Norse Mythology Mafia - Game Thread

  • Welcome to "The New" Wrestling Smarks Forum!

    I see that you are not currently registered on our forum. It only takes a second, and you can even login with your Facebook! If you would like to register now, pease click here: Register

    Once registered please introduce yourself in our introduction thread which can be found here: Introduction Board


Status
Not open for further replies.

Alco

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2020
Messages
4,097
Reaction score
545
Points
113
Age
34
Anyway, I can agree with the Lethal direction, to be honest. CP's point especially, speaks to me.

vote Lethal
 

Xenus

Active Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2020
Messages
639
Reaction score
96
Points
28
Location
England
I’m back :jericho

The Magic kill isn’t as interesting as people make out IMO. People are bald cowards :hogansun because Magic is a tough lynch and comes into the game later on so they wanted him out of the game. I don’t understand the approach of looking at people Magic has sussed (he was pushing for a no lynch at end of D1) as Magic usually works off town reads and POE’s the game early. With Poyser not in play early, look for the people who are trying to control the narrative, not the ones Magic was pushing - it feels like a misdirection. I’ll look at this, but in the meantime

:risingangle

Jeff, Tweet, Barry, Gambit, Big Man, Xenus, Phenom, OMB, CP, Ace, EV

This is the wagon in comparison with my n1 reads. Wouldn't mind pushing Xenus, I think there's a decent chance that Lethal and he are teamed tho so idc which of the two I currently gotta vote.

This is odd. Gonna actually throw down any sort of opinion there Tweet? So far you “wouldn’t mind pushing” me. Why? What’s tweaked you about me in the 24 hours I’ve been away? If you’re going to say something you need to back it up because this feels like you’re just nudging things along and seeing what sticks without actually doing anything and hedging your bets between me and Lethal because apparently we are aligned? Scummy play. Why do you think Lethal and me are aligned, what about either of our play leads you to that opinion, because I don’t think I’ve even commented on lethal (more on that later) and vice versa?

Vote Xenus

I didn't like his early play around me and I've seen a few people indicate they're reading him scum. he said he liked me off very little, all I did was call out a contradiction by Barry which would be very simple to do as scum which seemed to outweigh him not liking that I was in the thread and didn't post and also he called the flay direction an easy target which I started which would be another reason not to like me.

I don’t have to agree with your wagon, despite thinking you made good points early. I liked the posts you made around Barry, but I had my own direction that I liked at the point of the Flay wagon and lent my vote to it (note, I say direction, not wagon - I’m not claiming to have created the case or led it). Flay is an easy D1 wagon and you know it’s happened a hundred times because he’s naturally an ass, especially as town. In fact, I actually like Flay less from his play around the end of Day - not just because he appeared literally as Day ended, but he also started analysing the wagon on Haza (half heartedly in my view) and seemed much more involved, whereas town Flay would create chaos. You haven’t mentioned Flay since. What are your thoughts on Flay now? If it helps your thought process, I like you a lot less now than I did then.

I’ll comment on the lethal points separately as there’s a limit to what I can quote and find on my phone.
 

Xenus

Active Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2020
Messages
639
Reaction score
96
Points
28
Location
England
He’s Poyser now right? Going back to my main read from Day 1, no scum deaths yet so no way for me to formulate reads off interactions.

With regards to lethal, i do agree with those who said that his Italics gimmick at the start of the game draws attention to him, which I don’t think he’d be fond of as scum. Those kind of attention grabbing things early game i always tend to lean towards the town side of the line.

How is Poyser your main scum read on D2 when he’s had a total of 5 posts? Why would you not let this breathe and see how Magic v.2 behaves to see if you can formulate an actual read, rather than pushing someone who had no involvement D1 due to actual personal issues?
 

Ace

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
2,936
Reaction score
467
Points
83
Age
29
It's not even pre-emptive anymore, Ace :p

You've made this post like 3 times already now, just worded differently. So self-aware.
Because people keep asking me about my vote even though it would clear if they just read back through my posts.
 

Xenus

Active Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2020
Messages
639
Reaction score
96
Points
28
Location
England
Start of the lethal “wagon” is here.

vote Lethal

I'll add raisins later when I have time or someone else can do it for me if they feel the same

there’s no reasons and offers others the chance to look at it - bait or seeing what sticks, because I can’t see a reason to vote Lethal?

I agree CP saying he's sus of Magic only to then shoot him is a weird move, it's pretty WIFOMy tho, I don't even wanna go down that rabbit hole. I got no complaints with him outside that either so I don't see myself looking that direction anytime soon

vote Lethal

So you’re sussing CP but then following him on Lethal with no reasons added - so why? What are your reasons?

You’re nudging things along again in a very non-committal way as you did with me.

He’s Poyser now right? Going back to my main read from Day 1, no scum deaths yet so no way for me to formulate reads off interactions.

With regards to lethal, i do agree with those who said that his Italics gimmick at the start of the game draws attention to him, which I don’t think he’d be fond of as scum. Those kind of attention grabbing things early game i always tend to lean towards the town side of the line.

If you’re not sure whether Magic was Poyser how had you already voted him at this point?

I explained my problem with his post progression wrt to Jeff. Sometimes my reads come off of it feeling odd while reading over it, especially that early. Its why i went after Jeff last game in the first 10 pages (who was non-town). It’s not a way of reading people that’s always easy for me to explain but i try to do my best.

My problem is that you don’t actually do this from my knowledge of your game. You do things as scum and not as town. This could be you being lazy with just pushing along the same thing based off the first 5 pages and still keeping on it 100 pages later, but I think there might be something more to this. I want to hear your reasons for voting Magic v.

Idk, most of what went on with Poyser and Jeff happened within the first like 4 hours of the game, so that's cold coffee by now, but I know you'll do you regardless. Never change N0M :pals:

Oh look non-committal shading. What a shock

I agree with the N0M read tbh, so...

Official Vote: N0M

I've explained my reasoning for why I think N0M could be scum last dayphase. Much of his reasoning feels lazy and without bothering to look for any context so as to absolve himself of any real culpability to his nudges. Dunno bout you guys, but I like this direction for now.
This looks good for Barry - thinking similar things


Not feeling Lethal atm

Would prefer

Vote Jeff

Because he was on the wagon and as I said I feel like he's been going for low hanging fruit all game, wouldn't mind some further info
I like this from Doddsy. Going a completely different direction and asking the right questions. Why has no one even mentioned Jeff when Haza was his wagon? I supported that wagon completely and I’m not saying otherwise, but it’s strange that we’ve had 12 hours of wagon analysis and not once has anyone mentioned the person who actually pushed it the most. Points for Doddsy

that's the best argument against Lethal i've seen all day. This I can follow.
Anyway, I can agree with the Lethal direction, to be honest. CP's point especially, speaks to me.

vote Lethal
What argument? There is literally nothing there. How is that the best argument you’ve seen all day that he didn’t answer Phenom’s push properly?
 

Xenus

Active Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2020
Messages
639
Reaction score
96
Points
28
Location
England
I’m not voting Lethal. There is nothing there and the fact that he enters the thread writing in italics automatically bringing attention to himself, I don’t see. I don’t know a huge amount about his meta but I barely noticed him in the Tiger King game until he counter claimed me as a bloody Skitzo.

Vote Tweet

I want to see this out.
 

Xenus

Active Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2020
Messages
639
Reaction score
96
Points
28
Location
England
vote tweet


sure, let's do this since im doing nothing and nothing is bad.


cp can you do the wagon analysis thing, plz n ty.
vote lethal

i meant this lol

I missed this off the lethal post because I missed it the first time - for full disclosure. This isn’t very “Magic”, why are you pushing this along? I know what I’m expecting you to say, but I also know you’re smart enough to know I know too. You POE the game using town reads not scum reads, so you’re happy to push lethal because you don’t know he’s town blah blah. It just feels very underwhelming when there’s a lot of options on the table.

How do you feel about Tweet? Phenom? Big Man? Jeff? Me?

Wait, what?
I mean I’m really not sure how you don’t understand things that are explained in the posts that you quote. This isn’t the first time you’ve done this either this game.
 

PHEN0M

GOATNOM
Joined
Dec 16, 2019
Messages
3,977
Reaction score
979
Points
113
Age
34
Unvote

Just won’t make my own reads anymore and sheep. Let me know who to vote.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.