"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Poyser]

Is there an echo in here

 

[Lethal]

Still wouldn't mind baldrick being blasted either tbh

I don't have any major objections to it tbh. Obv I'd be opting for Mando here and I'd like to see more from both Tweet and Doddsy but there's no real guarantee either will provide it lol

Vibing with Poyser here

@Grimini Killer vote count please? we have around 7 hours and not much data to go off.

 

[Lethal]

Voting one and having the shot wouldn't be that bad of an option either.

And Jeff, I'll have your back. Guaranteed.

 

[Poyser]

Voting one and having the shot wouldn't be that bad of an option either.

And Jeff, I'll have your back. Guaranteed.

Guessing this means you think Jeff is town?

 

[Lethal]

Guessing this means you think Jeff is town?

His scum tells haven't pinged me to date.

 

[PHEN0M]

His scum tells haven't pinged me to date.

Noted for future use.

 

[Baldrick]

The problem is if you hit me, there's only going to be two of you everyone is going to target then.

@Lethal Banks call it paper pushing 101 all you want, they are just my opinions. I'm not going to against what I feel.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

 

[Lethal]

The problem is if you hit me, there's only going to be two of you everyone is going to target then.

@Lethal Banks call it paper pushing 101 all you want, they are just my opinions. I'm not going to against what I feel.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

You've thrown around word salad and haven't pushed any agenda. If I get targeted because I'm wrong, well, it wouldn't be the first time

 

[Baldrick]

You've thrown around word salad and haven't pushed any agenda. If I get targeted because I'm wrong, well, it wouldn't be the first time

I've got no agenda to push right now. I've shared my thoughts.

Plus i've got you on the wrong thing. I get it all the time when i'm wrong on something.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

the last quote came after ur initial post i belive

where u at rn in terms of reads. can u name the players u r looking at and put them in a town and scum pool? provide reasoning for each even if just a gut feeling

It probably did. I’ve been very in and out this weekend, as I mentioned earlier that I was traveling. I should be settled in tomorrow afternoon.

I don’t have solid reads on everyone. I lean Scum on Man, as I think he seemed a little erratic early on. He did the same thing in the game I played with him on WC, and he was scum.

I have a slight scum lean on Jeff, but I don’t feel as convinced as some others.

Baldrick strikes me as town. Again, comparing his style to the one game I played with him on WC, it’s similar and he was town.

I’ll be doing some sightseeing, grabbing lunch, and driving 6 hours this evening. I’ll try to get a bit more involved if I can convince my wife to drive.

 

[Lethal]

^ Got some quotes or screenshots to back this up? Cos all of this "he seems erratic" stuff being thrown around is making me nervous

 

[Oneiros]

1. @Poyser - Town mostly because of the overanalysing.
2. @Tweet - Wouldn't lynch now as I suspect Switchblade more than I do him, and they're unlikely to be aligned.
3. @Ace Marvel - Town even though he reminds me of a friend of mine that can be a baby faced assassin.
4. @Doddsy - Null
5. @Lethal Banks - Town
6. @PHEN0M - Didn't post (actually has now that I've refreshed before posting)
7. @McNightstalker - Scum lean. Can go either way but not for a lack of information to be analysed. I mostly don't like his reasoning.
8. @Ekkologix - I want to say town lean on effort but I diagonally read some of their posts.
9. @CraigPelton - Null
10. @Oneiros ---------
11. @Death Dealer - Didn't post
12. @Worst Player Ever - Didn't post
13. @Sister Abigail - Town
14. @Baldrick - Null but weird as hell posting style
15. @Red Dragon - I'm starting to lean scum but like I said before way too chaotic. Reminds me of Skybox. More thougths on him below.
16. @Tommy Bedlam - Might be scum but it's not a solid lean for now.
17. @Wangman Page - Town lean
18. @OldJay - Null. I'd say a scum team wouldn't let him ignore the game this much, but can be indy.
19. @T-Pein™ - Didn't post
20. @Mandalorian - Town lean. Unlikely to be aligned with Red Dragon,
21. @Captain Holt - Null but I'd say town if pressed.
22. @Switchblade - Scum lean
23. @Showtime - Null
24. @Ace - Didn't post


I feel like McNightstalker and Baldrick's game will unfold the more they talk and I'll be able to have a proper read on them. Would not lynch Baldrick right now.

Red Dragon on the other hand I think is going to post the same way all game. Things will get clearer about him when he decides the target of his supposed day kill anyway. I'm of the opinion he should use it this day phase. Firstly because if he's town mafia scum might kill him before he uses it, secondly because he might be scum that wants to make sure he avoids being blocked by town - all that talk about not letting himself be influenced would corroborate the second option.

I am curious to why Doddsy is leaning scum on Ace Marvel and why CP is so adamant Magic is town as I've seen nothing that could indicate his alignment either way.

Switchblade > Red Dragon > McNightstalker would be my preferred killing order, might change depending on what RD decides to do.

 

[John McHenry]

1. @Poyser - Town mostly because of the overanalysing.
2. @Tweet - Wouldn't lynch now as I suspect Switchblade more than I do him, and they're unlikely to be aligned.
3. @Ace Marvel - Town even though he reminds me of a friend of mine that can be a baby faced assassin.
4. @Doddsy - Null
5. @Lethal Banks - Town
6. @PHEN0M - Didn't post (actually has now that I've refreshed before posting)
7. @McNightstalker - Scum lean. Can go either way but not for a lack of information to be analysed. I mostly don't like his reasoning.
8. @Ekkologix - I want to say town lean on effort but I diagonally read some of their posts.
9. @CraigPelton - Null
10. @Oneiros ---------
11. @Death Dealer - Didn't post
12. @Worst Player Ever - Didn't post
13. @Sister Abigail - Town
14. @Baldrick - Null but weird as hell posting style
15. @Red Dragon - I'm starting to lean scum but like I said before way too chaotic. Reminds me of Skybox. More thougths on him below.
16. @Tommy Bedlam - Might be scum but it's not a solid lean for now.
17. @Wangman Page - Town lean
18. @OldJay - Null. I'd say a scum team wouldn't let him ignore the game this much, but can be indy.
19. @T-Pein™ - Didn't post
20. @Mandalorian - Town lean. Unlikely to be aligned with Red Dragon,
21. @Captain Holt - Null but I'd say town if pressed.
22. @Switchblade - Scum lean
23. @Showtime - Null
24. @Ace - Didn't post


I feel like McNightstalker and Baldrick's game will unfold the more they talk and I'll be able to have a proper read on them. Would not lynch Baldrick right now.

Red Dragon on the other hand I think is going to post the same way all game. Things will get clearer about him when he decides the target of his supposed day kill anyway. I'm of the opinion he should use it this day phase. Firstly because if he's town mafia scum might kill him before he uses it, secondly because he might be scum that wants to make sure he avoids being blocked by town - all that talk about not letting himself be influenced would corroborate the second option.

I am curious to why Doddsy is leaning scum on Ace Marvel and why CP is so adamant Magic is town as I've seen nothing that could indicate his alignment either way.

Switchblade > Red Dragon > McNightstalker would be my preferred killing order, might change depending on what RD decides to do.

Ouch

 

[John McHenry]

1. @Poyser - Town mostly because of the overanalysing.
2. @Tweet - Wouldn't lynch now as I suspect Switchblade more than I do him, and they're unlikely to be aligned.
3. @Ace Marvel - Town even though he reminds me of a friend of mine that can be a baby faced assassin.
4. @Doddsy - Null
5. @Lethal Banks - Town
6. @PHEN0M - Didn't post (actually has now that I've refreshed before posting)
7. @McNightstalker - Scum lean. Can go either way but not for a lack of information to be analysed. I mostly don't like his reasoning.
8. @Ekkologix - I want to say town lean on effort but I diagonally read some of their posts.
9. @CraigPelton - Null
10. @Oneiros ---------
11. @Death Dealer - Didn't post
12. @Worst Player Ever - Didn't post
13. @Sister Abigail - Town
14. @Baldrick - Null but weird as hell posting style
15. @Red Dragon - I'm starting to lean scum but like I said before way too chaotic. Reminds me of Skybox. More thougths on him below.
16. @Tommy Bedlam - Might be scum but it's not a solid lean for now.
17. @Wangman Page - Town lean
18. @OldJay - Null. I'd say a scum team wouldn't let him ignore the game this much, but can be indy.
19. @T-Pein™ - Didn't post
20. @Mandalorian - Town lean. Unlikely to be aligned with Red Dragon,
21. @Captain Holt - Null but I'd say town if pressed.
22. @Switchblade - Scum lean
23. @Showtime - Null
24. @Ace - Didn't post


I feel like McNightstalker and Baldrick's game will unfold the more they talk and I'll be able to have a proper read on them. Would not lynch Baldrick right now.

Red Dragon on the other hand I think is going to post the same way all game. Things will get clearer about him when he decides the target of his supposed day kill anyway. I'm of the opinion he should use it this day phase. Firstly because if he's town mafia scum might kill him before he uses it, secondly because he might be scum that wants to make sure he avoids being blocked by town - all that talk about not letting himself be influenced would corroborate the second option.

I am curious to why Doddsy is leaning scum on Ace Marvel and why CP is so adamant Magic is town as I've seen nothing that could indicate his alignment either way.

Switchblade > Red Dragon > McNightstalker would be my preferred killing order, might change depending on what RD decides to do.

You explain your reasons for @Red Dragon and I but no reason for your number 1

What's up wit day?

I understand why people are iffy on my reasoning. I'll make attempts to be more articulate. I'm usually off the forum over the weekend so I'm kinda trying to rush my thoughts

 

[Canadian Dragon]

1. @Poyser - Town mostly because of the overanalysing.
2. @Tweet - Wouldn't lynch now as I suspect Switchblade more than I do him, and they're unlikely to be aligned.
3. @Ace Marvel - Town even though he reminds me of a friend of mine that can be a baby faced assassin.
4. @Doddsy - Null
5. @Lethal Banks - Town
6. @PHEN0M - Didn't post (actually has now that I've refreshed before posting)
7. @McNightstalker - Scum lean. Can go either way but not for a lack of information to be analysed. I mostly don't like his reasoning.
8. @Ekkologix - I want to say town lean on effort but I diagonally read some of their posts.
9. @CraigPelton - Null
10. @Oneiros ---------
11. @Death Dealer - Didn't post
12. @Worst Player Ever - Didn't post
13. @Sister Abigail - Town
14. @Baldrick - Null but weird as hell posting style
15. @Red Dragon - I'm starting to lean scum but like I said before way too chaotic. Reminds me of Skybox. More thougths on him below.
16. @Tommy Bedlam - Might be scum but it's not a solid lean for now.
17. @Wangman Page - Town lean
18. @OldJay - Null. I'd say a scum team wouldn't let him ignore the game this much, but can be indy.
19. @T-Pein™ - Didn't post
20. @Mandalorian - Town lean. Unlikely to be aligned with Red Dragon,
21. @Captain Holt - Null but I'd say town if pressed.
22. @Switchblade - Scum lean
23. @Showtime - Null
24. @Ace - Didn't post


I feel like McNightstalker and Baldrick's game will unfold the more they talk and I'll be able to have a proper read on them. Would not lynch Baldrick right now.

Red Dragon on the other hand I think is going to post the same way all game. Things will get clearer about him when he decides the target of his supposed day kill anyway. I'm of the opinion he should use it this day phase. Firstly because if he's town mafia scum might kill him before he uses it, secondly because he might be scum that wants to make sure he avoids being blocked by town - all that talk about not letting himself be influenced would corroborate the second option.

I am curious to why Doddsy is leaning scum on Ace Marvel and why CP is so adamant Magic is town as I've seen nothing that could indicate his alignment either way.

Switchblade > Red Dragon > McNightstalker would be my preferred killing order, might change depending on what RD decides to do.

i like this a lot . Town points