Throwback Music Mafia [Game Thread]

[Tweet]

You are actively going against Chloe B.
If they want to personally push Blaine why are you interfering with that?
Just like I said.
If we do Lynch Blaine and he flips mafia you are a natural sus for me.
I will not allow a "well if I was mafia I would never" from you.

I'm interfering because I think there's better ways to get a read on Blaine, and I definitely don't want Blaine to claim because Chloe tells him to. Like I said, if you guys collectively disagree with my take on Blaine, you're free to ignore me and wagon him all you want.

 

[T-Pein™]

See this last point is why I think he'll likely be town, I don't think he has a great understanding of fake claims as mafia and him saying he's not VT oughta mean he already knows what he's gonna claim. Out of him that just strikes me as someone who looked at their role PM and now tells us exactly what he saw.

I understand that you dont like him as mafia.
But you will look real bad if he gets lynched and flips mafia.
You are actively talking for him and defending him.
Its like idk if he is mafia or town yet..why would I stick my neck out for him?
Do you agree with this or not?

 

[Marty McFourth]

I understand that you dont like him as mafia.
But you will look real bad if he gets lynched and flips mafia.
You are actively talking for him and defending him.
Its like idk if he is mafia or town yet..why would I stick my neck out for him?
Do you agree with this or not?

That's not always a scum trait tho

I defend too much as Town as well, it's just in my nature.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Why can RR/Flay not be s/s?

Because of the Blaine votes. Flay voting first and then Rugrat following, didn't feel like scum/scum. I agreed with T-Pein's anaylsis.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Being defensive of another player isn't really Alignment Indicative since I and plenty of others have defended scum as town and had it blow up in our face, so I don't really factor that into reading someone, rather the play around the defended player aside from the defense is more important to me.

 

[Evans]

Okay fair enough, was that so hard?

So who do you like as scum? I know you've voted me but let me ask you, do you think my play this game fits my scum meta breh?

So more questions about scum meta, except mine this time. Do you think I'm following my scum meta?

You're acting like it was a real struggle and I was fighting not to talk about it lol, why are you trying to paint that picture?

I don't have any solid scum reads 13 pages into the game. My vote on you is to keep pressure on you and see how you react to myself and others which I have no conclusions yet. I found your post to Barry a bit too on the nose and I doubtful that you go to that level of baiting on Barry just for voting you early game.

edit: hit post too soon - to answer the last question, I don't know your meta well enough to say if thats the case or not tbh but I think the above answers this actually

 

[Chloe B]

You
Rugrat, potentially. Blaine vote felt weird and he removed it and is now quiet again. Doesn't look great.

Not really sure about anyone else right now. I don't have meta reads, so I'm just going off what I read in the thread. I don't trust meta reads as much as other people anyways.

Why exactly do you think I'm scum?

 

[Curry]

Because of the Blaine votes. Flay voting first and then Rugrat following, didn't feel like scum/scum. I agreed with T-Pein's anaylsis.

I'd so that's only exclusionary if they thought it'd go somewhere which I can't imagine either did with the flimsy reasoning.

 

[Tweet]

So when I asked for one of Curry and TFW to be vigged did that resonate with you?

That's a different story because looking over this field of players, there's just about literally no chance that the vig is gonna take orders from you no matter who it is, so that take of yours is not something I feel the need to argue against.

 

[Chloe B]

You're acting like it was a real struggle and I was fighting not to talk about it lol, why are you trying to paint that picture?

I don't have any solid scum reads 13 pages into the game. My vote on you is to keep pressure on you and see how you react to myself and others which I have no conclusions yet. I found your post to Barry a bit too on the nose and I doubtful that you go to that level of baiting on Barry just for voting you early game.

I dunno bro. Maybe because I had to ask you multiple times

and ooh boy it's like you didn't know me back on WF

 

[Chloe B]

That's a different story because looking over this field of players, there's just about literally no chance that the vig is gonna take orders from you no matter who it is, so that take of yours is not something I feel the need to argue against.

I'm asking if you wanted to argue with it, I'm asking if you agreed with it

 

[Marty McFourth]

I just felt his opening to be kinda unnatural for him, maybe it's that he hasn't played in a long time but I remember him being a lot more laid-back and distant than this opening here, it just strikes me as a bit overtuned and trying to look "normal" too much.

From what I recall of Curry, it feels like Town him. I swear the last game a long time ago I saw him play he had a little burst of posts and then slowed. I guess you could look at him asking questions as more of trying to appear town than actively hunting scum, but I am not feeling suspect of him at the moment, really.

You seem pretty comfortable in thread atm is why I'm asking

It's cozy in here.

Such as?

I try to look confident and appear like I'm scum hunting, but often times it doesn't look as sincere. I don't know man, it's been like 3 years lol. You really shouldn't read too much in to it.

Even if I was scum this game, I would be winging the shit out of it. Not trying to follow some meta from years ago.

I guess this isn't helping my case, but yeah, I'd slip up somewhere. Especially after my initial surge of posts.

 

[Odo]

Flays play is what I’d do as town if I were in his position

 

[Marty McFourth]

Why exactly do you think I'm scum?

I thought you were trying too hard to be a town leader (as in, it looked like scum blending in) and then you made a post that felt odd about me and Curry and the vig and how we weren't 'playing' when it was still in fluff stage. So I wasn't sure what you wanted from us, I guess.

You're also asking a lot of questions than anything else, and I feel like that's an easy way to be productive as scum but it can be a town trait too.

 

[Tweet]

I understand that you dont like him as mafia.
But you will look real bad if he gets lynched and flips mafia.
You are actively talking for him and defending him.
Its like idk if he is mafia or town yet..why would I stick my neck out for him?
Do you agree with this or not?

Well I got reason to believe he's probably town based on the little activity he showed so far so we're not in the same boat. The main thing I was worried about is Blaine actually claiming just because Chloe told him to, because if Blaine really is town, and someone tells him to claim, chances are that's exactly what he's gonna do and I simply don't see any need for that to happen at this time. If he ends up being scum, let's just say I'm not exactly known for being on the right side of history a lot, I'll be fine either way

Once again, if people disagree with me by the masses and wanna wagon Blaine, by all means go ahead. I'll keep telling you I'm against it but that'll be about the extent of what I can actually do to prevent you.