Mafia Mystery Mafia ~ Game Thread

[CakeWalker]

What does your current list look like CP

 

[Kajuh]

That was quite a whirlwind of thoughts to read through, CP

 

[Kajuh]

Hmmm juice looks pretty good actually

Uhhh kajuh seems pretty town too

Does this mean you're mostly leaning toward Alco then?

 

[CraigPelton]

Not to WIFOM but she was around on the site doing NWA prediction results, so she was definitely around to submit the role

Is this true juice....

 

[CraigPelton]

That ace janitor is bizarre

 

[CakeWalker]

Kajuh - did you only get to mason one person? I don't think anyone has asked - who do you win with?

 

[CraigPelton]

Did ace mention kajuh at all this game

 

[CakeWalker]

I think you were posting this to me after I said Jeff is more likely to be scum than Kajuh - I just meant it as in if Kajuh is scum then Jeff basically can't be town because he would have lied about usage on Kajuh. Whereas Jeff can be scum and Kajuh still town.

Also Jeff can be a hider/commuter who is scum tbf. I'm not denying at this point that he clearly has either the role he is claiming, or one close enough.

Ie Lethal's result on him is definitely legit.

This is one of Ace's last posts - it doesn't look at all like he was aligned with Kajuh here. I actually think Kajuh is the janitor.

 

[CraigPelton]

ok

what don't you like?


Different note, read back on Flay's posts and her most awkward interactions were with Kajuh and Jeff, randomly tunneling on a "weak interest" and then consistently arguing with Jeff in a manner which doesn't feel particularly genuine.

cba multiquoting but you guys can read back her posts yourselves if you want, doesn't take long

Fucking "Chloe" is a dude, shit is too confusing tbh, I'm not designed for this 21st century bullshit



Yup exactly I don't quite know how to interpret that whole situation - would scum Jeff "clear" a fellow scum for the WIFOM?

I... could see it. But I fear its diving too deep too soon to speculate on that.

I think you were posting this to me after I said Jeff is more likely to be scum than Kajuh - I just meant it as in if Kajuh is scum then Jeff basically can't be town because he would have lied about usage on Kajuh. Whereas Jeff can be scum and Kajuh still town.

Also Jeff can be a hider/commuter who is scum tbf. I'm not denying at this point that he clearly has either the role he is claiming, or one close enough.

Ie Lethal's result on him is definitely legit.

Yeah I get you, could pretty easily be a scum commuter though.

I'm mostly talking this through for myself from a logical perspective given how I read Flay's interactions with Jeff and Kajuh to be weird.

So yeah Ace sure doesn't sound like he was masons with Kajuh to me here

 

[CraigPelton]

Pretty sure Kajuh is just scum and knew Ace's role cause well they janitored him, then they decided to fake the mason thing to make Kajuh look extra good on top of the jeff fake clear because "why would kajuh tell us ace's role blah blah". This seems plausible and I just don't think I see 2 other scum in the remaining players tbh

 

[CraigPelton]

I agree that flay's interaction with kajuh was weird, I thought that before I read Ace say it. but I thought kajuh otherwise looked pretty good. not as good as pretty much everyone else except alco and maybe rugrat though. I think I'd lynch alco over rugrat.

 

[CakeWalker]

Good job CP Watson!

 

[CraigPelton]

poyser should take a shot at alco or rugrat tbh, pretty sure we lynch kajuh here no matter what

 

[Kajuh]

Kajuh - did you only get to mason one person? I don't think anyone has asked - who do you win with?

Yes, It was just Ace and I

 

[CraigPelton]

1) Banez
2) Jeff
3) Rugrat
4) Ace
5) Doddsy
6) Alco
7) Lethal
8) T'Challa
10) Poyser
11) CP
12) Flay
13) Grim
14) Magic
15) Juice
16) Kajuh
17) Chimp

why the scum lean on Ace?

My very own poor meta read on him. The more convincing he is to me the scummier he gets and I've liked his posts so far. Counter intuitive, I know.

Kajuh was not masons with Ace lmao