Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Odo]

How did he follow up this though? Did he continue pushing? I didn’t play that game

If I thought itd make any difference, id consider answering

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Wanted to reply to this specifically Jeff.

You would have pushed for me to claim onwards from this post if I challenged it, yes?

Had you made an attempt to ignore me or delay for reasons I didn't deem proper, very likely I push it afterwards. correct.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

But yeah, that's why I FIGURED you claimed. You saw what was coming on my end and you decided not to fuck around. The fact you are seemingly pretty honest and open about that it also good imo.

 

[Evans]

Had you made an attempt to ignore me or delay for reasons I didn't deem proper, very likely I push it afterwards. correct.

So, I also felt that you definitely push me for my claim, so why go through the hassle after everything that's happened today and just get it out of the way so we can progress and move on.

 

[Tweet]

@Jeff Valley Driver I like Poyser so far. He's got the bite for calling out little things that aren't town. He was active on his readback, responding as he read as opposed to just claiming to have read back and challenging one or two posts. This more like the town Poyser I've played with just hasn't been as busy yet.

He expands on his feeling for his Odo vote again matching a common feeling that Odo is playing differently.

@Tweet would you feel like Odo has been treating you as if he suspected you were scum? This was a point Poyser made.

He's correct on the vote placement and he's not addressed these directions. I haven't seen any particular pushes in those directions aside from the vote posts. @Odo have I missed posts?

And now challenging Odo and not sneaking around it as you'd expect scum to building a wagon, he's kept up with the challenging town meta.

I'd give Poyser a town read for current play so far.

Well I think Odo has put himself in a weird position when it comes to me. Started off by saying he's not a fan, then I asked him to tell me why, he started doing so but I don't think he thought he actually had any sort of point. It's not at all unusual for him to still read me null 4 days into the game but usually if he thinks I'm null, he actually says so. This time instead, off the things he said about me you'd think he's leaning scum with me but for some reason says he actually isn't. I think he's trying to position himself very carefully so people can't actually nail him down on reading me one way or the other but would still like to keep himself within striking distance in case he sees an opening.

The issue I got reading over this is that I don't think Odo would care so much about me as town vs him as scum that he'd make me the center of his game, but I can't shake the feeling that there's something off about the way he's interacting with me this game.

 

[Evans]

Well I think Odo has put himself in a weird position when it comes to me. Started off by saying he's not a fan, then I asked him to tell me why, he started doing so but I don't think he thought he actually had any sort of point. It's not at all unusual for him to still read me null 4 days into the game but usually if he thinks I'm null, he actually says so. This time instead, off the things he said about me you'd think he's leaning scum with me but for some reason says he actually isn't. I think he's trying to position himself very carefully so people can't actually nail him down on reading me one way or the other but would still like to keep himself within striking distance in case he sees an opening.

The issue I got reading over this is that I don't think Odo would care so much about me as town vs him as scum that he'd make me the center of his game, but I can't shake the feeling that there's something off about the way he's interacting with me this game.

 

[Odo]

Well I think Odo has put himself in a weird position when it comes to me. Started off by saying he's not a fan, then I asked him to tell me why, he started doing so but I don't think he thought he actually had any sort of point. It's not at all unusual for him to still read me null 4 days into the game but usually if he thinks I'm null, he actually says so. This time instead, off the things he said about me you'd think he's leaning scum with me but for some reason says he actually isn't. I think he's trying to position himself very carefully so people can't actually nail him down on reading me one way or the other but would still like to keep himself within striking distance in case he sees an opening.

The issue I got reading over this is that I don't think Odo would care so much about me as town vs him as scum that he'd make me the center of his game, but I can't shake the feeling that there's something off about the way he's interacting with me this game.

That seems like an awful lot of trouble to go to, when I could just, you know, not bother with any of this?

I don’t get what any of you think is in it for me, even if I executed any of this in a way that attracted no suspicion?

 

[Tweet]

Evans I cba actually reading back what your stance on him was, but weren't you sus of Jeff before? If this isn't accurate just say so.

 

[Evans]

Well I think Odo has put himself in a weird position when it comes to me. Started off by saying he's not a fan, then I asked him to tell me why, he started doing so but I don't think he thought he actually had any sort of point. It's not at all unusual for him to still read me null 4 days into the game but usually if he thinks I'm null, he actually says so. This time instead, off the things he said about me you'd think he's leaning scum with me but for some reason says he actually isn't. I think he's trying to position himself very carefully so people can't actually nail him down on reading me one way or the other but would still like to keep himself within striking distance in case he sees an opening.

The issue I got reading over this is that I don't think Odo would care so much about me as town vs him as scum that he'd make me the center of his game, but I can't shake the feeling that there's something off about the way he's interacting with me this game.

Thanks, this adds credence to the point that Poyser has made about Odo's behaviour around yourself, his off play. I'm sort of understanding what you mean around keeping you within striking distance. I noticed him almost reinforcing his position when he was jabbing at you about having your vote on me and advising you where it should be etc.

Makes me lean more town for Poyser.

 

[Tweet]

That seems like an awful lot of trouble to go to, when I could just, you know, not bother with any of this?

I don’t get what any of you think is in it for me, even if I executed any of this in a way that attracted no suspicion?

Did you ever finish saying what's supposedly so sus about me or is the first act all I'll get?

 

[Odo]

Did you ever finish saying what's supposedly so sus about me or is the first act all I'll get?

The rest seems fairly redundant now, but basically every post you made in the early game was pretty terrible for one reason or another. Thinking Jeff would try another reaction test play as scum is just lunacy for example

 

[Odo]

However, Evans came along and stank the joint out to the point where I had less certainty because he was opposed to you when it became convenient , and then over the time it just felt both of you had exceeded the level of pointless effort I’d expect from scum, hence the reluctance to vote either of you

 

[Tweet]

The rest seems fairly redundant now, but basically every post you made in the early game was pretty terrible for one reason or another. Thinking Jeff would try another reaction test play as scum is just lunacy for example

What do you think of him insinuating that I actually didn't think nightposting was allowed in this game? The point itself is pretty whatever I'll admit but I still kinda think he said it to make me look like an idiot.

 

[Tweet]

Also really, that's all it takes to make you not consider somebody might be scum? By the same logic, if I get upset and emotional over getting sussed next time I'm scum, you're not gonna push it cause "surely he's not gonna do that again after last time"?

 

[Odo]

Also really, that's all it takes to make you not consider somebody might be scum? By the same logic, if I get upset and emotional over getting sussed next time I'm scum, you're not gonna push it cause "surely he's not gonna do that again after last time"?

no, cause one is premeditated, and one is an emotional response