Royal Rumble Rate Royal Rumble 2017

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Rate this year's Royal Rumble


  • Total voters
    38

C.M. Shaddix

The Architect
Hotshot
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
5,106
Reaction score
962
Points
0
Age
27
Location
Suplex City BITCH
Vince is this high on Orton that he actually does that... I'm declaring it a curse now that we will never be happy with a rumble match again

I can't even imagine how big the boos were for Reigns at 30. It should of been Joe.
 

RedDwarfTechy

WWEF's Resident Hologram
Joined
Apr 4, 2014
Messages
3,906
Reaction score
1,987
Points
113
Location
Parts Unknown
4/10

AJ and Cena were amazing.

Kevin and Roman were great.

The other matches were okay....

The Rumble let me down. I feel like they should have had at least one person be a surprise and so many other wrestlers deserved to win over Orton. I am sorry but that just ruined it for me.

This is exactly how I feel.

Cena and AJ stole the show, and even though I'd have preferred AJ winning, the loss was done in such an awesome way. The Rumble itself? just boring and drawn out. The highlight being the entire New Day being eliminated and Baron Corbin getting legitimised with a massive elemination in Strauman.

Zayne/Jericho should have won, they held on that long for such crappy eliminations too. Just a shame.

It's not like Randy needs it, he's got his own thing going, I'd much rather see one of those feuds, JeriKo splitting up and feuding or Zayne and KO going back at it at the grandest stage of them all.

This is just.... meh.

I don't mind Cena as champion but please god someone beat him at Elimination Chamber, I really don't want another Cena vs Orton >.<
 

Prince Bálor

I'm kind of a big deal
Joined
Apr 27, 2014
Messages
24,384
Reaction score
6,635
Points
0
Location
Serbia
Royal Rumble was good. 7/10

- The pre-show matches were solid. The 6-woman tag is obviously leading to the women's EC, the tag title match was rock solid and Nia vs Sasha was short, but effective.
As for the tag title match: I was a bit surprised G&A dethroned Sheamus and Cesaro and on the pre-show nonetheless, but here we are. Imagine how awesome it would've been if G&A won the titles months ago upon their debut. But, better late than never, I guess.

- Charlotte vs Bayley was good for what it was. ★★★
I wasn't invested in this match at all, because I don't watch RAW's women's division anymore and the tradition known as "CharloteWinsLOL 'cause it's a PPV" ain't bringing me back in. Other than that, the work was a little sloppy in places, but overall good. The finish was nice, also.

- Kevin Owens vs Roman Reigns was very good. ★★★¾
Unlike previous Reigns/KO matches that have felt lifeless, this one was quite good and Reigns and Owens tore it up. The match had a good pace and energy and it felt like these guys hated each other. KO retaining surprised the hell out of me, man. I thought Reigns was going to win despite the shenanigans, but ultimately, KO retained and I'm glad I was wrong. Now, I'm looking forward to the inevitable JeriKO break-up.

- Neville vs Rich Swann was good. ★★★
It would've been much better if the crowd was invested, but the match was good and the finish was cool. Hopefully Neville can salvage the division now.

- John Cena vs AJ Styles was fantastic and MOTN. ★★★★½
I absolutely loved this match and it was easily the best thing on the show. It had a big fight feel, great pacing, the crowd was really invested, the near falls were great, some good callbacks to their previous outings, they traded submissions, Cena's facial expressions and the teasing of a heel turn was also great. Styles was great as always, too, and was put over huge despite losing. No complaints.

- The Royal Rumble match was good. ★★★
Far from a great Rumble, but it still entertained me. Things really started to pick up once Strowman entered. And since we're on the subject, I thought they really did a great job with him when he was out there and also protected him when he got eliminated. Corbin eliminating Strowman was great, btw. The dude went full speed and hit a Clothesline and it felt real.

Lesnar's run was fun, and his interaction with Goldberg was good, I must admit, as was the Goldberg/Taker interaction.

Sami Zayn should've been the Ironman, but oh well. Y2J's run wasn't bad, though.

One of the disappointing things was that they brought Reigns back in, but didn't have him get his revenge on Strowman. However, having Reigns eliminate Taker was interesting and probably sets up a match for WM, and this is wishful thinking, but we may finally see a heel Reigns.

Also, the most disappointing thing was the lack of surprise entrants. Tye entering at #10 was perfect, but it was also predictable and we called it like 2 months ago. The reason I love the Rumble is because of surprise entries and we didn't get those this year as much as everyone would've wanted.

Now, as for the winner, Randy Orton, I like him and I do not mind him winning, but it felt a little bit underwhelming given the options they could've gone with. Although having Orton win opens up quite a few possibilities for Mania given that EC is just around a corner. So, we'll see.

All in all, I liked this show.
 
  • Like
Reactions: alexb

alexb

The Lunatic Fringe
Joined
Mar 4, 2014
Messages
628
Reaction score
678
Points
0
Age
48
January 10th:

"The sad thing about it is they are making it so obvious that Roman is winning the title at the Rumble, it ain't even funny so I guess we shall brace ourselves for a chorus of boos at the Alamodome. On the flipside, I guess there's some good to this given that if he does indeed win the title, that'll keep him away from the Rumble match itself.........unlessssss..... he somehow fails to win and enters himself in the Rumble after all; :bige3:bet you guys would love that;:bully: I should probably shut up and not give WWE any weird ideas. :steph::psycho::eek:hyeah:"



Well, I guess we shall now have to wonder if any excecutives from WWE are actually following this forum cause unless I missed it somewhere else, I certainly didn't hear or read such a prediction from anyone else; and trust me, I had a listen to several podcasts these past couple of weeks. Just to be clear, this obviously has nothing to do with me trying to brag or anything. Believe me, as soon as Roman's music hit at number #30 I was very very dissapointed and it actually felt dreadful to be right but I guess we avoided total disaster after all with Orton finally being the one to win it.

Overall, I feel "underwhelming" is the best word to describe this year's Royal Rumble match which is why I rated the PPV with a 5/10. As many fellow members already noted, it sucked that we didn't have any real surprises, which has always been a tradition and I guess the biggest dissapointment of all was probably the absence of Samoe Joe...unless the idea is to have him show up on RAW tonight and make his debut there instead. Perhaps an angle with Rollins, as in a hired gun for HHH?

Elsewhere, giving Baron Corbin the Strowman elimination I felt was brilliant, Kofi's traditional spot felt like it really hurt, was glad to see the King back on commentary (even for just one night) and...Taker vs Roman for Mania??? I really can't say I am thrilled about this but if they indeed go down this route, I guess the bright side is that Roman stays out of the title picture and/or...bet yet...turns heel?

As for the rest of the card, most matches were very good and I guess the only thing that really surprised me was Anderson & Gallows winning the RAW tag champs. Idk, it kind of feels like too little too late for these guys but hey, let's give them a chance.








 

jbirch20

Jobber
Joined
Jan 17, 2017
Messages
3
Reaction score
3
Points
0
Age
28
Location
Leeds
Just wondering what your guys opinion on this years Rumble was? Personally thought it was amazing! Knew Charlotte would win, it's far too soon for Bayley, Reigns v Owens was quality along with the sexy piñata and the WWE Championship match between AJ Styles and John Cena was incredible. Very happy. As for the Rumble itself, I personally enjoyed it! This might not go down too well but I love Roman Reigns! Having said that though, I would've loved to have seen some legends return and a Balor return. Still loved it!
 

Solid Snake

New Member
Champion
Joined
Jun 4, 2016
Messages
51,392
Reaction score
19,899
Points
0
Just wondering what your guys opinion on this years Rumble was? Personally thought it was amazing! Knew Charlotte would win, it's far too soon for Bayley, Reigns v Owens was quality along with the sexy piñata and the WWE Championship match between AJ Styles and John Cena was incredible. Very happy. As for the Rumble itself, I personally enjoyed it! This might not go down too well but I love Roman Reigns! Having said that though, I would've loved to have seen some legends return and a Balor return. Still loved it!

Moved your post here, we already have a full running thread to share thoughts. Feel free to read through it to see what members felt and rate the RR in the poll. :bodallas:
 
  • Like
Reactions: jbirch20

TheAceOne

The Artiste
Joined
Oct 25, 2016
Messages
164
Reaction score
55
Points
0
Age
40
Location
London, United Kingdom
There were only two good things to come from the show: the WWE Title and Cruiserweight Title matches.

The WWE Title match was world class. Cena and Styles have amazing in ring chemistry. I could watch them wrestle all day. As for the Cruiserweight Title match: I'm glad Neville won. He deserves to be a Champion.

The Royal Rumble match itself was very poor.There were no surprise entries. Absolutely none. The action was mediocre at best. It goes down as my least favourite Rumble match.

Roman Reigns`s appearance just made things worse. Because of Vince`s stubbornness in trying to get Roman over, we now have Roman facing Taker at Wrestlemania, instead of the match we all want to see, Taker vs Cena.

In his mind, he thinks that because we respect Taker, we will like Roman aswell, just because he will be in a feud with him. He thinks were that easy. The fact is, Roman will never be popular. It is what it is. But Vince won't accept it.

Even Tye Dillinger's appearance, which I was very excited for, was very underwhelming. He got eliminated too quickly.

Huge fan favourites Sheamus and Cesaro lost their Tag Titles to a team that gets almost zero reaction from the audience.

It turns out that Vince doesn't listen to what the fans really want. He just does what he wants, and takes us for granted.

Overall, I give the show a 4/10
 

WholeFN'Moe

The Architect
Hotshot
Joined
Nov 4, 2016
Messages
2,524
Reaction score
646
Points
0
Age
38
Location
Moncton, New Brunswick, CA
they fucked it up big time.

EVERYTHING WAS STUPID IN THAT RUMBLE MATCH.....

Did anyone else btw, notice Ziggler come in as a full heel & proceed to superkick every single other heel in the match?

Can you BE ANY WORSE at your job... that guy might be more annoying than Roman.

Also was just thinking about Roman being in it after he lost his Title match.... BUT AJ WASN'T?!

At the very least could they not have BOTH been in it? ....AJ should have been number 3 again, would have been awesome.
 
Last edited:

Grievous 3D

Is Currently In Stasis
Banned
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
14,732
Reaction score
10,647
Points
0
Age
42
Location
Townsville, Queensland, Australia
The real kicker about Reigns being in the Rumble is it may-be the first time in Rumble
history that a challenger for a World (level) title has been entered into the Rumble after
failing to capture the title...

Seth Rollins & John Cena were not entered into the Rumble in 2015...
John Cena was not entered in the Rumble in 2014...(Neither were Bray Wyatt or Daniel Bryan)
Dolph Ziggler was not entered in the Rumble in 2012...

Oh...well...would you look at that...it has happened before...in 2011...and that guy was...
Randy Orton...lol

Research is interesting...but perhaps they had an excuse that year considering they had
a 40 man Rumble that year.

I'm just shocked they actually had Reigns in the match...

May-be Vince/WWE is just using Roman to "troll" the fan at this point?

Reigns vs. Undertaker at Wrestlemania? I'm sorry...but that could turn out to be the worst
match on the card. Combining the fans hatred of Roman with the fact that the Undertaker
looks like he struggling to move...Ugh...I'd rather see Strowman/Roman at Wrestlemania
with Strowman crushing Reigns...but...who really knows at this point?

Strowman/Roman at Fastlane with Taker costing Reigns the match could be the set up?

I like Orton winning the Rumble...but...I haven't been around for the last 15 years...so...
I'm guessing him winning may piss off a few long time fans.

The Elimination Chamber Pay Per View should be interesting...

Cena, Styles, Wyatt, Harper, Corbin & Ziggler in the Chamber for the World title?
Ambrose/Miz for the IC Title?
Alexa, Becky, Mickie, Naomi, Nikki & Natalya in the Chamber for the Women's title?
American Alpha vs. ??? for the tag titles?

Actually...may-be they'll go with 3 separate women's matches to "fill out" the card?

Just thinking out loud...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Solidus1 and Vicka

Grievous 3D

Is Currently In Stasis
Banned
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
14,732
Reaction score
10,647
Points
0
Age
42
Location
Townsville, Queensland, Australia
I've really got my fingers crossed for Roman to get injured by Strowman before WM
That's a horrible thing to say...but I agree...

God...Imagine 6 months or a year without Reigns around...I wonder who'd get the "big push"?

Strowman I guess...but I am slowly warming up to Strowman...he was the star performer on
the entire Rumble PPV...
 

Gembo

The Showoff
Joined
Dec 4, 2016
Messages
1,343
Reaction score
82
Points
0
Age
21
Location
Glasgow, Scotland, GB
I have the unpopular opinion, I'm giving it an 8 out of 10. I thought the Charlotte vs Bayley match was good, a few botches at the start but ultimately there were some good spots. Neville vs Swann was a great match, as was Cena vs Styles, and the Kevin Owens vs Roman Reigns match was pretty good, even though the stipulation didn't make much sense. I think the rumble had some good bits and some bad bits. While it didn't really have any big surprises and its debatable whether Randy Orton should've won or not, it had the Undertaker and Goldberg fighting at the end, everything Brock did in it, and, most importantly in my opinion, LUKE HARPER TURNED FACE, but no one seems to mention it, he attacked both Randy and Bray and set up a feud between him and either Randy or Bray. Here's something to think about, Luke Harper will probably get a world title run in the next two months, so he can face Randy in the main event of Wrestlemania.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Snowman1

Grievous 3D

Is Currently In Stasis
Banned
Joined
Sep 30, 2016
Messages
14,732
Reaction score
10,647
Points
0
Age
42
Location
Townsville, Queensland, Australia
LUKE HARPER TURNED FACE, but no one seems to mention it, he attacked both Randy and Bray and set up a feud between him and either Randy or Bray. Here's something to think about, Luke Harper will probably get a world title run in the next two months, so he can face Randy in the main event of Wrestlemania.
I'm pretty sure that title run will go to Bray before Harper...and it wouldn't surprise me if Harper sides with Orton against a heel Bray...