Barry Presents: WS Mafia 3 "The Revival" Game Thread

[CraigPelton]

I hadn’t even seen CPs vote when I was typing. I’m playing on my laptop primarily since I’m working and didn’t click on the “there’s been more posts. View them?” button. If the unvote seemed sketchy, I’ll take full blame for that.

The most suspect thing for me here by far is nothing to do with your play around Blaine or the timing of your Juice vote. It's immediately unvoting her and voting someone else in your next post after people sussed you for the juice vote. No conviction and playing for approval are red flags.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Yeah Juice does that as either alignment tho from what I recall, we'd just be lynching her for being inactive which doesn't feel like the best direction early d1

I specifically remember a game (maybe the last one played here) where she was town and was super active and actually figured a lot of stuff out. She just couldn’t get anybody to go with her on stuff.

 

[Mandalorian]

This seems kind of redundant given the post you replied to says basically the same thing lol

The key thing about it is that I agreed with it.

 

[Mandalorian]

Pretty weak sus here imo

Wasn’t even sussing Pendex here?

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

well I tagged her before any of you fucks even mentioned she hadn't posted anything

I still don’t think you’d tag a scum mate to get her in the thread. You’d use the PM. Which is why I say if I’m right about juice, you’re even more likely town.

 

[CraigPelton]

The key thing about it is that I agreed with it.

Then why the "but"?

 

[CraigPelton]

Wasn’t even sussing Pendex here?

What was the point of the post then?

 

[Comrade Khan]

The most suspect thing for me here by far is nothing to do with your play around Blaine or the timing of your Juice vote. It's immediately unvoting her and voting someone else in your next post after people sussed you for the juice vote. No conviction and playing for approval are red flags.

to piggy back off this -

yes. The issue is your (tommy) transition from your first suspect to your 2nd suspect was done after people reacted to the Juice vote. You didn't spend a lot of time discussing or counter sussing ppl who gave you immediate suspicion. You didn't really spend any time between both suspects discussion pros and cons or your thought. You seemed immediately taken aback by people not likling the timing of your vote and immediately moved away and voted elsewhere (and gave some reasons).

This is a game of perception to a dgree, surely you can understand, Tommy, why this reactive behavior appears very suspicious to an onlooker yes?

 

[The Gipper]

Additionally, if I'm right about Juice, Gip's comment about not liking the people voting that way is something that town will want to keep in mind.

I’m perfectly fine with that, Tommy and I’ll stand by it. To me right now Juice is not the option that benefits town the most, you on the other hand, I think you’ve really put yourself in a box here. And I already had suspicion on you before this so.

Official Vote: Tommy

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Yep. It is all about perception. I'll admit the fast vote change fucked up. I was trying to make something happen regarding at least one of my two chief suspects. Hopefully, if my mistake ends up leading to my demise, it answers some questions about at least 3 (probably 4) other slots.

 

[Mandalorian]

What was the point of the post then?

It was a comparison between Pendex’s start in a game where they were scum to this game and I noted a minor similarity. I followed up and said it wasn’t enough for a proper read because it wasn’t as egregious as the one they did on me in the game I was referring to. What part of that thought process are you taking issue with?

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I hadn’t even seen CPs vote when I was typing. I’m playing on my laptop primarily since I’m working and didn’t click on the “there’s been more posts. View them?” button. If the unvote seemed sketchy, I’ll take full blame for that.

Wouldn't this make Tommy the third vote (at least in spirit)... Those of you who subscribe to third vote theory might like the sound of it

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Wouldn't this make Tommy the third vote (at least in spirit)... Those of you who subscribe to third vote theory might like the sound of it

We talking overall votes? If that's the case, I think I was the fourth vote, wasn't I? Pein voted Jeff, you voted Juice, CP voted Man, then I voted Juice.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

We talking overall votes? If that's the case, I think I was the fourth vote, wasn't I? Pein voted Jeff, you voted Juice, CP voted Man, then I voted Juice.

CP on Juice
Me on Juice
(CP switches to Mando but you don't see that)
You on Juice

 

[The Gipper]

Wouldn't this make Tommy the third vote (at least in spirit)... Those of you who subscribe to third vote theory might like the sound of it

What’s the third vote theory exactly?