Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Tweet]

Also Evans if you want my opinion, I think you gradually switching sides on this reeks of holding your flag in the wind and going with the flow of the thread.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Thing is I don't necessarily buy either of you even asking why Odo read me town, when his posts up to that point were clear on more than one occasion why he did. Neither of you are dyslexic, so one can assume you had read those posts already, and are only asking to make conversation

 

[Poyser]

I also don't believe for a second that Jeff suddenly sees the need to come up with fancy traps when his regular playstyle has served him well recently, in fact it's more reminiscent of what he's done as scum in the past, see WS Mafia Reloaded.

I don’t hate this

 

[Poyser]

My role would come out eventually and it's a good utility role for town so it being out in the open is a good thing, in my opinion at least.

No

 

[Evans]

Evans I literally explained to you why I said the things I said about Barrys claim and here you are asking about the same issue again. Like I can't do anything other than refer you to the post I made yesterday where you seemed to get what I was talking about.

Well considering I've made a new point and you've either not read the post or you're misdirecting it here as leading me back to a conversation we had last night when the new point came about from something Odo mentioned doesn't help at all.

1) Can you explain why a hider/commuter is an investigative role?

2) I believe that you'd be looking for Barry to prove the role as a townie as opposed to joking around about lynching him and backing over yourself when questioned over joke posts that you made, especially as an investigative role.

 

[Poyser]

Though I will say I thought Jeff’s point on barry was a GOOD UN as well

 

[Poyser]

I disagree over the nod being as suggestive as you're implying but I do agree about the claim.

Considering Barry is usually quite defiant in his claims, looking back at Magic: The Gathering that Haza hosted. He refused to claim informed town (although if he revealed the info, he'd die). I'm perplexed by his non-chalant claiming commuter/hider for the utility of town when he's not done this before.

 

[Odo]

Well considering I've made a new point and you've either not read the post or you're misdirecting it here as leading me back to a conversation we had last night when the new point came about from something Odo mentioned doesn't help at all.

1) Can you explain why a hider/commuter is an investigative role?

2) I believe that you'd be looking for Barry to prove the role as a townie as opposed to joking around about lynching him and backing over yourself when questioned over joke posts that you made, especially as an investigative role.

Hider is investigative as if you use it and survived, it typically means you targeted a townie

 

[Comrade Khan]

unvote
vote e-v

 

[Chris]

I didn't really like Jeff for his trap/vote reaction play early on but after reading through, I think he'd have been more erratic if he was scum and thought he fucked up off a play like that (see WWE Jobbers which was already mentioned), and he's been pretty calm and focused here. Could be an improvement but idk I think he's town.

 

[Poyser]

It doesn't help that I don't agree with your conclusion that Barry might be scum, I'm leaning the opposite way for the time being.

Did tweet ever elaborate on this

 

[Evans]

Thing is I don't necessarily buy either of you even asking why Odo read me town, when his posts up to that point were clear on more than one occasion why he did. Neither of you are dyslexic, so one can assume you had read those posts already, and are only asking to make conversation

What specifically has given you firm town feelings? I've seen your post about 92 posts and none setting off alarm bells, but anything specifically you've looked at and gone "yup, that's town to me"?

A good number of Jeffs posts were arguments over whether Tweet read the OP or not amongst other odd things. Whilst a highly active Jeff is usually indicative of town Jeff, his posts usually carry more substance than an unnecessary amount of bickering with Tweet and not much direction against his actual vote target (although Barry disappeared immediately after his claim, so it's hard to say what else he could have done lol)

You even quoted this post to use against me, Jeff. Clearly they weren't clear enough for me or I wouldn't have mentioned the bolded?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Still don't love Tweet, but the timing in which EV just pivoted, unvoted, but STILL isn't voting to add pressure. I hates it

 

[Lethal]

Flag holding is a brilliant new gameplay observation.

Tweet, Jeff, please either vote each other or move on with the game. You're looking like the vintage Lethal/Sky exchanges, and we are being PALS remember.

No buys on my Ace sentiments

 

[Poyser]

His attitude seems to be more in line with how he behaves as town, like he seems pretty impudent and not very amicable. There's also obviously his claim, which... frankly puzzles me cause it's a good role and I got no idea why he would just out it with no pressure on him whatsoever. But at the very least I'm not about to lynch the Hider today.

You think his town meta is not being very amicable but claiming as soon as he gets votes and nodding along to others’ cases makes him..... town?