Let the Past Die: The Skywalker Saga - A Star Wars Mafia Game Thread

[Grimoire Lenin]

ok I didn't consider it from that perspective at the time. I felt it was more him testing if I was the one that was full of shit. but looking back, yeah, I can see it as a way not only to get my alignment but to also buddy/pocket a player with some thread pull who he would know would react aggressively to what looks like an exposed lie.

fair point

No disrespect intended to Ace, but do you see him as the sort of player who'd bite on that opportunity all on his own? Or do you think he'd have to have been instructed to go for that?

I'm just not sure I see scum Ace doing that since it'd pigeonhole him into a POE lynch since he was proven wrong.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I'll take a stab at full list while were waiting too. And I may change my mind from earlier now that ive thought about it more

1 - Empire Strikes Back
2 - Force Awakens
3 - Return of the Jedi
4 - The Last Jedi
5 - A New Hope
6 - Rogue One
7 - The Phantom Menace


havent seen the others yet

 

[Comrade Khan]

That was a chore of a catch up lol

Who did EV rep in for? Mitch?

Don’t really like his conclusions from his readback, not sure how he goes through lethals posts and concludes lethal and ace are aligned, doesn’t make sense

yea mitch

 

[Evans]

That was a chore of a catch up lol

Who did EV rep in for? Mitch?

Don’t really like his conclusions from his readback, not sure how he goes through lethals posts and concludes lethal and ace are aligned, doesn’t make sense

Yes I repped in for Mitch.

Which parts of thinking they're aligned do you not like? I felt the Lethal/Ace interactions were disingenuous and busywork. Lethal never really pushed on it at all and quickly backed down from Ace pretty much copy & pasting his previous posts lol. Lethal also is on my reads list as a lighter red, indicating that I'm not gonna lynch him ahead of Odo/Ace but I'm suspicious of him.

 

[Evans]

No disrespect intended to Ace, but do you see him as the sort of player who'd bite on that opportunity all on his own? Or do you think he'd have to have been instructed to go for that?

I'm just not sure I see scum Ace doing that since it'd pigeonhole him into a POE lynch since he was proven wrong.

How do you feel about his slip/mistake?

 

[Comrade Khan]

No disrespect intended to Ace, but do you see him as the sort of player who'd bite on that opportunity all on his own? Or do you think he'd have to have been instructed to go for that?

I'm just not sure I see scum Ace doing that since it'd pigeonhole him into a POE lynch since he was proven wrong.

true...Unless he had direction to do so. Butthen you point still stands about shelflife of that play, which soomeone with experience would also advise against....

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

How do you feel about his slip/mistake?

Are we referring to the Mace Windu thing?

 

[Evans]

No disrespect intended to Ace, but do you see him as the sort of player who'd bite on that opportunity all on his own? Or do you think he'd have to have been instructed to go for that?

I'm just not sure I see scum Ace doing that since it'd pigeonhole him into a POE lynch since he was proven wrong.

true...Unless he had direction to do so. Butthen you point still stands about shelflife of that play, which soomeone with experience would also advise against....

Or did he not realise that making that play to try and add doubt to my claim would come off as heavy handed as it did? I mean, I'm pretty set on lynching him after Odo on current info so I might be in a tunnel, but the way he's curled into a ball after the mistake feels like scum trying to not draw as much attention to himself as he'd get arguing back about the mistake. If that makes sense?

 

[Evans]

Are we referring to the Mace Windu thing?

Yarp

 

[Comrade Khan]

well fortunately we will have all day to discuss it, plus hopefully some cool results from cool ppl!

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Or did he not realise that making that play to try and add doubt to my claim would come off as heavy handed as it did? I mean, I'm pretty set on lynching him after Odo on current info so I might be in a tunnel, but the way he's curled into a ball after the mistake feels like scum trying to not draw as much attention to himself as he'd get arguing back about the mistake. If that makes sense?

A few notes on that subject:

If he and Odo are scummates, I don't think Odo would ever go along with that unless Ace went rogue and tried to get you lynched without thinking of the long-term and how it would affect him.

That said:

Scum executing you after the tide was turning for you and the fact that Chris got caught in the blast radius could mean that if Ace and Odo are also scum, it was a shortsighted move made out of desperation so they wouldn't lose two scum in one day/3 in two days.

I just don't necessarily think there's really enough to have Ace pinned to the wall here. He's definitely a POE lynch at this point, but I'm gonna stick with my gut and say his PGO claim is likely town. I uh- I have a decent idea of who (if he hasn't already given character) he might claim all things considered if he's sticking with the PGO, if you catch my drift.

Yarp

Wasn't Mace Windu talked about at length before-hand? I can't really remember the timeline of events but tbh it seems to me like missing the forest for the trees and a bit of a massive nitpick.

 

[Poyser]

Yes I repped in for Mitch.

Which parts of thinking they're aligned do you not like? I felt the Lethal/Ace interactions were disingenuous and busywork. Lethal never really pushed on it at all and quickly backed down from Ace pretty much copy & pasting his previous posts lol. Lethal also is on my reads list as a lighter red, indicating that I'm not gonna lynch him ahead of Odo/Ace but I'm suspicious of him.

But lethal didn’t focus on like anybody else did he? Why would he make his only contribution to day 1 be singling out his teammate that’s in no danger and pushing him? Whether it was strong or not

 

[CraigPelton]

But lethal didn’t focus on like anybody else did he? Why would he make his only contribution to day 1 be singling out his teammate that’s in no danger and pushing him? Whether it was strong or not

Lethal likes to bus as scum and people generally don't follow him on stuff so it's low risk. I can see what EV's getting at.

 

[Evans]

A few notes on that subject:

If he and Odo are scummates, I don't think Odo would ever go along with that unless Ace went rogue and tried to get you lynched without thinking of the long-term and how it would affect him.

That said:

Scum executing you after the tide was turning for you and the fact that Chris got caught in the blast radius could mean that if Ace and Odo are also scum, it was a shortsighted move made out of desperation so they wouldn't lose two scum in one day/3 in two days.

I just don't necessarily think there's really enough to have Ace pinned to the wall here. He's definitely a POE lynch at this point, but I'm gonna stick with my gut and say his PGO claim is likely town. I uh- I have a decent idea of who (if he hasn't already given character) he might claim all things considered if he's sticking with the PGO, if you catch my drift.



Wasn't Mace Windu talked about at length before-hand? I can't really remember the timeline of events but tbh it seems to me like missing the forest for the trees and a bit of a massive nitpick.

Yeah I get where you're coming from re: first point. Might be an over-complicated theory but it's something I want to explore, including a full claim from Ace in the next day phase.

I agree the execution was a desperation ploy to end the day phase.

Yes, Windu was mentioned a lot, but Dooku wasn't mentioned at all. That's why it's weird.

Ace has said his claim isn't PGO also.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Yeah I get where you're coming from re: first point. Might be an over-complicated theory but it's something I want to explore, including a full claim from Ace in the next day phase.

I agree the execution was a desperation ploy to end the day phase.

Yes, Windu was mentioned a lot, but Dooku wasn't mentioned at all. That's why it's weird.

Ace has said his claim isn't PGO also.

See, I missed that little detail.

Oh well then throw that out the window.