The Horus Heresy: Mafia - Game Thread

[Odo]

what has Odo and Odo alone gotten us into here....

 

[Tweet]

I see. Perhaps we are getting our wires crossed a bit here. I used the duel because I do believe junk is scum here. If she's not, considering how much Odo doubled down, it's more than reasonable to look in that direction. I don't really think there's anything inherently wrong with that line of thinking. One can agree with a case and be suspicious of it's source's validity at the same time. Those thoughts don't have to be mutually exclusive at all times, especially this early.

Let me put it another way then.

If Junk flips town here, what do think the chances are that anyone is actually gonna follow you on a crusade against Odo, especially considering the way you snap used your duel?

 

[Odo]

This kinda just feels like you haven't put any thought into why people would look at you if Junk flips town tbh which in a way feels towny, I've caught myself derping before at being pushed bc like I KNOW I'm town lmao

Guess it could also be viewed as opportunism to go after Odo if you know Junk's flip but that's pretty on the nose if so lol

only play I see there is if they think I’ll get indignant, not claim and get executed or some shit

if that’s even a thing

 

[Odo]

Let’s get junks flip first

 

[Death Meta Knight]

Let me put it another way then.

If Junk flips town here, what do think the chances are that anyone is actually gonna follow you on a crusade against Odo, especially considering the way you snap used your duel?

Can't say I considered it nor do I particularly care?

 

[CraigPelton]

guys lets not eat each other until we know junks flip

hope nobody steals this post or even just the core idea of it

 

[CraigPelton]

god damn it

 

[Showtime]

I want something more concrete behind a push. Voting him just provides him an opportunity to scream OMGUS and bounce off from it.

My vote is on Tweet though but it's based off of nothing except cynicism from Saw and my role

Unvote

I also wanted to prove my role, but it'll be revealed soon enough anyway

so you said this and then voted me because i gave a generous town read to doddsy?

in this keeping along the lines in which i play? do you not expect generous town reads from me?

not that i think it's generous. y'all really be slow. first post of the game hinting at your role and claiming it's interesting is not the same thing as flat out claiming hated townie. one is a direct claim to remove any type of pressure you can receive throughout the game becaues youve already claimed, making it less likely that a wagon picks up on you. the other is narrowing down your ability to fake. i mean unless he got some FANTASTIC fake claim that he just couldn't wait to share with everyone immediatel yupon entry.

This is fairly generous and not for very great reasons either.

Were you town last game? Were you the only one who was any good as per the usual? (no need to answer this)


I think this is a fair observation. I like this.


I dislike this. Do you want to bully a new (or newer?) player away from you already?

Not impressed by Magic here, by any means.
vote Magic

this is also shit because 1) i often go after new players regardless of alignment and 2) that was hardly anything.

should we just leave the new players to their own devices?

for the first time in what feels like forever, I like Poyser's opening posts. And I can't even tell you why exactly

i do like this tho cause gut town reads and not trying to fake reasoning is a good look.

@Showtime claim or die

no thank you. if your posts don't improve and don't look a shit attempt at replicating your entry from last game i'll probably push you. so far your best point was a shit comparison between doddsy claiming hated townie at the start of the game and doddsy's hint this game. failing to pick up what i was doing with lethal is also a bad look because youre looking at the game through a black and white lens without any nuance, aka typically a scum player that isn't looking to generate any reads.

 

[Death Meta Knight]

I agree in principle that it is 100% fruitless to talk about events that have yet to transpire. As I said, all are free to do as they wish, I don't particularly care however if my methods don't please some.

 

[CraigPelton]

I'm pleased, Death Meta Knight

 

[PHEN0M]

Vote Junk to win the duel.

 

[Poyser]

idk what i was supposed to be considering. can you explain to me please.



if this is your reasoning then this is pure shite.

yes, doddsy a few games ago claimed his role because it was a passive role that he had no control over. that's quite a bit different then hinting at an interesting role because 1) you can no longer claim vt 2) you cut out a bunch of other plain roles too. i dont think he's thinking that far in advance for his fake because it might not work out.

comparing that to claiming hated is kinda stupid breh.

i voted lethal because the only people that had posted were tkok, a bunch of noobs, and lethal and lethal has more overt reactions than i could expect from the rest(altho his reaction was kinda tame, i thought he would come at me more for voting him).

this is not a good look, especially since it just seems like you're reiterating your start from last game except replacing myself with odo.

You literally said claiming or hinting at your role so early points to town and I just showed you an example from the same player doing it as scum yes it was passive but it’s still a stupid read because you’ve just seen him do it. The role hes hinting at might be his real scum role. His real role could be interesting!

 

[Showtime]

Pretty sure Lethal is town.

Two games ago when Magic and Doddsy were co-scum and they decided to bus him, Magic said to him in thread that claiming Hated Town was a bad move cause it instantly tells scum not to waste their roles on him. In this game all of a sudden it's a good thing for Doddsy to talk about his role. @Showtime what's different here from two games ago?

he didn't claim a role.

he said he had an interesting role, which makes it more likely scum use a role on him, no?

what do you think of poyser?

 

[Odo]

he didn't claim a role.

he said he had an interesting role, which makes it more likely scum use a role on him, no?

what do you think of poyser?

I think you’re posting pure shite

 

[PHEN0M]

Interested to see what’s at the end of this Magic read back, will act accordingly from there. Still like my Kajuh direction. He seems to have disappeared.