Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Comrade Khan]

Yea a read isn't a lynch

 

[Poyser]

When will town learn that letting Poyser lead town never leads to anything good, regardless of alignment.

When I’m town and lead town, we tend to win bud

 

[CakeWalker]

All I am getting from this - is two of our mods have massive egos. And really don't like losing.

 

[Poyser]

My day one reads were Jeff, Chloe and Lethal - I was 2/3 on Day 1. I don't think town was destroyed - let be real know.

Yeah having correct reads is one thing - the hard part is getting them lynched lol

 

[Rugrat]

I don’t think we were destroyed, I’m happy to say scum were better.

we lynched the survivor and would have lynched Jeff the other day. I don’t think it’s guaranteed Kajuh gets lynched either as people had Alco high in PoE too

 

[Comrade Khan]

I don’t think we were destroyed, I’m happy to say scum were better.

we lynched the survivor and would have lynched Jeff the other day. I don’t think it’s guaranteed Kajuh gets lynched either as people had Alco high in PoE too

Fair

 

[RDK]

All I am getting from this - is two of our mods have massive egos. And really don't like losing.

Who likes losing lol

 

[Poyser]

I don’t think we were destroyed, I’m happy to say scum were better.

we lynched the survivor and would have lynched Jeff the other day. I don’t think it’s guaranteed Kajuh gets lynched either as people had Alco high in PoE too

I think it’s pretty guaranteed, we only needed 2 extra votes to get the win lol

 

[Ace]

I don’t know if you’re missing the point or not here. It was the janitor that gave us the mislynch on kajuh because you didn’t flip Mason - he was claiming to be Mason with you - ergo he might be lying. If you just flipped Mason this obviously doesn’t happen right? Like the problem is directly that the janitor and reviver were together and it did break the game, along with you still getting a cop result you never should have received

It didn't break the game. It would have broken the game if someone had claimed cop and then I came back and said actually know, I was cop. As it stands, it just meant I came back and vouched for a townie. The same would have happened if, say, I had copped Blaine and got a town read. I would have had extra information that otherwise would not have been the case.

I'm not agreeing with a reviver role but I'm just saying it wasn't gamebreaking, it was just annoying for you guys that the mislynch you had banked on (it wasn't even confirmed that Kajuh was getting lynched but anyway) got taken away.

Because we don't tend to have revivers I honestly don't know what the order would usually be in terms of me getting my result.

 

[Poyser]

But yeah I don’t think destroyed is the right word, but we were definitely better and heading to a pretty simple win. Even if alco did get lynched, pretty sure I could have got the mislynch the following day

 

[Comrade Khan]

N I mean ya poyser n I distancing was pretty damn good imo

 

[Poyser]

It didn't break the game. It would have broken the game if someone had claimed cop and then I came back and said actually know, I was cop. As it stands, it just meant I came back and vouched for a townie. The same would have happened if, say, I had copped Blaine and got a town read. I would have had extra information that otherwise would not have been the case.

I'm not agreeing with a reviver role but I'm just saying it wasn't gamebreaking, it was just annoying for you guys that the mislynch you had banked on (it wasn't even confirmed that Kajuh was getting lynched but anyway) got taken away.

Because we don't tend to have revivers I honestly don't know what the order would usually be in terms of me getting my result.

Lol you’re just completely wrong but I’m not really gonna keep going at it

 

[Ace]

Town mislynched every phase...

I mean we were going to lynch you and then you fucking exploded and got a free kill on a townie so while you may technically be correct, it's disingenuous to frame it as such.

Lets not pretend Alco wasn't at the top with Kajuh on many people's scumread lists either.

Poyser could have actually survived and won but I guess he didn't think so.

 

[Laughable Chimp]

Scum weren't great. Town were worse though. We lost because we let Poyser control the agenda and the only other people who could combat that died early(Magic) were not town(Doddsy) or decided to lead a random mislynch on a townie and was going to lead town into another one(CP)

 

[RDK]

Mvp: Barry imo