Save the Cheerleader, Save the World: Heroes Mafia Game Thread

[RDK]

This is a very bad way to try and twist my post.

You didn’t to either, I was just building into my reasoning kiddo

Yes I didn't. And like I said already, until there is a counter (doesn't have to be BG), town is going to have standard protection.

 

[Evans]

Okay Haza

 

[Evans]

I’ll happily lynch the claimed bodyguard too, just to make sure that’s clear and not open to interpretation as well.

What gives you this level of conviction this early?

 

[PHEN0M]

What gives you this level of conviction this early?

Im feeling myself EV. I get the same vibe from him i did when he was last scum with how he’s posting and i was killed before i could do anything about it.

 

[Poyser]

vote big man

 

[Evans]

Im feeling myself EV. I get the same vibe from him i did when he was last scum with how he’s posting and i was killed before i could do anything about it.

Okay. What if you are wrong?

Do you really think lynching Gambit off a vibe this early is an optimal town play? Risk v reward chances etc

 

[Roy Mustang]

Im feeling myself EV. I get the same vibe from him i did when he was last scum with how he’s posting and i was killed before i could do anything about it.

So you want to lynch the town bodyguard off a vibe? Vote: Phenom

 

[PHEN0M]

There’s a lot of other people playing, you can ignore my read if you’re not feeling it.

 

[PHEN0M]

Okay. What if you are wrong?

Do you really think lynching Gambit off a vibe this early is an optimal town play? Risk v reward chances etc

Then I’m wrong, won’t be the first tim, won’t be the last.

 

[Big Man]

what is this based on? Do you feel this would outweigh the benefit afforded by claiming a top tier role?

I suppose it depends on how badly you need that benefit. if there is a strong case on you and likely to be lynched then you claim it, but you're just buying a bit of extra time imo because if there's another strong protection claim there's a good chance they will start hinting at it/push you hard depending on the player or if there's 2 weaker ones it just takes one to claim and the other will start hinting at it.

 

[TKOK]

this was only 4 pages long when I begun reading

 

[Evans]

There’s a lot of other people playing, you can ignore my read if you’re not feeling it.

I’m interested the thoughts around your read though. I do think Gambits play has been more in tune with his AEW scum performance than his town showings, but I don’t know Gambits meta well enough to suggest if that is a proper tell or not.

The BG claim as well is obviously a gamble that could be detrimental to town, losing protection that early.

 

[Junkette]

Off topic: how do I change posts per page?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Off topic: how do I change posts per page?

unfortunately the one feature we were unable to add here

 

[Junkette]

I don’t see the gamble based on another players hunch being wise so I’m not gonna lynch the bodyguard claim on day one especially since I wasn’t even on board the original wagon.

i still feel like PHENOM is faking this conviction cause he knows he has too as scum, taking it back altogether would look downright atrocious