"Glory, Hallelujah" | Barry Presents - The American Civil War - Mafia GAME THREAD

[John McHenry]

We did aknoledge each other tho, that point is erroneous n im getting really annoyed ppl are using this.

And that could have been just the amount of posts happening. Which is why you arent in my 3

 

[Comrade Khan]

And that could have been just the amount of posts happening. Which is why you arent in my 3

? U put me as scum

 

[Poyser]

I probably shouldnt have said straight town but I just get the sense his motives are genuinely curious. I don't get a sense he's trying to divert suspscion

I dont really get what this means really

Could you perhaps point to a post or two that you think makes him look "genuinely curious"?

 

[John McHenry]

? U put me as scum

You're also a very aggressive player. It could be because you've been called out a lot but it could also be a strategy. I also don't know how anyone plays.

 

[Comrade Khan]

You're also a very aggressive player. It could be because you've been called out a lot but it could also be a strategy. I also don't know how anyone plays.

thats a lot of different raisins.

 

[Poyser]

Then I have no idea what he was pushing for

Yes quite a few tbh.

Poyser
Tweet
Ace Marvel
Lethal Banks
PHEN0M
John McHenry
Ekkologix
CraigPelton
Oneiros
Death Dealer
Worst Player Ever
Sister Abigail
Baldrick
Canadian Dragon
Tommy Bedlam
Wangman Page
OldJay
T-Pein™
Mandalorian
Captain Holt
Poltergeist
Showtime
Ace

Ughhh not really sure what to ask first here

Why do you have magic as town?
Same with mandolorian and captain holt

 

[John McHenry]

Wouldn't it be best for both sides to eliminate the dead waste non posters first?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Further side note poyser is town: hed just laugh at me being mad at ekko, not try to cool the temp. Hed throw oil

 

[Comrade Khan]

Wouldn't it be best for both sides to eliminate the dead waste non posters first?

Sometimes yes, but the flip side of that is you get very little info of their flips since they have no posts to look at after. But yes, at one poimt it nedds to solved

 

[Poyser]

Back to smark, since i have a hard time this game reading him fully, what did u think of him sussimg kpop when he thpouht he softed but seemingly seemed ok w me ? Hes a tough cookie, unsure if hes justvholding his cards close to the vest n showing enough so he can get reads or if hes sneaky

You'd have to ask smark why he had you scum/ace town specifically in that scenario. I mean I think I could guess why mechanically, but Im not sure if there were any play based reason for him to think that way.

It's more interesting that he was suddenly ok with you afterwards, for sure. Like if Ace doesnt have a kill, then ok, mechanically the case for you being scum isnt as strong. That said he did seem to have issues with the way you handled the claim and your play so it is a bit ehhh that he just dropped it. Also with him pretty much saying he has a kill, and Im assuming he's not a straight up vig due to his reaction... It's a bit odd that he's not more curious about getting your flip, for sure.

That said its also hard to figure out why he would do that if he's scum and you're town. I believe he said he had reasons to doubt your claim before Ace chimed in, so backtracking would be weird. Kinda does seem like he just isn't sure

 

[John McHenry]

Sometimes yes, but the flip side of that is you get very little info of their flips since they have no posts to look at after. But yes, at one poimt it nedds to solved

Just seems mor beneficial to take them out than I advertantly taking out a teammate, they could be a teammate to but as they aren't helping...

 

[Poyser]

Like why am i scummy because im not aggresively reading tweet scum or town? Dude acts like he doesnt give a shit n doesnt want to be here and its somehow my fault for not hyper engaging him? So im supposed to have strong feelings about him just bc ppl said so? It couldnt possibly be that i just wasnt interested in his slot because i was lookimg elsewhere ? Jfc lol

Im more concerned with tweets play around you than vice versa tbh. I thought Ekko made a pretty good point that Tweet said more than once he isn't sure about you but then he didn't seem at all arsed that you didn't chase him for answers or about engaging you to get a better handle of your alignment.

Kinda like he just gratefully accepted that you didn't wanna rumble lol. If he's town I'd kinda expect him be a bit more aggressive with you if he doesn't read you town

 

[John McHenry]

Doddsys take is very odd to me since in contradicts a lot of my opinions

 

[Poyser]

Just seems mor beneficial to take them out than I advertantly taking out a teammate, they could be a teammate to but as they aren't helping...

It's not really beneficial at all to lynch a low/non-poster. Well, it's perfect for scum to lynch them, but there's no benefit for town.

If they are mafia, then there's nothing to defend them with really so they won't bother. If they are town, they're pretty easy to just lynch without consequence. As they don't have many (if any) interactions with other players, you really get absolutely nothing from their flip either way. If they're mafia you can't really find their teammates, other than possibly ruling out the first person to suggest lynching that player (though someone not posting is an idea bus candidate so even that's not very strong).

The way to handle the low posters is if you have a night kill, then kill them. If you are a cop, then cop them. You could also track them. Either way you need to try and get their alignment through night roles as it's not really possible during the day, and mafia will never kill these players as they're ideal to keep around. Inactivity/apathy is mafia's greatest ally

 

[Comrade Khan]

Oh before i forget @Poyser , when i flip make sure u grill anyome today who sussed me but didnt vote. Scum r likely to have a few cowards who dont want me to shoot them for voting me just a tip