Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Poyser]

ok done your posts. TL/DR version : Your argument is that while Nom isn't necessarily always active as town, when he IS active, he's more likely to be town. Correct?

Regarding Odo: You are scum reading him because you expect him to have a clearer direction at this point in the game, on top of the fact you think his NOM read is generous and was solely made in an effort to quash any sort of future push going that way.

Am I following so far @Poyser ?

Doesn’t really seem like it no lol

 

[Poyser]

No lol, I’m being pushed specifically for my defending of Phenom defending himself against CP, who then used him previously pushing Evans as evidence of him being engaged early, which you went along with lmao




RECEIPTS. You even liked this post so dont claim ignorance here lmao.

Show me proof, I have no recollection of this and unless the game states are roughly equivalent, it’s dismissible. Show me proof that meets all that criteria and I’ll accept I’m wrong

It’s the series of posts I just posted

 

[Odo]

Its also rich to complain about me tunnelling when 9/18 players just arent posting, and then the ones that youd say are my peers were basically absent until pushing me lol

It’s the series of posts I just posted

Im not seeing how thats the push on you - thats what I meant, im not disputing this push on Evans happened but idrc about that

 

[Bobby Barrows]

Not for nothing, but I'd love to hear more from @Christian Cage if anyone cares.

 

[Poyser]

@Poyser in case we cant edit, that is supposed to read : Your argument is that while Nom isn't necessarily always active as SCUM

My read on Odo is more than just expecting him to have a clearer direction it’s also that his votes have been pretty much exclusively on low hanging fruit; something he himself pinged me on when I was scum. Also the fact that he said he disagreed with all of my reads and yet never tried to push me strikes me as odd too as he’s not usually shy of pushing me early especially if he senses soemthing not right.

I also don’t really buy that he wasn’t trying to keep tweet under pressure. Do you disagree that all of his posts aimed at Tweet signal some kind of scum read? Because he denies that scum read exists lol

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Doesn’t really seem like it no lol

I mean I read your posts and that's essentially the basis of both your cases. what exactly else am I magically missing here?

 

[Poyser]

Its also rich to complain about me tunnelling when 9/18 players just arent posting, and then the ones that youd say are my peers were basically absent until pushing me lol



Im not seeing how thats the push on you - thats what I meant, im not disputing this push on Evans happened but idrc about that

I couldn’t even begin to remember which game it was lol, I wasn’t bringing it up to try and convince you, but telling you I don’t buy that as a defence because I know he’s pushed me as scum

 

[Poyser]

I mean I read your posts and that's essentially the basis of both your cases. what exactly else am I magically missing here?

I literally made a long post about it when I voted Odo

You’re saying I only had 1 point in that?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

no it clearly had 2 points. i just condensed them, i literally said TLDR version. but thanks for the clarification nonetheless

 

[Odo]

My read on Odo is more than just expecting him to have a clearer direction it’s also that his votes have been pretty much exclusively on low hanging fruit; something he himself pinged me on when I was scum. Also the fact that he said he disagreed with all of my reads and yet never tried to push me strikes me as odd too as he’s not usually shy of pushing me early especially if he senses soemthing not right.

I also don’t really buy that he wasn’t trying to keep tweet under pressure. Do you disagree that all of his posts aimed at Tweet signal some kind of scum read? Because he denies that scum read exists lol

Youre expecting me to have a clear direction when half the game is AWOL, the guy that Ive concluded is scummiest I dont want to lynch because of his role and the other guys you could say Ive been suspicious of seem to be actively trying to position themselves right on the boundary of me wanting to lynch them?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

for the record, the way I worded that post was in no way meant to disparage or minimise your case, either. I was legit looking for clarification and a tldr version so I may see your p.o.v better.

 

[Odo]

Neither you or CP were actively posting until recently. Whos the big game I should have been targeting exactly?

 

[Odo]

Next person on the list is KIF, I think we can probably cut it there safely

 

[Poyser]

View attachment 5845

Neither you or CP were actively posting until recently. Whos the big game I should have been targeting exactly?

But you even commented that all my reads were vastly different to yours and then did nothing with it. You barely even pressed me on them.

And as I’ve said you seemed to be suspicious of tweet for one, I’d be expecting you to go for the throat just like you said you would last game if you weren’t the cop. As far as I’ve seen you don’t have anything on mitch or brutus yet you seemed fine leaving your votes there. Did Mitch even do anything that caused you to switch your vote? Cuz if he did I must have missed it lol

 

[Odo]

I couldn’t even begin to remember which game it was lol, I wasn’t bringing it up to try and convince you, but telling you I don’t buy that as a defence because I know he’s pushed me as scum

Yeah but if youve got any intention of convincing anyone else, it might be worth finding? Of course youre not trying to convince me lol

I mean idrc either way