I have a soft spot for AJ so I really don't consider her the most overrated. Overrated yes but definitely not the most overrated, but you have to admit she plays the pyscho-ex gimmick perfectly.
Honestly my pick was
Chris Jericho. He did absolutely nothing when he came back to the WWE, other than giving Fandango a hell of a debut match at Wrestlemania, and giving Ryback his first PPV win via rollup. I like Jericho and I find him entertaining, but fuck man his last run did absolutely nothing for me. I suppose his purpose in the WWE nowadays is to put over the newer talent, which is a shame but I guess Jerico had a good run during his prime when he first won the Undisputed Championship. Oh but I have to admit his match with RVD was pretty excellent so I'll give him props for that.
Seth Rollins was my second nomination, which I kind of regret nominating him only because he isn't that well received as he was a little while ago. Don't get me wrong he does good but nobody considers him higher up anymore now that his title is gone. I'm sure he'll bounce around when The Shield breaks up and have some good runs with the IC title, possibly the WHC as well (or maybe not...) but anything higher than that? Doubt it.
Randy Orton was my other nomination because I'm biased against Orton like that. Leave it to Orton to get bigger pops then anyone that he's faced on RAW so far since he turned heel, and yes that includes Dolph Ziggler as well.
As for the other nominations:
Punk: I can see why he's overrated. But then again he's either went against guys who are above his league or below his league so it's kind of hard to judge. His feud with the Shield right now is the perfect level as to his popularity and drawing status so hopefully he will be better received from the IWC.
Alberto Del Rio: How the fuck is he overrated? He gets shit on my pretty much everybody so I don't see why people consider him overrated. Then again it may be a matter of him getting titles, which then I can see why he's 'overrated'.
Dean Ambrose: Again I'm a bit biased because I was a huge Jon Moxley fan while he was in the indies, but again I don't see how he can be considered overrated. Yes he's been US Champion for a while but honestly WWE has never had him defend that title, especially since Reigns and Rollins lost their tag team titles. Plus Ambrose got jobbed the fuck out at Survivor Series.
Swagger: :rofl
John Cena: Yeah him being considered 'overrated' is probably the biggest ongoing discussion in the IWC since... whenever he's been considered overrated (2007?). But in short no I don't consider him overrated.
RVD: RVD's an interesting case, because the past couple of times he switched shows people chewed him out for having a very stale moveset, yet there were others that treated him like he was the next Cena. When he came back to the WWE he had a moderate showing and a modest run while feuding with Del Rio and Ambrose. Yeah I personally think he's not overrated for his most recent run, which is a first tbh.
Ryback: Same as Del Rio, a lot of people shit on Ryback so I don't see how he's considered overrated. And again yes he was in the main event scene but he never won the gold against Cena. Hell he won what, 2 PPV matches?
Fandango: I wouldn't considered him overrated, I would consider his debut over-hyped more than anything. Of course since his concussion he's done fuck all as well, js.
Curtis Axel: Definitely not overrated. Especially without Heyman there to back his ass up. :heyman:
Edit: Apparently Chris Jericho wasn't on the list, Randy Orton it is then.
