The Horus Heresy: Mafia - Game Thread

[CraigPelton]

any chance we could just get the flip haha just kidding that of course would be inappropriate...

 

[Showtime]

I don't really like this vote can you come back and say what you think of lethal plz

why don't you like the vote?

 

[Tweet]

I'm outright saying it, there's no hidden intentions. So unsure exactly what you are getting at as I've made that clear twice now...

Regarding the character cop, agree to disagree. outed roles can't be trusted in the first place.

What I'm getting at is, you used this duel shot without consulting anyone and if Junk flips town, you somehow think that's a reason to look at Odo next. If you're this unsure about Odo, why use a duel based on HIS CASE in the first place?

 

[CraigPelton]

What I'm getting at is, you used this duel shot without consulting anyone and if Junk flips town, you somehow think that's a reason to look at Odo next. If you're this unsure about Odo, why use a duel based on HIS CASE in the first place?

twitter what % do you put Junk flipping MAFIA at?

 

[RDK]

Let's say Banez bickering about getting town read is also not something I see him doing as scum.

this is something I often use to scumhunt so regardless of the accuracy in certain circumstances I like the thought process as t

 

[Death Meta Knight]

What I'm getting at is, you used this duel shot without consulting anyone and if Junk flips town, you somehow think that's a reason to look at Odo next. If you're this unsure about Odo, why use a duel based on HIS CASE in the first place?

I see. Perhaps we are getting our wires crossed a bit here. I used the duel because I do believe junk is scum here. If she's not, considering how much Odo doubled down, it's more than reasonable to look in that direction. I don't really think there's anything inherently wrong with that line of thinking. One can agree with a case and be suspicious of it's source's validity at the same time. Those thoughts don't have to be mutually exclusive at all times, especially this early.

 

[Tweet]

twitter what % do you put Junk flipping MAFIA at?

If I gotta pick between mafia/indy, 75% indy, 25% mafia. Overall speaking about a 13.392117% chance to flip town.

 

[Junkette]

What did you expect Poyser? I’m at work and not claiming would just lead to the obvious stalling accusations

 

[Chris]

dont really like this based on my post to Poyser and the fact it's not only an assesment I don't really think aligns Magic's slot but also a parroted assessment

Eh, I thought Magic's town read was terrible too but it was more so that Poyser brought up how he and Doddsy both did this as scum a couple games ago and Magic would have known about it too.

But I think this is a good point on Alco, especially the part where he criticizes Magic for going after the new guy. Magic always goes after the new guys right? I was scum with him my second game and he even voted and questioned me early bc he said it's something he'd do as town. So idk why Alco was use that as a point to vote Magic at all

 

[Odo]

Anyone feel like hedging and lynching Jeff?

 

[Showtime]

Because it takes no consideration of the way that lethal plays

idk what i was supposed to be considering. can you explain to me please.

But magic’s town read on Doddsy is shit

we were both (me and doddsy) just scum with magic a couple games ago and both claimed in our first post lmao

also voting lethal for a nothing post is eh, he didn’t really say why that would make lethal scum specifically because about 95% of lethals posts are nothing (no offence )

if this is your reasoning then this is pure shite.

yes, doddsy a few games ago claimed his role because it was a passive role that he had no control over. that's quite a bit different then hinting at an interesting role because 1) you can no longer claim vt 2) you cut out a bunch of other plain roles too. i dont think he's thinking that far in advance for his fake because it might not work out.

comparing that to claiming hated is kinda stupid breh.

i voted lethal because the only people that had posted were tkok, a bunch of noobs, and lethal and lethal has more overt reactions than i could expect from the rest(altho his reaction was kinda tame, i thought he would come at me more for voting him).

this is not a good look, especially since it just seems like you're reiterating your start from last game except replacing myself with odo.

 

[CraigPelton]

If I gotta pick between mafia/indy, 75% indy, 25% mafia. Overall speaking about a 13.392117% chance to flip town.

these calculations check out you guys

now I'm worried

 

[CraigPelton]

what has Odo and Odo alone gotten us into here....

 

[Chris]

I see. Perhaps we are getting our wires crossed a bit here. I used the duel because I do believe junk is scum here. If she's not, considering how much Odo doubled down, it's more than reasonable to look in that direction. I don't really think there's anything inherently wrong with that line of thinking. One can agree with a case and be suspicious of it's source's validity at the same time. Those thoughts don't have to be mutually exclusive at all times, especially this early.

This kinda just feels like you haven't put any thought into why people would look at you if Junk flips town tbh which in a way feels towny, I've caught myself derping before at being pushed bc like I KNOW I'm town lmao

Guess it could also be viewed as opportunism to go after Odo if you know Junk's flip but that's pretty on the nose if so lol

 

[Death Meta Knight]

You are more than welcome to, however, I would remind you my duel doesn't end day, so you are free to wagon me post flip.