Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[Rugrat]

Lock it up imo.

Thanks for hosting Blaine and sorry about the finale

Why? There’s no flaming, it’s just discussing ideas lol

 

[TOP GUY TIME]

I’d put the blame on Smark and Haza in this case tbh

Blaming them is stupid.

 

[CakeWalker]

Blaine you are a first time host - you've literally done nothing wrong.

 

[Poyser]

All I know is I wasn't in the deadqt but can't speak for others.


Yes but that's just you disliking a reviver role, it's got nothing to do with the problem of being able to revive a janitored target, just your problem with revivers in general. Which may be valid but that's a personal preference thing.

Same with the PGO. You really shouldn't assume these things from a new host and I have certainly heard of PGO's being unlimited shots - they can still be lynched.

Anyway to suggest you couldn't have still won is silly to me, I had no cop shots since I was VT and while I had you as a scum read, you may well have been able to convince town as a whole otherwise.

I understand you may be frustrated if there were botches/imbalances but this all feels a bit harsh to just executively decide to end the game of a new host because you don't feel like fighting to the end.

No lol, the reason we could lynch kajuh based on not being your Mason is directly cos of the janitor....

 

[RDK]

Why? There’s no flaming, it’s just discussing ideas lol

It's the same shit being said and nobody is thanking Blaine for putting weeks of his time into a game for them to play. What's the point lol

 

[Ace]

Revivers and janitors can never ever exist together. Period

Like I love you ace, but the game was 100% broken lel

I didn't agree with any of this.

 

[Laughable Chimp]

Why is Juice mothering Blaine? Giving me Titania vibes.

Anyway someone post the dead qt please.

 

[Laughable Chimp]

Don't make me ask twice.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I’d put the blame on Smark and Haza in this case tbh

Nah, haza had 1h in am to look over n cut a bunch . Smark was helping w vote counts. Its just a bummer situation overall

 

[Rugrat]

Thanks for the game, Blaine!

 

[Poyser]

I feel like we took the majority of the shite this game in pretty good stride tbh, didnt bitch at all. But the revive and cp not dying and ace getting his cop result on alco was just the final straw lol. And like I said, the revive just shut the door on our path to victory so I don’t really feel bad about conceding

 

[CakeWalker]

For a first time host - it had really complex ideas and on a creative basis it reminded me of some of my earlier games that I used to run. People should of just let the game play out - and then talking about how to improve it in the post game.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I didn't agree with any of this.

Well u should lol

 

[Ace]

No lol, the reason we could lynch kajuh based on not being your Mason is directly cos of the janitor....

I mean yeah but that could go for any revive, the person could come up with a report they hadn't disclosed previously that changes the face of the game. It's kind of the point of the role.

I'm not saying i like revivers or that jan/revivers make sense. but in this game the effects weren't nearly as badly pronounced as could have been and honestly a lot of it was 'working as intended' (like a revived person having information thought to be hidden in the graveyard. [This is why they become vanilla to reduce their powers if they had any].)

 

[Rugrat]

Let’s stick it in the records I’m 3-0 as town this year