Barry Presents: WS Mafia 3 "The Revival" Game Thread

[Mandalorian]

I still don’t think you’d tag a scum mate to get her in the thread. You’d use the PM. Which is why I say if I’m right about juice, you’re even more likely town.

Yeah but wouldn’t a mafia player use the thread and not the PM to look town?

Whose to say they couldn’t just do both?

 

[Sky]

What’s the third vote theory exactly?

The idea is that on a wagon, a third vote is more likely to be a scummy one. Second vote is agreement, third vote is opportunism

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I still don’t think you’d tag a scum mate to get her in the thread. You’d use the PM. Which is why I say if I’m right about juice, you’re even more likely town.

well you would be wrong on that but I do get what you are saying that a PM is obviously better. And I do think you know creating plausible separation between me and my scumates is something I take care in, it's kind of been one of my main plays as scum for the last year or so

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Yea, I recall us creating distance when we were scummates. I'm pretty sure that I tried to avoid interacting with anyone on my team at all in the last game I played. Fair enough. I'm just throwing out observations.

 

[CraigPelton]

It was a comparison between Pendex’s start in a game where they were scum to this game and I noted a minor similarity. I followed up and said it wasn’t enough for a proper read because it wasn’t as egregious as the one they did on me in the game I was referring to. What part of that thought process are you taking issue with?

And this isn't a sus to you?

 

[Sky]

We're getting an oddly meek Mando in this game I feel

 

[Canadian Dragon]

vote mr Thomas Bedlam

 

[Canadian Dragon]

@Jango Fett you have 1 post, please come play the game

@T-Pein™ need a lot more from you as well, a couple of votes and no discussion after them isn't quite going to cut it in a small game

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Alright, I've got meetings all afternoon, so I'm gonna throw this out there. If I find out that I'm dead when I get back, it is what it is. I certainly made myself look bad by switching votes. There's not gonna be anyway to get around that fact, so I just have to own it. Fuck up, lesson learned. However, I will point out, that if I was scum, I would've likely gone over my move with my team before making it. Unless the estimation is that there's no one with any experience on the scum team, I think somebody would've been like, "Hey, don't do that shit. It's gonna look bad." Based on the experience levels in the game, I think the most inexperienced possible team would probably be Me/Blaine/Juice. If that was the case, they wouldn't be my only two strong suspects.

I still firmly believe that either Juice, Blaine, or Juice and Blaine are scum. Unless I missed it when skimming back through posts, Blaine (who has talked about a lot of other topics) has had no response to Juice's appearance/disappearance. If I go down, I'm flipping town (and not even a particularly exciting townie), and at least one scummer who is actively posting will be able to say, "Eh, he fucked up by changing votes." Don't buy it, town.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

my counter argument against you not being coached is that your team could have not been around.

I will put some stock in you often asking for advise as scum and being more prone to freeze up than react, that is actually factual

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Fair. If I had a team and they weren’t around, I would’ve stood pat. I’m typically so unsure of my ability that I usually wait for the green light, and would be even more cautious in a game in which we only had a 3 person scum team.

 

[CraigPelton]

Maybe you didn't ask your team because you didn't want to accidentally post it in the thread

 

[CraigPelton]

I still firmly believe that either Juice, Blaine, or Juice and Blaine are scum. Unless I missed it when skimming back through posts, Blaine (who has talked about a lot of other topics) has had no response to Juice's appearance/disappearance. If I go down, I'm flipping town (and not even a particularly exciting townie), and at least one scummer who is actively posting will be able to say, "Eh, he fucked up by changing votes." Don't buy it, town.

I feel like your scum reads on these guys are getting increasingly confident despite receiving no new information from either lol

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Maybe you didn't ask your team because you didn't want to accidentally post it in the thread

Dammit. The things I’ll never live down.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

I feel like your scum reads on these guys are getting increasingly confident despite receiving no new information from either lol

Not more. I was just as convinced that one or both was scum this morning. Just trying to leave town my thoughts in the event that I don’t live to see the evening.