No More Happy Endings - Once Upon a Time Mafia Game Thread

[Bobby Barrows]

I don’t think this really answers what I’m asking. You stated that you wanted to keep your head down so you wouldn’t be killed, yet you shot Pein when there was no pressure on you to do so and at the same time put yourself on everyone’s radar with the act itself and your lack of caring about it afterwards.

I’ve already said that shooting Pein when you did doesn’t make much sense at all if you are mafia. However this soft claim is a similar situation, but this time it makes little sense to do if you are town.

I've gone over this ad nauseum. Did it because I was bored, wanted to shoot T-Pein and thought he'd flip scum. I play to my mood, and when I'm feeling chaotic, chaotic and erratic play is what you get.

I'm not some great player and have never said I was, but what you're presenting isn't exactly incongruous to the idea that I did something stupid for shits and giggles and decided to abandon my strategy on a whim.

 

[Wangman Page]

Yes sir

Sister, Wang, Sky, Tommy

Bit lower on is you

This was in response to Jeff asking about reads because he said he had no real scum leans but seemed high on going after Juice with his back and forth. That day phase and her confirming that she is town means not much of anything.

I will see if I can find his last actual reads list.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

This man gets it

yes but also hinting that on d1 as town is...a choice. if you hadnt also shot tpein youd have been shot. a lot of wifom to unmuck here

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Because my experience of sheriff has always been - once a sheriff fires their gun, they can't use their nightly investigative powers anymore.
But the mafia variant of Stalker - doesn't lose the ability to investigate after firing the shot.

That's a convenient way to frame it, don't you think?

 

[CakeWalker]

Convenient way to claim what?

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Convenient way to claim what?

"Hurr durr, here's a role, here's the scum variant, there's no way it could be town that way!"

 

[Wangman Page]

Gacy
Pendex
Sky
T-Pein™
Mandalorian
Lethal Jade
John McHenry
People's Wang
Cereal Killer
The Grimch
Sister Abigail
Silent Bite
Turanga Leela
PHEN0M
Baldrick
Shade
Tommy Bedlam
Ekkologix

Updated to reflect current events.

This was the last one he put out.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Boy I do not like that read list from Lethal.

 

[CakeWalker]

I'm just sharing prior experience. No need to try to be insulting.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

This was the last one he put out.

Seems like such a random kill based on how many people he had town leans on.

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Like if not for Lethal being Jan'd that's still way too many town reads so early in D1, and only Pendex?

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

@Turanga Leela , did you happen to see my question about your read list earlier? Particularly the 50/50 part that had Shade and Baldrick (IIRC). Were you saying that you were 50/50 on both of them, or that you think one is scum and one is not?

 

[CakeWalker]

I'm actually 50/50 on both of thee,

I thinks its very possible - they are both mafia.

 

[Wangman Page]

Boy I do not like that read list from Lethal.

This was also on Wed as well before the duel I believe.

Sent from my SM-S908U using Tapatalk

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

I'm actually 50/50 on both of thee,

I thinks its very possible - they are both mafia.

Thanks. Does the fact that Baldrick (albeit briefly) chimed in about knowing Shade had seen a duelist role before impact anything for you? Or do you think it's an attempt at distancing? I'm just seeing if you and I are on the same wavelength here.