Dungeon & Dragons Mafia - Game Thread [GAME OVER]

[CakeWalker]

DAY TWO - VOTE COUNT #6

Lethal [4] - T-Pein, Sister Abigail, Sky, Mandalorian
Sister Abigail [1] - John McHenry
Sky [1] - Lethal
John McHenry [2] - Ultra, Jeff Valley Driver

WITH TEN ALIVE IT TAKES SIX VOTES FOR A LYNCH TO OCCUR.

Time Left Of Day Two

Counting time since Jul 25, 2023 6:00 pm. Showing days, hours, minutes and seconds counting up

www.timeanddate.com

​

 

[Ultra]

Vote lynch: Sky

Too many connectives to ignore. Flip would provide so much about so many. Has all of these inspired reads but unwilling to push them. Self-awareness defending that did not exist in Scream. Completely ignores Dragon's case on her. Cries about being tunneled as if she cannot be suspected.

I'm gonna rest my case. Take my legacy reads there @Jeff Valley Driver (Sky/Mando/McHenry).

Lynch me and I'll mock you all from the dead chat and cringe at your hindsight SHOCK that I am town.

Or....listen to what I've said and win the game for town.

I also think this looks better for Lethal as it's a logical extension and follow through of the posts he was making earlier, part of what sold me into the vote is that he seemed to jump over all the X vs Sky thread discussion to do meaningless busywork

 

[John McHenry]

I'll be getting that claim today

I don't think I will be not for you.

 

[Sister Abigail]

He's followed his every move. Something I don't think I've seen him do before. He's also doing it without adding much to the reason or logistics. He's not really trying to get answers from anyone other than who Ultra has targeted. This of itself wouldn't suggest that Ultra is scum but Ultra hasn't been concerned by it in the least hasn't called him out on it or asked for more clarification.

Not really sure how I'm supposed to get answers from slots that just dip and are inactive.

 

[John McHenry]

Not really sure how I'm supposed to get answers from slots that just dip and are inactive.

You should have plenty for this day. But its less the target and more that your acting out of what I typically see.

 

[Canadian Dragon]

I don't think I will be not for you.

 

[Ultra]

I don't think I will be not for you.

Did I stutter?

 

[Sister Abigail]

I'm inclined to give Lethal the benefit of the doubt at the moment. Feel SA is more scummy atm.

If Lethal is allowed to invite other people to his private chat that would be beneficial I think.

How does Lethal get the benefit of the doubt?

Why am I scummy?

 

[Sister Abigail]

sky has followed votes for sure, SA def been sucking up to Ultra all phase though too. SKy has been going wherever the wind blows outside her opening SA vote

What's wrong buddying a town read? I even said I'm willing to work with you this day.

 

[John McHenry]

Did I stutter?

If I tell you the power is useless, and I'll likely be killed, at the very least the power will be wasted. If I don't you'll get a mislynch on me the power will be wasted and I die.

 

[Mandalorian]

Idk it kinda feeled like u were trying to get ahead of an inevitable flip n trying to mb throw feelers for d3. Perhaps I'm seeing it that way cuz I'm the target n tbh atm I think anyone who entertains I'm scum is being very foolish.

This doesn’t make sense. I said that line of thinking may track if he was scum, not town. If he flips town then that theory goes out of the window, but I wasn’t accounting for that. I’d get a TMI argument if I was basing a point on Lethal being town, but I wasnt. Yeah, there was forward thinking involved, but not from the angle that you’re trying to paint it as.

 

[John McHenry]

How does Lethal get the benefit of the doubt?

Why am I scummy?

Cause I wanted to know why you were parroting Ultra at every turn. I didn't see you make an argument of your own. If you just want pressure on me that's fine you have some reading to do and then you can give a proper evaluation.

 

[CakeWalker]

 

[Mandalorian]

I don't think I will be not for you.

I’m just going to say that I think you have to at this point. They’re not going to stop until you do and with two hours left we’re going to run straight into a no lynch or you’ll just get booted anyway for not giving the full claim.

So at this juncture, the most helpful thing for town is you claim so we can move on from the people asking for it phase, get into the discussion over whether we believe it before ultimately making a decision.

 

[Mandalorian]

Also, the longer from now that McHenry takes, the worse I’m going to feel about the slot because whilst it’s noble he doesn’t want a town role outed (I don’t think anyone does in an ideal world) the distraction and stalling is not helpful for us at all. Would rather we were just able to move on and work with the time we’ve got left effectively.