Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

[Alco]

Lethal gave Tweet an easy town read > was interrogated about it > his explanation was not cash money. (he's giving Tweet a town lean out of caution and trust? )

Seems like a pretty good argument to me, to be honest.

 

[Xenus]

Lethal gave Tweet an easy town read > was interrogated about it > his explanation was not cash money. (he's giving Tweet a town lean out of caution and trust? )

Seems like a pretty good argument to me, to be honest.

Isn’t lethal’s point that he’s trusting him for now but is cautious about it? That’s the way I read it.
Either way, why does that easy town read make you suss of him? Is he buddying Tweet? Are he and Tweet aligned? Is he trying to deflect the pressure? You’re not giving much here as to actual reasons for the vote.

 

[Alco]

Isn’t lethal’s point that he’s trusting him for now but is cautious about it? That’s the way I read it.
Either way, why does that easy town read make you suss of him? Is he buddying Tweet? Are he and Tweet aligned? Is he trying to deflect the pressure? You’re not giving much here as to actual reasons for the vote.

Ah I read it differently then.

From my point of view it's a good guy read of Tweet.
I don't think there was much pressure on Lethal yesterday? So no, that's not it.

I have a pretty okay record of reading Lethal, so there's a portion of feeling involved too.

Also it's not at all about the italic font lol, I'm not an idiot.

 

[Xenus]

Ah I read it differently then.

From my point of view it's a good guy read of Tweet.
I don't think there was much pressure on Lethal yesterday? So no, that's not it.

I have a pretty okay record of reading Lethal, so there's a portion of feeling involved too.

Also it's not at all about the italic font lol, I'm not an idiot.

Good guy in what sense? The pressure I was referring to was from Tweet as lethal specifically mentions that the read is given in spite of Tweet sussing him.

I haven’t mentioned the italics when it comes to your read. That helped me formulate my own opinion on Lethal and has no bearing on your post - I think that looks good for lethal (WIFOM) and I don’t see any reason to relate that to reading him as scummy.

 

[Xenus]

The Lethal lean on Tweet was actually even earlier than I thought it was. The wagon appears to be based on something that happened 24 hours ago when there was still 8 hours left in Day. Why was this not picked up yesterday if it’s a great case? I don’t see it.

However; im wrong on my interpretation of Lethal’s lean on tweet being cautiously town. Reading back on it I’m not sure what he’s on about either. I just don’t think the basis of a good wagon 12 hours into D2 is a town lean 24 hours ago when we’ve had a kill and a lynch.

 

[Xenus]

I also think it’s telling that the OMB lynch seems to have died a death. No one wants to confirm the split now, despite there being only one death?

the only reason you have a census in a game is if there’s shenanigans with the split and Odo knows this. 15/5/1/1 is a pretty tame split, so I’m assuming a recruiter or two SK’s? But no one has even mentioned this despite a vanilla N1.

 

[Ace]

I also think it’s telling that the OMB lynch seems to have died a death. No one wants to confirm the split now, despite there being only one death?

the only reason you have a census in a game is if there’s shenanigans with the split and Odo knows this. 15/5/1/1 is a pretty tame split, so I’m assuming a recruiter or two SK’s? But no one has even mentioned this despite a vanilla N1.

From my side OMB is a decent lynch target we can fall back on and be guaranteed some useful information if there is nothing more interesting that comes up.

But I'm not gonna insta-push OMB now as there is nothing new we're gonna get from him.

For me at least, OMB was always a "better than no-lynch" lynch rather than a massive scumread.

 

[Xenus]

From my side OMB is a decent lynch target we can fall back on and be guaranteed some useful information if there is nothing more interesting that comes up.

But I'm not gonna insta-push OMB now as there is nothing new we're gonna get from him.

For me at least, OMB was always a "better than no-lynch" lynch rather than a massive scumread.

Good post Have a town read.

 

[Chloe B]

Hmm few wagon options...

 

[Chloe B]

Xenus can be town.

Because of Effort FC?

Be honest how much of his stuff have you actually read

 

[Roy Mustang]

Unvote

Just won’t make my own reads anymore and sheep. Let me know who to vote.

vote: phenom

Sent from my SM-A202F using Tapatalk

 

[Xenus]

My thoughts on people below, in case anyone wants an opinion or to question me given my absence yesterday. Cba to use colours on a phone:

Alco - not a fan of his reaction to the push on lethal, but feel he was jumped on for his colour-gate. Null.

Evans - role seems town provided the split is correct. Could see this as a scum role if they have a recruiter. Lean town based on the Smark interaction - reminds me of him tunnelling me over the magic thing in tiger king.

CP - Again not a fan of the lethal push based on something that happened 24 hours ago and to me appears innocuous. Capable of doing the magic test wagon as scum or town.

Ace - (I messed up the order cause my paste button isn’t working on the phone version) His reaction to my OMB post pushes him into a town lean. Makes a justifiable case for the lynch without pushing it too much.

Jeff - would push. Not impressed with his entry on D1 (although accept he was busy) and he did push the Haza wagon and has got zero suspicion for it other than from Doddsy. A good option.

Lethal - Null but will be telling if he flips later on and could unlock the game in terms of interactions.

Barry - like this thinking on Phenom, but offered very little else.

Tweet - I’ve made my thoughts clear. Vote is on.

Smark - probably town.

TKOK - Null

Phenom - backed down way too easily on what was a blah push on Poyser/Magic. Could be lazy town which would fit the meta.

OMB - census with a blah result. I’d be surprised if he was faking the result though - would need to be led to this by someone better (sorry I know this isn’t very but it’s true.

Magic v.2 - nothing to go on.

Gambit - town lean. Good ideas and showing independent thought. Seems to be trying to work things out (e.g. Flay)

Doddsy - same as Gambit sans Flay.

Chloe - messed up his claim and reappeared at end of Day, but that’s very Flay. I’m torn but not leaning town; probably in the “would lynch” pile.

Rugrat - underwhelming. Nothing to go on save for the standard boring D1 push on a town magic. Would support a push.

Big Man - good early game but underwhelming later. Pushed the Haza lynch despite having very little involvement before it (yes I know I did this too, but I know my intentions were good and I don’t know this about others). Not commented on Flay much despite pushing that wagon whilst Gambit and I worked out the claim. Wagon for wagon’s sake?

Brutus - who?

That’s the most detailed reads list you’ll get so feel free to come at me on it.

 

[Odo]

Day 2 Vote Count 1

CP 1 - Chloe
Lethal 4 - CP, Tweet, Magic, Alco
Xenus 1 - Big Man
Phenom 2 - Barry, Gambit
Jeff 2 - Doddsy, Phenom
Tweet 1 - Xenus

Corrected an error in time remaining - Day 2 will last 30 hours. You therefore have just under 16 hours remaining. 11 votes to lynch.​

 

[Comrade Khan]

coffee and read back time

 

[Lethal]

Before I post my catchup input and such, I'm a little bit disappointed that people are falsely proficising my thoughts and such.

My LEAN on Tweets is based on him not being so transparent as to implicate himself in the EV/Smark exchange. I am cautious of Tweet though, as I am almost always suss of him for some reason and which to actually give it a chance this game to see if I can find town points of his. But sure, dance around my point and start a wagon from misunderstanding a point that I've clarified....3 times already? Good grief.