A Good Day to Die Hard: Mafia with a Vengeance [Game Thread]

[Poyser]

Yall wine about the dumbest shit , no offense. There was 0 wrong with ekkos role, he just wrongfully assumed that a no result on barry somehow meant something it didn't, and didn't consider the game stats since when he pulled his fake stuff, barry was already getting duelled. Sk's are allowed to have perks and sometimes you do good usage but don't get rewarded. That's mafia , get over it and stop crying to hosts every time something doesn't go your way . 0 reason to write multiple paragraphs either when smark already explained thisto ekko in dead qt. It's a game , gentlemen

Saying there was 0 wrong with it is just your opinion too though. Clearly, people disagree

 

[Poyser]

And yes if your entire role is designed to catch one very specific role, but that role can get around you anyway, then yeah there is something wrong with it lol

 

[Poyser]

Also I’m not bitching lmao I put forth my opinion, it turned into a massive paragraph back and forth because smark can’t take people disagreeing with him without seeing it as some sort of personal attack

 

[Smart Marx]

Lol i guess I just throw that term around. He was led to believe he can catch the serial killer and he couldn’t really, so I was like ah that’s a bit bastard. It’s not like I’m saying this was a bastard game lol. Sorry if you thought that’s what I was saying

If Barry killed that night he would have caught him. If anyone had this role they would have killed. And I know this because it’s been given many times by me.

There’s a reason his role was also full. He had the opportunity to cop him again. He wasn’t cleared like a mafia godfather. He was told no result.

 

[Smart Marx]

Also I’m not bitching lmao I put forth my opinion, it turned into a massive paragraph back and forth because smark can’t take people disagreeing with him without seeing it as some sort of personal attack

You were clearly complaining when the game first ended. Like objectively so.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Like seriously yall complaining about setup when you should look internally. Its not hard and then ppl dont sound like babies and don't spend pages criticizing a role. Don't fake as town and consider all avenues and this stuff generally doesn't happen. I dunno where ppl get off where these setups are supposed to be uniform or a certain way. Mafia is art in a way, if you can't accept that people put in all kinds if different roles then this game isn't for you imo

 

[Poyser]

Lol

 

[Smart Marx]

And yes if your entire role is designed to catch one very specific role, but that role can get around you anyway, then yeah there is something wrong with it lol

Why is an fbi so much more protected than be cop?

The cop is also only designed to catch mafia, but no one has a problem with The Godfather.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Saying there was 0 wrong with it is just your opinion too though. Clearly, people disagree

No, u and ekko disagree. Everyone else was happy and didn't find it necessary to nitpick a role when the clear issue was ekkos play abd nothing else. Everyone else on town knows why they lost, so why waste so much time annoying the host with frivolous complaints. I don't get it and don't see the point from my pov

 

[Poyser]

Part of the art is making sure the game ain’t fucked, bro. If you’re the kind of host like smark that likes to have a million moving pieces and power roles galore then it’s hard to balance and people will let you know when you get it wrong. Can’t take criticism then don’t host

 

[Poyser]

Why is an fbi so much more protected than be cop?

The cop is also only designed to catch mafia, but no one has a problem with The Godfather.

Yes but there’s also 3-5 other players the cop can catch

 

[Comrade Khan]

Tl/Dr it's a pointless exercise that only serves to annoy smark and enable ekkos complain when it a) already had been explained and b) again the issue is don't lie as town and u dont die. He could have simply been smart, waited for Barry's flip. The if he doesn't flip sk, then u can consider poyser. There was no real reason to go after poyser being sk anyways w 2 missing kills. Next time hunt scum I say

 

[Poyser]

No, u and ekko disagree. Everyone else was happy and didn't find it necessary to nitpick a role when the clear issue was ekkos play abd nothing else. Everyone else on town knows why they lost, so why waste so much time annoying the host with frivolous complaints. I don't get it and don't see the point from my pov

Junk agreed with me too. I nitpick to try and make sure shit doesn’t happen again or so hosts can learn from it, it’s pretty simple. If someone hosts a shite game and everyone claps and is like wow good job bro, then the hosting never gets better. After the few years we had when almost every setup was a fucking shit show, this has clearly been needed. I’m not saying this game was a shit show, but there were definitely things that can be improved. Largely a misleading role and the scum team having too big a numbers advantage due to extra kills and hated townjes etc. again, if you can’t take criticism or feedback then just don’t host.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Part of the art is making sure the game ain’t fucked, bro. If you’re the kind of host like smark that likes to have a million moving pieces and power roles galore then it’s hard to balance and people will let you know when you get it wrong. Can’t take criticism then don’t host

The game was nowhere near fucked, and I think deep down you know that buddy

 

[Smart Marx]

Junk for the record gave me some constructive criticism and I was like, yeah, next time I won’t have a traitor and a vote steal. That was too much.

But if you’re complaining about losing, that’s not constructive criticism.

I’ve taken probably more feedback and tried to incorporate it into my games than probably anyone.

But it’s just not fun that there’s this massive prob with my setup nearly every single game I host.

Especially when town lost imo purely because they played a poorer game. Three myslynches seems fair to go into lylo as far as I can tell. IDK anymore though.