ROMANVM HISTORIVM: A Roman History Mafia Game Thread

[Poyser]

ugh re-reading TFW's initial posts about Chevy has me wavering again lol

What makes me think there’s good alignment potential is Chevys first post where he shaded the fuck out of TFW and then voted junk who hadn’t posted lmao

 

[RetepAdam.]

Wait and see mode?

I'm in wait-and-see mode on you.

 

[Poyser]

He did at the end re: Poyser.

Doesn’t mean much to me when Poyser had a firm grasp on when the hammer took place.

Fuck off, I called evans’ posts out as shite as soon as I saw them lol. I did largely prefer a TFW lynch but I was in two minds most of the day. To say I was only for lynching evans at the end is dishonest

 

[Poyser]

The fact that there’s now very likely a recruit makes mitch confirmed town or at the very least not mafia to me

 

[RetepAdam.]

Reads list because I don't know what is going to happen tonight and it's an easy reference point:

I have a lot of town reads and town leans, I'm expecting to be wrong on some of them. A lot of people looked good from this phase. So I definitely see some bussing there on Chevy.

Ace, Alco and Retep are people that I'd lean in to pushing. I'm like almost certain that Ace is scum and he should definitely be pushed.

1. CraigPelton - He was on Chevy real early and didn't feel like a bus, plus his posts have felt good and he's been involved. Feels like town CP, fairly happy with him.

2. Mitch - The census claim mostly. His play looked whatever, especially around Chevy. I just don't see it being a Mafia role, although I could be wrong. I wouldn't lynch him at any rate. The way he claimed was also very similar to last game, just blurting it out with not much pressure. Felt like a town motivation.

3. Blaine - His reaction and aggression towards Ace/Tweet pushing on him looked town and he's been involved like his town self. Looks good.

5. Flay - Null but he's not pinging me as scummy at least.

6. Alco - Thought his early play looked bad and found his posts around Chevy weird. Keep an eye on him, possibly just an inactive thing. I've been wrong on Alco twice so not putting a lot of stake in it.

7. Doddsy - Null, early posts were fairly easy to make and didn't tell me much, didn't look bad or anything. I have no thoughts.

8. Ace - I'm certain he's scum. Look at his Throwback Music Mafia gameplay, I feel like it's so similar. Plus the easy slide in Blaine vote and dipping for all day phase.

9. Lethal - His posts looked town, and he came in to the game well I thought.

10. Tweet - Fairly obvious. He was on Chevy like wildfire, not a buss. Felt natural and just a good read.

11. Magic - I liked him pushing the Chevy lynch through. His early play wasn't anything to write home about, but I lean town on Magic. Could be a bus but Magic could have easily lynched me off with Odo if he wanted to.

12. Odo - His hard lock read of me and certainty I'll flip scum seems town, not sure he'd go through all that effort if he knew I was gonna flip town. Plus his general posting style and demenaor just feels town imo.

13. Retep - I didn't like his stuff around Chevy. I wouldn't push him before Ace, but he hasn't really looked town to me.

14. Wang - Play looks pretty identical to his last game as town and seems natural to me, that reads list felt like he just laid all his cards on the table. I feel comfortable he's town at this juncture.

15. TP - Seems more reserved, but gut read is town.

17. Junk - The way Chevy went at her, could be a bus I suppose. I liked that she didn't hide from confrontation.

18. Poyser - Feels town because he's hard locked on me like Odo is, but I haven't got strong towny vibes like I have with Odo tbh. He's one to keep an eye on.

Don't say I didn't do anything friends

Peace

You have town reads on literally everyone but five players (and yourself)?

 

[Odo]

I'm in wait-and-see mode on you.

oh, that makes more sense. Though I then ha e to question why that’s a bad place for what you would describe as a noteworthy player to be in - when surely it’s always going to be harder to pin down any strong player?

 

[Junkette]

Fuck off, I called evans’ posts out as shite as soon as I saw them lol. I did largely prefer a TFW lynch but I was in two minds most of the day. To say I was only for lynching evans at the end is dishonest

Yea yea I get that, but it was clear you favoured TFW, town read on TFW aside what are the actual odds the two leading wagons on day one are both on scum? Honestly legit asking if someone wants to attempts to check the odds on that notion

 

[Marty McFourth]

i dont think it's mitch, i could see the other two, in particular doddsy.

Me neither. Mitch blurted out his claim exactly like he did in Dr. Who Mafia when he was the town Vig.

 

[Junkette]

Basically wouldn’t put it past you bussing there either boy given the wagon. So the swing in favour of TFW makes me feel weird about you tbh.

 

[RetepAdam.]

The fact that there’s now very likely a recruit makes mitch confirmed town or at the very least not mafia to me

Why are we running with this so hard based on a character cop perk?

Also,

Four times per game, you may choose to protect a player at night. If that player is also protected by an active power, both protections will negate.

This seems like it's going to be pertinent later.

 

[Poyser]

Yea yea I get that, but it was clear you favoured TFW, town read on TFW aside what are the actual odds the two leading wagons on day one are both on scum? Honestly legit asking if someone wants to attempts to check the odds on that notion

In pure mathematical terms it’s obviously unlikely but that’s pretty irrelevant when taking play into account lol

I’m wavering on TFW tbh I’m not gonna lie, just with the sheer amount of effort hes put forth even whilst knowing he’s probably gonna be dead soon. I do still think a lot of his posts in the first half of day were bad and I also think there’s pretty good alignment potential with him and evans but I dunno, I’m questioning

I also don’t really hate his ace read tbh

 

[Junkette]

I’d say odds are very much unlikely a towncore has two scum as there leading wagons on day 1. Maybe this is the GOAT town but I doubt that tbh.

 

[Marty McFourth]

Instinct is that Alco is town, so among the low post count dossers, I’d prefer Doddsy/Mitch/Ace in no particular order

I don't really see what Alco has done to get a town read tbh, although my track record at correctly reading him is shite lol

His posts felt wallpapery and the sheep vote seemed more hesitant than usual for him, idk. I trust my Ace read more over him.

 

[Junkette]

In pure mathematical terms it’s obviously unlikely but that’s pretty irrelevant when taking play into account lol

I’m wavering on TFW tbh I’m not gonna lie, just with the sheer amount of effort hes put forth even whilst knowing he’s probably gonna be dead soon. I do still think a lot of his posts in the first half of day were bad and I also think there’s pretty good alignment potential with him and evans but I dunno, I’m questioning

I also don’t really hate his ace read tbh

Honestly added Ace to my isolation pile because of TFW

 

[Junkette]

Could be something there for sure.