]

Sorry I only saw up to three, light weight I know lol.

 

[Pete]

How is Slumdog overrated when most people seem to hate it?

I got Children of The Corn 1 (for free) but have yet to see it. Stephen King movies are usually shit (apart from Stand By Me), so I'm not expecting greatness.

 

[Lewb]

I guess I'll go for Constantine. The hatred for Keanu Reeves is just too much for most people, but I just see a brilliant film.

 

[Keith]

How is Slumdog overrated when most people seem to hate it?I got Children of The Corn 1 (for free) but have yet to see it. Stephen King movies are usually shit (apart from Stand By Me), so I'm not expecting greatness.

That doesn't really work as a counter agruement because clearly I don't think that most people hate it, you have to back up your claim. From my point of view, it swept the board at the 2009 Oscars, was a big box office hit and a lot of people who have not seen Danny Boyle's smaller movies see it as a great feel good movie. I think it is another one like the Dark Knight where it was always going to be impossible to live up to the hype, TDK is a better film mind.

 

[The Cork]

Lost In Translation is the ultimate marmite movie.

Some critics swear by it, others think it's a turd with a cheap ending.

 

[Pete]

A lot of non-critics I've come across bash Slumdog as predictable, not that good, cheesy, etc...

I guess it comes down to opinion. I've watched most Danny Boyle movies and the only one I didn't like was 127 Hours, because I felt it was showy and lacked substance. Trainspotting is among my favourite movies to this day, and The Beach wasn't half bad either. I also liked what I've seen of Shallow Grave.

 

[Slim]

The beach actually wasn't that bad. I kinda enjoyed it. Not one that I'd pick up off the shelf and watch all the time... but it is a different movie.

For me... hmmmm

Xmen 3... for me it ranks up there cause it was just actiony
I would also agree with American Beauty... I liked it.
Not sure what else coming to mind at the moment.