Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Canadian Dragon]

No, the ability to follow another player where they go is not a good role, at all, like no use.[!}sarcasm

not THAT good of a role. mr semantics, you should pay attention and not put words in my mouth

 

[CraigPelton]

Mr. Robot Mafia: Game Thread

@Nikita Chrischev what are your reads

wrestlingsmarks.com

Mr Robot Mafia

Barry was scum. Couldn't find anything on him reacting to a tracker claim as town so idk

 

[Odo]

Evans, on a scale of horseshit to not horseshit, how highly do you rate the case CP made on me, that Poyser subsequently followed?

 

[Evans]

Mr Semantics

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Mr. Robot Mafia: Game Thread

@Nikita Chrischev what are your reads

wrestlingsmarks.com

View attachment 5847

Mr Robot Mafia

Barry was scum. Couldn't find anything on him reacting to a tracker claim as town so idk

I do it no matter what alignment I am, bruh.

 

[Tweet]

Not for nothing, but I'd love to hear more from @Christian Cage if anyone cares.

Good shout, Chris seems uncharacteristically quiet for long stretches of this game.

My read on Odo is more than just expecting him to have a clearer direction it’s also that his votes have been pretty much exclusively on low hanging fruit; something he himself pinged me on when I was scum. Also the fact that he said he disagreed with all of my reads and yet never tried to push me strikes me as odd too as he’s not usually shy of pushing me early especially if he senses soemthing not right.

I also don’t really buy that he wasn’t trying to keep tweet under pressure. Do you disagree that all of his posts aimed at Tweet signal some kind of scum read? Because he denies that scum read exists lol

If you want my opinion on Odos play around me so far, it seems to me he's carefully choosing to be just within striking distance of me in case some opportunity presents itself. However this is somewhat close to what he's done as town in pretty much all games we've played recently regardless of my alignment, so I struggle to actually call him scum for this. There is something I'm looking out for though, if it doesn't happen this is gonna become a scum read.

Oh I'm aware. I'm just not so willing to lynch a claimed tracker on D1. Benefit of the doubt and all that.

What are your thoughts about another investigative role claiming when you supposedly have one as well?

I’m gonna stick my neck out and say town tho

Elaborate pls.

 

[Poyser]

@Poyser I take it you think CP is town?

As it stands yeah, more to do with agreeing with him on 2 reads (I posted phenom suss before I saw him post about it which is a good sign) also not really sure he makes a play for you as scum either

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Good shout, Chris seems uncharacteristically quiet for long stretches of this game.

If you want my opinion on Odos play around me so far, it seems to me he's carefully choosing to be just within striking distance of me in case some opportunity presents itself. However this is somewhat close to what he's done as town in pretty much all games we've played recently regardless of my alignment, so I struggle to actually call him scum for this. There is something I'm looking out for though, if it doesn't happen this is gonna become a scum read.

What are your thoughts about another investigative role claiming when you supposedly have one as well?

Elaborate pls.

It's a Smark game; Of course there'll be a million investigative roles.

 

[Tweet]

I feel bad about playing setup spec when Smark is the host, but this is now the second investigative role that claims pretty much without pressure. Yes sure people were still kinda sus of Evans but there's not actually a large wagon on him that would have prompted this as far as I can tell. So to summarize, can you guys not?

 

[Tweet]

I feel bad about playing setup spec when Smark is the host, but this is now the second investigative role that claims pretty much without pressure. Yes sure people were still kinda sus of Evans but there's not actually a large wagon on him that would have prompted this as far as I can tell. So to summarize, can you guys not?

Well I suppose this isn't so much setup spec as it is me going at those unprompted claims.

 

[Poyser]

Good shout, Chris seems uncharacteristically quiet for long stretches of this game.

If you want my opinion on Odos play around me so far, it seems to me he's carefully choosing to be just within striking distance of me in case some opportunity presents itself. However this is somewhat close to what he's done as town in pretty much all games we've played recently regardless of my alignment, so I struggle to actually call him scum for this. There is something I'm looking out for though, if it doesn't happen this is gonna become a scum read.

What are your thoughts about another investigative role claiming when you supposedly have one as well?

Elaborate pls.

And you don’t think it’s a bit of a red flag after the chest beating about how he would’ve shown you no mercy and never let you off the hook last game if he wasn’t intentionally slow playing to protect his role?

 

[Evans]

Evans, on a scale of horseshit to not horseshit, how highly do you rate the case CP made on me, that Poyser subsequently followed?

I'd say I agree with CP that your play does feel different. It's a concern I raised myself when I came back from a break. I've said it unsettles me but you're pushing directions and that's town behaviour and I don't have any real reason to suspect you of anything. CP clearly has more to it to justify his vote. You were encouraging me to vote for a lot less earlier - so not horseshit.

I'm still reading through Poysers posts, I'll get back to you.

 

[Poyser]

Also I think saying I followed CPs case is pretty disingenuous unless you’re telling me I made no independent points lol

 

[Evans]

Well I suppose this isn't so much setup spec as it is me going at those unprompted claims.

Look at the time stamps of everything that went down. I thought it was quite intense tbh.

 

[Poyser]

I don’t really mind EV claiming, just not entirely sure what changed between refusing to claim earlier to now claiming even tho the votes had kinda abandoned ship?