Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Alco]

Vote: TKOK

@Demo God

This seems kinda weird given the things going on in the thread at the time.

 

[Alco]

That's me!!

Oh okay, carry on

 

[Ace]

I’m not going to invest any time into the game today, and whilst I didn’t really want to claim cause of my role, it seems I don’t have a real choice

I’m a detective - basically a gunsmith but with a caveat which I’ll clarify later

hence my immediate suspicion of Barry

Maybe I'm being dumb but why can't a gunsmith and a hider be in the same game? I know they're both investigative but they have pretty different outcomes.

I'm guessing you're on that same train as Poyser in that you don't think there will be multiple investigative roles, which I don't agree with but at the very least seems to be a perception shared by others (ie Poyser) who know how setups usually work here.

Not sure what the point is of hiding the caveat but w/e.

 

[Kiffy Lube]

I'm gonna vote now since I may not be on when the 48 hour window is over. I was favorin' Jeff over Tweet durin' the early part. So I'll go Jeff for now. If I get on and see more information, I'll change my vote then.

vote: Jeff

 

[Odo]

Maybe I'm being dumb but why can't a gunsmith and a hider be in the same game? I know they're both investigative but they have pretty different outcomes.

I'm guessing you're on that same train as Poyser in that you don't think there will be multiple investigative roles, which I don't agree with but at the very least seems to be a perception shared by others (ie Poyser) who know how setups usually work here.

Not sure what the point is of hiding the caveat but w/e.

they can be, but there’s overlap. The OP advises of that too, so it’s a case of weighing it up

Theres 100% a point to hiding it, I guess you’re gonna have to trust me on that one

 

[Ace]

they can be, but there’s overlap. The OP advises of that too, so it’s a case of weighing it up

Yep. Certainly not cut-and-dry.

Theres 100% a point to hiding it, I guess you’re gonna have to trust me on that one

You seem to want us to ignore things and just trust you on quite a bit, lol. Eg Brutus vote and now this. I struggle to believe there is so much nuance to these things.

 

[Ace]

Just as a side note, we literally had day and night cops last game which was much smaller so playing the "not more than one investigative role" card feels a bit excessive.

 

[Odo]

Yep. Certainly not cut-and-dry.

You seem to want us to ignore things and just trust you on quite a bit, lol. Eg Brutus vote and now this. I struggle to believe there is so much nuance to these things.

Well consider that there’s no personal benefit to me even revealing its existence in the first place?

 

[Odo]

Just as a side note, we literally had day and night cops last game which was much smaller so playing the "not more than one investigative role" card feels a bit excessive.

 

[Ace]

Well consider that there’s no personal benefit to me even revealing its existence in the first place?

Gives you something in the bag down the line maybe? But this is actually a fair point overall.

Words, please.

 

[Odo]

Like what tho? It’s a restriction. If I’m scum, my first goal is to get out of this phase alive, so I’d be better served just claiming pure gunsmith. In a world where I’m faking, if someone cc’s me, it’s not like I’m going to be able to transition safely away lol

Your other point doesn’t deserve words, but sure ok. Firstly I’m not the guy setting parameters over what is or isn’t in the game, that’s Poyser. I said like 2 posts ago that it’s a case of weighing it up, but there’s overlap there. I’d this an unfair conclusion to come to or what?

 

[Odo]

More votes on Brutus please

 

[Ace]

Your other point doesn’t deserve words, but sure ok. Firstly I’m not the guy setting parameters over what is or isn’t in the game, that’s Poyser. I said like 2 posts ago that it’s a case of weighing it up, but there’s overlap there. I’d this an unfair conclusion to come to or what?

I never addressed my post to you though? I literally agreed with you in the previous post that it's not cut and dry, lmao.

 

[Odo]

Just as a side note, we literally had day and night cops last game which was much smaller so playing the "not more than one investigative role" card feels a bit excessive.

so er why this

 

[Odo]

Oh you were just saying it to nobody in particular, I see