From those 3 years, How Much effect has this put on this Company Wrestling Quality??? (Positive or Negative) Why?
Great question,
The problem even started a little earlier than 2005 as far as superstars departing and whatnot. Probably about 2004 the wwe lost its core guys, Austin, Rock, Brock, Foley and the trend only continued in 2005 with the likes of Cage, Eddie, Y2J as you mentioned. That was the main transition time. In that time, they created three new stars. Cena, Orton, and Batista were born at wm 20 and established at 21. No they gain as much as they lost, but its a tough recovery from losing that much talent, that took years and years to bulid.
2006 rolls around, You lose Angle, Big Show. But Edge was establish as a main event guy. Plus you had a large slew of great new talent. Kennedy, Punk, MVP, Lashley,Umaga, amoug others. The Hardys were getting mad over. So things look about where they should. They attempted to establish Rey and Booker, but that did not live up to expectations
2007, they really didnt build anyone up much. Lashley was the man, and he's gone. They continued to lose more guys, booker, Beniot, RVD. AND not much new good talent was brought in.
2008 more of the same. Not much in coming in, in terms of new talent. They don't want to take a chance on someone because of the "risk" involved.
The only real sucessful push since Cena is Edge. Since then everyone else has been in circles.
How has this affected the product?
Negatively. The fans simply don't care for half of the roster. The IC/Tag belts are meaningless They are forced to put midcarders in main event roles (Rey, Booker, Regal, JBL,) They have had some bad luck, when they do select someone in push. (Hardy, Lashley, Khali) But yea it has hurt the product. The main events are getting very repititive and HBK and Undertaker aren't going to be around forever. I'd hate to think what the wwe is going to look like without those two. The product is taking a hit now, and i dont see it getting much better, in the very near future.
On the bright side. I think Colt Cabana will be a big star for the company. If they know how to use him, he can be on the level of Angle, Rock, with the comedy style mixed with good wrestling. But will the wwe use him right? You also have MVP, Punk, Kennedy, and the Hardys still waiting for their turn. But actually the wwe is doin what they can now. They've just made some bad decisions on who to push, when they do.