Wow, Montana, that's a pretty impressive list!
I met Rob Vam Dam at WonderCon 2005 while he was on the shelf due to injury. He and his wife had a table there selling autographs and his dvd One of a Kind. I bought a photo and had him autograph it and Sonya was kind enough to take a photo of him and I posing with my camera. It's funny cause as he was writing on the photo, he asked if I minded him cursing on it (he wrote "from the whole fucking show...") or if I just wanted "f'ing" instead. I told him cursing was fine with me, I make sailors blush. He laughed and handed it over. I would have bought his dvd as well, but I had it already sitting at home. Would have brought it with me, but I didn't realize he was gonna have a table.
That's the only wrestler I've met, per se, though I past by the tables of Virgil, Bushwacker Luke & Honkytonk Man at this past year's WonderCon.
Back in 1996, I was working at a music store in Delaware when a coworker got to meet Francine. I guess she was down there for the day of some tax free shopping and stopped in our store (Christiana Mall). He asked if she needed any help, recognized her and talked to her for a couple minutes. He came back to the breakroom where I was eating, but by the time I had inhaled my food and went out, she had gone. C'est la vie.
They're not be wrestlers, but I'm very proud to have met Kevin Smith and Bruce Campbell (two men whose work I enjoy). They were both very cool and hilarious to talk with.