No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Mandalorian]

Shade's an FWA guy too tho tbf iirc.

Also I mean look at Baldrick's reasoning behind "clearing" Man. Especially off the back of this first post.

I didn’t really know what Baldrick was trying to get at when he initially commented on it.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

He goes from "I'm worried about Man" to "Man's town! He's so aggressive~" once three town players died, does no one find that at least a little questionable?

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Shade's an FWA guy too tho tbf iirc.

Also I mean look at Baldrick's reasoning behind "clearing" Man. Especially off the back of this first post.

Right. I'm thinking we may have two scummers right there together. I'm just a bit more focused on Shade ATM.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Why am I still a null?

u were a blue lean, lost a bit of points with Juice being confirmed. if grim is scum u look worse. if he is town, u look better and were just wrong

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Right. I'm thinking we may have two scummers right there together. I'm just a bit more focused on Shade ATM.

Thoughts on N0M, in case I missed it

 

[CakeWalker]

Also Grim's you dismissed me with the hurr durr comments - but you never actually said that was your role. A tactic - to perhaps claim something else later?

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Also Grim's you dismissed me with the hurr durr comments - but you never actually said that was your role. A tactic - to perhaps claim something else later?

I mean I never denied it lol

 

[CakeWalker]

Silence is not acceptance or denial. Silence is just silence.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Thoughts on N0M, in case I missed it

Also on my person of interest list. Shade and N0M are my two biggest scum reads at this point.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

How much of this is pursuing a genuine scum read versus wanting to punish a player because they didn't say sorry enough for their snafu?

You were claiming you weren't defending Juice, but... you're really defending Barry. This is ridiculous. Having read only up to this point in the thread I still have you as the most likely co-scum

 

[Wang Chung]

Evening

Game start hello there message.

So you like to play and miss?

Talking about cricket.

Sorry guys been at work, then stuck at the Leisure Centre with the kids swimming. I'll see what I can catch up with before I watch the football.

Stating why he hasn't been here.

Not sure why this caught my eye but yes....it does make one wonder doesn't it?

I think certainly is a strong take on this...from what i've read so far anyway. Would you expect it to be followed up?

Quoted an OMB post about Grim not being town read and he shoots TP. Then another quoted post asking a question and leaving.

Oh ffs Wang...hope you're good dude. Hit us up if you need to!

Whilst I get Man's questioning maybe it's time to move on a little now before it just bogs everything else down.

Happy to be where i'm at with the reads people are giving on me. I've not been here due to work and kids activities, can't do a great deal about that but I have been reading through things and I am formulating opinions...allbeit slowly.

I'm just wondering if we're missing something that is right in front of our eyes here. Is the obvious play too obvious for it to be real if that makes sense?

He also discusses something with man and wanting to move on so it doesnt vog down the thread. Then he makes a comment about an obvious play is too obvious. Seems to be shading Grim.

My biggest concern at the moment is Man & Leila as why would you go through all that in a night phase? I'm expecting both to be on the same side though.

Grim is too obvious...but is it too obvious for it to end up being true?

I need to take some more time to go through the John stuff again.

Then saying he expects both Man and Juice to be on the same aide regardless of alignment.

Feels Grims shot was a calculated scum play.

said he needs to look at Johns stuff again.

Where did I mention they are scum? I said it was concerning but I expect them to both be on the same team.

doubles down on them veing the same team.

On the flip side of this...if it is his third game, you are telling me there has been no mention of scum chat? Find that hard to believe.

then questioning scum chat with a newer pkayer.

Totally agree however you also need to apply logic.

Says you have to apply logic to the scum chat questioning.

Or it's linked to another person.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

Then discusses how lethal was linked to someone else.

Interesting....

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

To Juices appeal to smark to post her alignment.

For me that clears Man too as he wouldn't go so hard during a night phase.

I'm happy to go with Grim at the moment but we do have plenty of time for others to have input.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

Feels that man is cleared now due to that and happy to vote Grim.

Knowing Mando as well as I like to think I do, it's not something he would pull during such a phase. If it was the day phase I would look at it a bit differently.

Man...I can see what you are saying about Grim, but it doesn't sit right with me. Why whould you take that kind of shot D1? A 4 way swing so early on is huge, so that side of things it could be a very calcualted risk.

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

Appealing to Man by saying he knows him. And doubling down on Grimbot and his shot.

Doesn't make sense in any alignment really but if it was a calculated risk based on a swing probability, this early on it would be most beneficial to mafia side surely?

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

Then changes his stance that that shot only helps mafia and not town

I was duelist last game there and first game we were all here

Sent from my SM-A137F using Tapatalk

And confirms he was a duelist in two games in a row. One that Shade was actually playing.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Also Shade pretending not to know if a kill doesn't show up, especially D1, it's due to a janitor, smacked him right down my list

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

He also discusses something with man and wanting to move on so it doesnt vog down the thread. Then he makes a comment about an obvious play is too obvious. Seems to be shading Grim.

I do remember that post. He was wanting Man to move on from a line of questions he was asking Juice. I took note of it because I wasn't totally sold on Juice at that juncture, and I wondered if he was trying to get heat off a teammate.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Tbh I think if Baldrick does flip scum it does look a bit worse for Man.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

This is categorically untrue. I know there was a duelist in the last game we played on WC, and if he had played enough games on that platform to be familair with Man, Wang, Grim, OMB, and Baldy, I feel confident that he would have seen a duel or two. At the very least, he would be familiar with how voting for them works. He asked this question and then DID NOT VOTE IN THE DUEL.

From where I'm standing this morning, Grim is definitely not town, but I really don't trust Shade at all. Jumping on the Grim D2 wagon pretty early after not voting at all (for either death) on day 1 just seems like an easy move.

Nice spot from Tommy here, feels like Shade is pretty obvious now that I consider it