Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Smart Marx]

Offcial Unvote: Not Brutus

A Demo God Production of Skywalker Saga Mafia
The surviving members of the resistance face the First Order once again,
and the legendary conflict between the Jedi and the Sith reaches its peak bringing the Skywalker saga to its end.

Midday 1 Vote Count

E-V (1) - Ace Dalton
Odo (3) - CraigPelton, Poyser, Tweet
Jeff Valley Driver (1) - PHEN0M
Ace Dalton (2) - Lethal Banks
NotBrutus (2) - Odo, Jeff Valley Driver
Grim Cornette (1) - E-V

With 18 players remaining in the game, it takes 10 votes to reach a lynch.

Day 1 will end on Monday, Aug 31st, at 7:00 PM ET.​

 

[Comrade Khan]

unvote
vote odo

 

[CraigPelton]

Wow pretty sure last I checked Tweet was voting me and now he's convincing people I'm town and to vote who I want to vote Nice

 

[Comrade Khan]

for the record, while I may have originally read Odo as town, and I'm not convinced of his intentions being nafarious atm, I have enough reasons to read the leaders of said wagon town (nor do I find the push on odo stinky). It's also not lost upon me I my early reads were off last game, and that Poyser was the correct one. Given that he's pushing this, and upon relexion and reading back, CP's case does have some legs (not to mention, I also like his point on barry, a lot, as I still would prefer to lynch barry atm over anyone)

 

[Comrade Khan]

Tweet prob town too in the end, last two games, as the day went on, he lost his smile and the will the play. even before poyser returned to bitch at me. Here, yes he did get sassy and tunelly, BUT, he didn't just fold or act defeated at the first sign of push back.

 

[CraigPelton]

What was my point on Barry?

 

[Kiffy Lube]

I still have no idea who to vote for after all of this. Sumthin' does need to happen so we don't end with a no-lynch though. Too much speculation and back-trackin' is doin' my head in.

 

[Poyser]

If I thought itd make any difference, id consider answering

Lmao what? Of course it makes a difference. There’s a big difference between a throwaway vote in his 4th post as opposed to here where he’s made a case on you and kept pushing it. So yeah I’d say it makes a bit of a difference with regards to my point, that’s why I asked

 

[Alco]

Oh boy, looks like I missed a ton of the juicy stuff!

Quick rundown of the Odo case while I attempt a readback?

 

[Alco]

A claim isn't a reason to lynch you, your play in general is. However a good enough claim can be a good way to dissuade that.

The timing of this is odd Dude's barely made 2 posts at this point.

 

[Ace]

I'm back and honestly most of this stuff feels like running in circles, but:

Odo is not necessarily arguing poorly, but my experience is that he'd be a bit more aggressive and... rude?... although I'm nervous to go all in on this read given era. I wouldn't be against lynching him but I'm not completely sold on him being scum - although the lean is in that direction.

Poyser feels fine. Not much more to say.

I'm actually going to retract my earlier read on CP - while I definitely have experienced him being laid back and trolly as town, and the inverse as maf, there is clearly something different in this game vs last game in how he is posting. If others can confirm that CP actually has a history of playing properly and getting involved as town, I'm actually willing to give him a town lean.

Jeff - null. He's active and getting involved but nothing has really stood out to me either way.

EV - Also willing to pull out of my earlier read a bit as I think his return has been fine (and not because he was nice to me ) - it feels like a town move.
Regardless of what is meta here I'm inclined to not vote out a tracker d1 - the possibility of a maf tracker is noted but that doesn't mean I'm willing to play that roulette game. Still keeping an eye on EV though.

Tweet - Meh. Still think posting has been okay I guess. also just ftr the whole Tweet OP sarcasm shit is a non-argument as it was slightly ambiguous when I read it but clearly not a slip of any kind so meeeeeeh.

Unvote

As it stands I honestly don't know who I'd want to lynch. I'd be okay with Odo, Barry maybe but tbph I'm not convinced on anyone. Not very helpful I know and I'm sure I'll be accused of fencesitting for this read list but hey ho.

I would like to see guys like Big Man and Alco, who have recently reared their heads, giving more feedback.

 

[Alco]

Yoda - Commuter/Hider, x-shot.

Let's go.

 

[Ace]

Also a side note is that if people think Barry is scum I wouldn't be against lynching a commuter/hider claim.

Obviously the role has some value but there are worse roles to hit with a mislynch on d1 if Barry turns out to be town.

 

[Poyser]

Didn’t even realise tweet was sus of cp lmao

 

[Poyser]

It’s why Poysers point makes no sense - like I’m allowed to question you in the interrogative and gauge your answers without condemning you to death

Nah my point is more about you being soft which you’re not usually. Like you were putting him under fire from a post perspective but you never used your vote which is unlike you and instead kept it parked on mitch for reasons you haven’t explained other than “it had a purpose” and now you’re probably gonna say the purpose is you town read him for “no selling” you which just seems like bullshit to me