Dungeon & Dragons Mafia - Game Thread [GAME OVER]

[Hidden Blaze]

imo, it's just something to do at times. I don't think it's alignment indicative by itself. Had Lethal insisted he had an actual plan and was giving any other reasons than he gave, I'd be worried. As it stands, it's wtv

I can definitely see that. Definitely the reason behind such a quick vote can tell you a little or a lot about a person. I think it’s probably something to keep tucked away in the back of your mind, but it’s not something strong enough on it’s own.

 

[Comrade Khan]

playing along with a joke post with a joke serious 'hmm this is suspect' could definitely be a bit. dont think it was tho.

so if you don't think it was a bit, do you like or dislike Pendex for saying it

 

[Sister Abigail]

[Vote Jeff]

 

[Pendex]

@Pendex were you expecting a serious answer from Lethal from a post 1 vote with no context?

What I got was broadly in line with what I expected.

But it is though, I answered it with a question of my own.
Reason - Jeff will provide the most content. Game had 30 minutes of zero activity and no entry posts. You trying to pull some cheap angle shoot here?

What is "angle shooting" about me asking for your reasoning for voting a certain player?

Now you've actually answered the question, not really sure why the defensiveness is present here?

 

[Pendex]

I have zero plan here. I'm bored watching rain fall at the cricket, and nothing else on TV. If other people want to view my vote in any way, shape or form, I'm all ears.

Like my ears perked up when Pendex took issue with it

I didn't take issue, I just asked about it because it was the only post in the game

 

[Hidden Blaze]

[Vote Jeff]

Any particular reason?

 

[Comrade Khan]

[Vote Jeff]

gonna add some reasons to that sunshine?

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Lethal Jade why are you still voting for me btw?

 

[Comrade Khan]

What I got was broadly in line with what I expected.
What is "angle shooting" about me asking for your reasoning for voting a certain player?

Now you've actually answered the question, not really sure why the defensiveness is present here?

fair question by Dex, actually. @Lethal Jade if you voted me to get ''the most'' out of the game, why are you immediately accusing someone questioning you of trying to angle shoot? Surely you would expect some questioning as to the reason of your vote given the context and circumstances at which you cast it. I could understand counter-questioning to a degree, but immediately jumping to the angle shoot verbiage does seem indeed a bit defensive.

 

[Comrade Khan]

hmmm ''only'' 18 hours left on d1, that' s short for this many players on d1. I'll push back on this lazy Sister vote then

vote sister

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Yeah, I'm not a big fan of that SA vote, especially in conjunction with Lethal's non-committal reasoning. Don't really like either of Lethal or SA, but I don't think they'd be aligned with one another knowingly and do this.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Yeah, I'm not a big fan of that SA vote, especially in conjunction with Lethal's non-committal reasoning. Don't really like either of Lethal or SA, but I don't think they'd be aligned with one another knowingly and do this.

way too early for team ups imo, but I do agree them doing this as a team would be dumb and well below both players capabilities as scum lol

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

I also do want to give Lethal the benefit of the doubt that maybe he's just trying to justify a vote on Jeff for a similar reason as me when I was on Man last game, buuuuuut that doesn't really explain the immediate defensiveness and refusal to answer.

 

[Hidden Blaze]

Tbh, voting Jeff would be a smart move for scum, since he’s one of the best players. I agree that lethal and SA probably aren’t aligned, but I definitely think one of them are scum. You want to get the best at scum hunting out of the game as quickly as possible to avoid being detected. Now the question is, which one is scum and which one just voted for him to do so.

 

[Grimoire Lenin]

Tbh, voting Jeff would be a smart move for scum, since he’s one of the best players. I agree that lethal and SA probably aren’t aligned, but I definitely think one of them are scum. You want to get the best at scum hunting out of the game as quickly as possible to avoid being detected. Now the question is, which one is scum and which one just voted for him to do so.

Is it really that smart though? Let's consider that if you show your hand too soon, you won't earn anyone's trust, and gunning for one of the best players in the game via vote isn't really as good a play as I think you think it is. Most of the time mafia will target the better players at night, so to cut the head off of town early.