"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[Poyser]

Doddsys take is very odd to me since in contradicts a lot of my opinions

Which ones specifically?

I could compare your readslist but Id rather you tell me what you disagree with and why/how strong the disagreement is

 

[Canadian Dragon]

You'd have to ask smark why he had you scum/ace town specifically in that scenario. I mean I think I could guess why mechanically, but Im not sure if there were any play based reason for him to think that way.

It's more interesting that he was suddenly ok with you afterwards, for sure. Like if Ace doesnt have a kill, then ok, mechanically the case for you being scum isnt as strong. That said he did seem to have issues with the way you handled the claim and your play so it is a bit ehhh that he just dropped it. Also with him pretty much saying he has a kill, and Im assuming he's not a straight up vig due to his reaction... It's a bit odd that he's not more curious about getting your flip, for sure.

That said its also hard to figure out why he would do that if he's scum and you're town. I believe he said he had reasons to doubt your claim before Ace chimed in, so backtracking would be weird. Kinda does seem like he just isn't sure

My gut says mb hes just a duelist or smth

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Or the vig that dies if they shoot town since ge was asking about restrictions actually

 

[John McHenry]

Which ones specifically?

I could compare your readslist but Id rather you tell me what you disagree with and why/how strong the disagreement is

Mando holt Abigail and I think he had tweet neutral literally my top 3 he's not even wavering on. So I'm either completely off or he's attempting to protect one of them

 

[Poyser]

My gut says mb hes just a duelist or smth

That would be very interesting indeed

 

[Poyser]

Mando holt Abigail and I think he had tweet neutral literally my top 3 he's not even wavering on. So I'm either completely off or he's attempting to protect one of them

That's 4 lol

Who are your top 3? And my top 3 Im assuming you mean scum reads?

 

[John McHenry]

That's 4 lol

Who are your top 3? And my top 3 Im assuming you mean scum reads?

Tweet abi mando

 

[Poyser]

Tweet abi mando

why

 

[PHEN0M]

This isn’t where I parked my car.

 

[Poyser]

8.5 hours left and I don't have a single clue what the vote count is. This is fine

 

[Poyser]

PHEN0M

 

[PHEN0M]

Nothing that has transpired prior to my arrival has happened in my mind so let’s have a great start to the game here fellas!

 

[Canadian Dragon]

So ive recalibrated @Poyser

My kill list atm:
Mando
Tweet
Doddsy

Thoughts?

 

[Poyser]

So ive recalibrated @Poyser

My kill list atm:
Mando
Tweet
Doddsy

Thoughts?

Still wouldn't mind baldrick being blasted either tbh

I don't have any major objections to it tbh. Obv I'd be opting for Mando here and I'd like to see more from both Tweet and Doddsy but there's no real guarantee either will provide it lol

 

[Lethal]

Well that took far longer than expected....but some vieww from that hundreds of posts i've just been through.

I'm on the fence with Man, something feels off but I can't put my finger on if it's a good thing or a bad thing.

Ekko has put a lot out there, now i'm not sure if that is for information overload or being a genuine attempt at getting a proper feel for things.

Wang i'll give the benefit of the doubt to for now.

Tweet....there's something nagging there but not enough to put a vote down.

Holt...i'm ok with for now, something will no doubt coke from that one way or the other as we move forward.

I'm not liking that there's still a few we haven't really had input from. Are we focussing too much on the contributions so far and not enough of those laying low?

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

Paper Pushing 101

Gone through "hundreds of posts" and sit on the fence with Mandalorian? Ok. Very 50/50 fence sitting and not wanting to risk sticking to anything. I dislike this, and think it's FAKE with disingenuous thoughts to appease the class.
Ehhh I'd rather you shoot Mando. Smark has been weird this game for sure but my gut is telling me he's just town
My takes after catching up

@Poyser - town
@Tweet - scum
@Lethal Banks - lean town
@Ekkologix - town
@Sister Abigail - scum
@Baldrick - town
@Canadian Dragon - scum
@Mandalorian - scum
@Captain Holt - scum
@Switchblade- town

My top 3 atm tweet, Mando, sister abigail

That was quite a catching up.

What makes you lean town on me?

So ive recalibrated @Poyser

My kill list atm:
Mando
Tweet
Doddsy

Thoughts?

I like the Mando option. For what it's worth, I'd add in Baldrick to this list.