No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Lethal]

T-Pein, while we're here and most others aren't. What's your logic? What drives you to vote one person over another?

SHOOK

Interesting that you're into Pein on this. You know how Pein is, no?

 

[Lethal]

Why does Lethal vs Jeff early seemed fake? Why are we getting heated over nothing?

You read the discussion, no?

 

[Lethal]

The towniest town told me we were voting you. Do you disagree with my vote? What have you done that's townie this game? What are your current reads?

Interesting stance given how few posts he'd made. I like the line of questioning though so it's nai for now

 

[Lethal]

Let's talk something non-boring

What is your current main theory at the moment regarding Lethal? Jeff? Mando? Abigail? T-Pein? Pick any number of them

I want to see where this is going. I want to town lean you here through provoking people.

Oh, okay, you're trolling. Good to know

We had difference of opinion on Juice's intentions so he just voted me

How was he trolling? Interesting jump to a conclusion there.

What thoughts do you have so far? What makes it typical?

According to one person here (Lethal), it is not typical.

Yeah it could be considered typical - these games tend to start off with fluff and then settles into a flow. Fluff is a waste of time and stat padding so I want to skip it asap

 

[Lethal]

Gave 3 theories about a previous interaction (Lethal/me and Jeff) that read to me as fence-sitting to cast aspersions on as many people as possible. T-Pein disagreed and that's why he voted me

+1

 

[Lethal]

Sigh, you guys just don't let me play fun, do you? I have zero read in Tpein because I have read zero of his posts before he tagged me. I'm just coming in and seeing what kind of interactions I can make.

But you followed his vote? I'm confused by your approach here.

 

[Lethal]

I’m interested to explore this a bit more. I saw you said that it was the lack of favouring one option over the others that prompted you to read it as Juice sitting on the fence.

My view of it was that Juice was actually giving us a lot to talk through and had the discussion veered onto discussing the options we could have gotten some decent stuff out of it.

Is there no credit from you for actually producing the options and extra discussion points, even though Juice didn’t elaborate or rank them in order of probability?

I vibe with this thinking. Juice gave something to go off, even if it's a little odd in the approach. Rather than discussing it, she's attacking it. Interesting.

juice said similar so that's a bit pingy. What felt fake about it?

I'm interested in this answer as well

 

[Lethal]

This seems like a much more viable reason as to why you waited to ask the question. I'm not sure why you chose to lead with the first response before swtiching to this.

Could infer that she was told to rephrase it to prevent unnecessary suspicion

 

[Lethal]

Let's answer that by looking through the 3 options:

1. Mafia is prolonging the dumb Lethal/Jeff argument in order to harm town - subtle bit of shade on everyone involved in the argument, implying that one or more of Lethal/Jeff/myself is scum so town will vote among us and probably hit at least 2/3 town.
2. Lethal is trying to get voted up - we don't benefit from Jester spec at this early stage, it's just a distraction.
3. This is all just town/town D1 fodder - obvious ass coverage "there could be, or there could not be", trying to seem noncommittal for later.

All 3 options, though discussion points they may be, are inherently non-productive (and serve to further scum's cause in the first two cases), and not distinguishing between them is somehow worse than committing to one of them. That's the full explanation

- Huh? If wolves are prolonging the argument, why were people telling us to chill?
- The jester speculation is just garbage from my POV. If I were jester I'd be trolling more than an argument with Jeff over a nonsense vote
- Option 3 is more likely but at this point (pg. 18) I still have Jeff nai so let's see.

I like how you put thought into your answer though

 

[Lethal]

Because others are better readers than me. I've been doing this for six years plus and we've established this.

But then you post this. Leads me to think, again, that someone might be helping you with your larger posts.

 

[Lethal]

But that's neither here nor there atm, and silly spec. Naughty Lethal. Let's keep reading

 

[Lethal]

Mando/Tommy/Jeff liking the post too. Good things

 

[Lethal]

Lethal maybe. Jeff not necessarily, I pointed out a post where he seemed to be crafting a response on Juice's behalf which seems off

oh?

mind reposting that for my lazy ass? I def missed it and would love to discuss it

Rabbit ears much? Let's see

 

[Lethal]

You didn't miss anything, you responded to it in fact

Oh yeah, Sky can be town.

 

[Lethal]

oh then ya we already talked about this. fwiw I thought it was a pretty fair conclusion by me. Though I found it slightly funny she nor anyone else "corrected" me on A)