A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[Tweet]

 

[Tweet]

……..............

 

[Smart Marx]

Dude, magic quit and killed himself in one of my games, told me the setup was fucking trash and unplayable and listed all the ways it was shit. Still didn’t cry about it

In one game? Try after every single one of your games.

You were also fucking crying because the setup made you lose. So I don't get why the kettle keeps talking about crying.

 

[Junkette]

Was this kid magic who didn't know how to criticize people without flaming them or adult magic>? lol

 

[Poyser]

In one game? Try after every single one of your games.

You were also fucking crying because the setup made you lose. So I don't get why the kettle keeps talking about crying.

I didn’t though, I had my moan and then I said Im sorry and I’m just reacting so badly because I know I didn’t play as well as I could etc. i never said the setup made me lose, i said we didn’t play well enough. I said mafia had too much and I’m right. If you find that hard to hear then idk what to tell you

 

[Poyser]

Was this kid magic who didn't know how to criticize people without flaming them or adult magic>? lol

Kind of in between lol

 

[Junkette]

You said sorry? Where? LOL

 

[Poyser]

Also I usually cover the mistakes I know I made when I do the end of game write up, probably takes the wind out of the sails of anyone that’s thinking of bitching

 

[Smart Marx]

I didn’t though, I had my moan and then I said Im sorry and I’m just reacting so badly because I know I didn’t play as well as I could etc. i never said the setup made me lose, i said we didn’t play well enough. I said mafia had too much and I’m right. If you find that hard to hear then idk what to tell you

If you said you're sorry I missed it.

I still don't see how you don't realize how much town had. The census alone nearly changed the whole game, but ok.

 

[Poyser]

Anyway I have my opinions on the setup but I don’t actually wanna take anything away from scum. They did enough and we didn’t. I’m extra annoyed because I know I missed some easy shit and it’s hard to take that it was such an easy game to figure out and I didn’t do it quick enough. As haza said, town just didn’t play well when it was all said and done.

@Junkette basically

 

[Smart Marx]

Someone just post signups.

 

[Smart Marx]

Also I usually cover the mistakes I know I made when I do the end of game write up, probably takes the wind out of the sails of anyone that’s thinking of bitching

I never had a chance. You guys hammered and were discussing post game like 2 hours before I got on.

 

[Poyser]

If you said you're sorry I missed it.

I still don't see how you don't realize how much town had. The census alone nearly changed the whole game, but ok.

Because it’s pretty irrelevant, I’m saying mafia had an advantage numbers wise, and whether or not all those extra kills were GUARANTEED or not, it doesn’t matter lol, they had access to them. And part of how that effects the game isn’t just with the extra kills/hated town themselves but how people try to figure out the game and find the balance.
And sure you can say “don’t setup spec” but you have to. You all insist on shoehorning 18 players into these games which tends to lead to like 4-5 basically dead slots of people that aren’t posting, posting little or just never around to post meaningful things when stuff isn’t happening. How else are you supposed to try and sort these guys without using setup spec as a helping hand? And I’m not saying never subvert it or try and make it less effective but man, you don’t have to try and subvert it at the expense of actual game balance

 

[Poyser]

And yes this game wasn’t lost by setup. It was lost with town mistakes. Cp not claiming PGO early, lethal visiting him, Wang visiting cp despite the claim, everything Ekko did and me not shooting blaze when I should have. Also throw in a massive slice of scum luck that always seemed to have town distracting themselves despite the fact the scum team was pretty much entirely figured out.

but just because the game wasn’t lost by the setup, doesn’t mean there wasn’t anything wrong with it lol

 

[Smart Marx]

And for the record, it was the continued barrage that broke me. We had the earlier discussion and got past it.

Then Ekko brought up a different discussion and somewhat got past it and then Poyser sided with him and brought it back up and just like can it end already?

I get it, don’t do both ascetic and SK cop. And I honestly, I probably won’t ever do hated again. It’s always a bother to people. I’ll try not do vote steal and a traitor again because I agreed with Junk it was too much. Like I said made the game quickly and Junk’s role was one of the later additions so it was hard to remember exactly how it would look when she joined up with the scum team, but I tried to give her many negative roles too like being a lover to balance it.

I still think the myslynch balance was still pretty good because I worked hard to think about that.

I just wanted to get people playing again after the last game stalled out and did my best with my time.