No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Just Juice]

I never said neutral was leaning town side.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Only two people I don't have a read on.

I don't really know what you are talking about really.

How are having people as neutral a read on them?

 

[Just Juice]

I've explained my definition of neutral numerous times. Null is those that I can't place. Neutral are those that I'm not sure if they are town or scum. And like Sky was a town read - but then was moved into Neutral.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Uh, if my memory doesn't fail me, I'm pretty sure I was asked? Can't remember by whom. Anyway, it was a topic of discussion and I felt the angle fairly obvious, there doesn't need to be any extra motive assigned to my comments than that.
Excelt where I haven't ignored scummy behaviour? You know, where I broke down why it was the least optimal shot for him to make as scum there, which is why I think he's town? If you want me to remove that for a second and give you reasons why he's town, well I don't have those. His play has been fairly apathetic and dare I say, lazy, this in spite of having over 100 posts. Trying to get anything out of him is laborious work.

I don't need him to show remorse though, I'm not sure why that's the standard he must be held to here. He took a shot he obviously felt was justified - it didn't pan out. If he's scum I actually think he'd be more likely to play to the apologetic angle for what it's worth, too.

So basically you read Barry as town because him killing Tpein was suboptimal?

 

[Just Juice]

I mean at this point your just being annoyed with formatting of how I layout my reads on a chart

 

[Mandalorian]

My biggest concern at the moment is Man & Leila as why would you go through all that in a night phase? I'm expecting both to be on the same side though.

Grim is too obvious...but is it too obvious for it to end up being true?

I need to take some more time to go through the John stuff again.

Why not? Juice has contradicted herself massively and placed herself above suspicion for reasons that I don’t think many share.

Quite a strange comment to make to be honest.

 

[Just Juice]

I'd offer another analogy - but it will just be received negatively.

 

[Just Juice]

Contradicted? Kekw

 

[Pendex]

I never said neutral was leaning town side.

I'll come back to this. If I'm wrong I'll concede.

So basically you read Barry as town because him killing Tpein was suboptimal?

Suboptimal when he could easily have killed me and it would have been more consistent with his reads meaning he gets less flak for it. He would also have McHenry who would look pretty bad off my town flip too due to his vote which was the worst of my small wagon, so yes.

 

[Mandalorian]

Contradicted? Kekw

Oh so you having two players as null and then claiming that you read them as town isn’t a contradiction then?

 

[Pendex]

I don't know what side of town they are - so neutral.

Here we go. "I don't know what side of town they are" implies some form of town lean to me, no?

 

[Pendex]

Null are the ones - I just have no idea at all about anything

And here is what would otherwise be considered neutral.

 

[Just Juice]

Oh so you having two players as null and then claiming that you read them as town isn’t a contradiction then?

Still at the gym? Or just not bothering to do this deep dive?

 

[Just Juice]

Here we go. "I don't know what side of town they are" implies some form of town lean to me, no?

The Town - The Village is the body of the players.

 

[Pendex]

The Town - The Village is the body of the players.

So when you say the "town", you didn't mean the town, but the players as a whole. Gotcha. So why make a distinction between Neutral and Null at all then?