Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Canadian Dragon]

 

[Canadian Dragon]

oh ill bug u again @Odo , thoughts on CP. specifically, tweets read on him. I want to know if there's any validity there

 

[Lethal]

It may seem unimportant to you but to other players your posts and explanations behind your thought processes is helpful

This was in reply to Tweets. I like it

 

[Lethal]

^ this was aimed at Odo

Of course. I'd be suspicious of you if you'd given me that seemingly solid town read

 

[Odo]

oh ill bug u again @Odo , thoughts on CP. specifically, tweets read on him. I want to know if there's any validity there

Er, I want to talk to him about it first

 

[Odo]

Its a good job I think youre town Jeff, Im very sceptical of anyone giving me the thumbs up on Day 1 lol

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Its a good job I think youre town Jeff, Im very sceptical of anyone giving me the thumbs up on Day 1 lol

I'm seeing the exact same approach as last game so far. I suppose it could generous this early on, but as I said, you also haven't made any posts to make me think otherwise.

 

[Odo]

@PHEN0M

What are your thoughts early doors?

 

[Lethal]

Big time Lethal play here:

Vote: Ace Dalton

Yeah I'm getting a nice town read from Tweet - whether he's right or wrong, the way he's arguing shows that these are actual thoughts rather than fabrications.

Jeff could go either way, not really willing to drop a read as I think it's too lazy to scumread Jeff off the exchange by virtue of Tweet being a town read. Being all over the shop is hardly unusual for Jeff after all ( )

Willing to give lethal a town pass for now. Seems comfortable in-thread and I'm okay with the claim too.

Tbph I haven't liked Shania Twain, I'm not going to get into meta arguments or anything but the damsel in distress ploy hasn't felt good at all.

Also a shit ton of filler like:

"More Drake & Josh gifs please "
"I like a good trap... oh wait not that kind of trap."
"I'm tryin' to figure out what has happened in the last 2 hours."
"I really have no idea what that Star Wars reference was about... "
"Am I the only one that notices a five o'clock shadow on Lethal's Sasha Banks avatar?"

Not really sure either way on EV yet. It feels a bit awkward for EV to get involved in the Tweet back-and-forth as much as he has if they're both town, and he's scum. Which is something to keep in mind moving forward.

CP trying hard on d1 against isn't making me comfortable with him at all.

Anyone else hasn't made enough of an impression on me either way yet.

Bit of a stretch to suggest thoughts over fabrications based off a baseless argument. Very vague assumption of Jeff's play and doesn't provide the same confidence in a read of Jeff that he does for Tweet. Gives me a town pass for my claim, um, sure, but it holds little weight. Making observations of KIF's 'filler' posts just seems a forceful way of ISO'ing someone who won't provide much opposition to it. Not sure how he rationalises EV being possible scum by inserting himself into that Jeff/Tweets discussion, as anyone reading it would have tried to steer it away. Doesn't explain why CP 'trying hard' makes him uncomfortable.

Oh and town lean OMB for this cos I'm in the same boat and this feels like something you'd only say as town.

Town lean over OMB being overly cautious of his eventual claim?

IMO it just seems posting for posting sake and trying to form connections and ideas that just aren't there

 

[Evans]

Not really sure either way on EV yet. It feels a bit awkward for EV to get involved in the Tweet back-and-forth as much as he has if they're both town, and he's scum. Which is something to keep in mind moving forward.

So it's awkward for me to get involved in the only active conversation in the thread at the time with the two most active players at the time?

@E-V can you remember which game you were scum in pls?

From what I remember, Arrow mafia back on WF.

Like this is a great example of what I mean. The bolded looks like distancing to me, theres no bite and no commitment. He even provides Tweet with a plausible defence, why????

Evans, walk me through your rationale here pls

There's no bite or commitment as at that point in time Jeff was my scum read, Tweet wasn't although I noticed inconsistencies in Tweets posting.

Instead of going down the rabbit hole of tunnelling Jeff with only 7 of us active in the thread, I was questioning Tweets over the holes I saw forming and as per advice I've been given over the last few games, trying to see the town reasoning in actions instead of thinking why it could be scum

I wasn't a fan of Tweet getting moody with me for asking a question about something that didn't add up for me and instead of just answering the question, like I'd expect an annoyed town member to do, he started asking me questions, implying that I just wanted to lynch Barry which I called out.

 

[Lethal]

Also, wouldn't mind knowing if TKOK, Mitch, Alco and Brutus are going to grace us with their presence.

 

[Odo]

So it's awkward for me to get involved in the only active conversation in the thread at the time with the two most active players at the time?



From what I remember, Arrow mafia back on WF.



There's no bite or commitment as at that point in time Jeff was my scum read, Tweet wasn't although I noticed inconsistencies in Tweets posting.

Instead of going down the rabbit hole of tunnelling Jeff with only 7 of us active in the thread, I was questioning Tweets over the holes I saw forming and as per advice I've been given over the last few games, trying to see the town reasoning in actions instead of thinking why it could be scum

I wasn't a fan of Tweet getting moody with me for asking a question about something that didn't add up for me and instead of just answering the question, like I'd expect an annoyed town member to do, he started asking me questions, implying that I just wanted to lynch Barry which I called out.

Ok, so wheres the followup to all this? AFAIK your vote is still on Jeff. Also, this doesnt adequately explain why you threw a softball to Tweet re: potential reasons for his answers you dont like?

 

[Odo]

Id expect Alco to surface tomorrow, he doesnt really play at weekends

The rest, god knows lol

 

[Odo]

Wish me luck lads, Im wading back into GDPR Best for Business.com

 

[Canadian Dragon]

We can tag him in the afternoon, day is 48 and its the weekend so I'm willing to show SOME patience there. And yeah Alco especially, as Odo said, he legit doesn't show up on weekends often and will often complain if the game starts during one.