Doctor Who Mafia - Game Thread

[Poyser]

Pretty sure Wang isn't confirmed mason but his play just makes him seem far too unlikely to be scum for sure. The fact he just blurted that out at night is probably a good look than bad one.

Yeah I dont really have any doubts about him at all

He COULD be a scum mason but I dont really see the optics of janitoring someone they know is a mason lol unless its literally just to make wang look good, but he already looked good

 

[Wangman Page]

What's a MyLo?

Myslynch and it's over.

 

[Marty McFourth]

This day is gonna be stalled until Grim and Chris claim so I'll be back later.

Still unsure where I want to go this phase, but I really don't think we having anything to lose either way with all the info Poyser left behind. It would suck to lose a player of his calibre in end game if he's town but the game is mostly POE'd out so it's not super important.

Whatever you guys want to do, I'll help out. Unless people are putting that decision in my hands

I just ask that people review Poyser more closely. Even look at CP's posts about the Big Man fake role info. His play really doesn't seem like scum that is about to lose if I'm being honest. It could be a huge scum play by him, but I don't see the payoff. I trust most of the players as you're basically all confirmed town or close to it

 

[Marty McFourth]

My preference for today is Chris or Poyser, Poyser probably makes the most sense info wise, Chris is looking terribly scummy, but I would be fine with Grim too.

Tweet would be the last person I'd go for unless I see Poyser flip town then it'd be more likely for me

 

[Wangman Page]

This isn't true, you claimed it during night:




Not that it really matters anyway lol, Scum knew chevy was the mason so they'd know his partner was going to claim eventually and therefore they couldn't frame Mitch

You are correct. I had that sequence reversed in my head.

 

[Poyser]

 

[Mitch Buchannon]

Hey so I lied about shooting Chris and being blocked I shot at Poyser last night and he wasn’t killed so take that with a grain of salt


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Poyser]

 

[Poyser]

vote mitch

dont think so pal

 

[Marty McFourth]

I think I'd choose to believe the claimed Vigilante over a VT claim that already looked quite shoddy. I don't see what Mitch has to gain by making that up and you flipping town, so you have to be scum. No Janitor BS with Chevy as Mason already settled.

I don't see Mitch being ballsy enough to fake claim that as scum, especially with how likely it would be to be counter-claimed in most set-ups

This looks like a case closed for me.

Vote Poyser

 

[Marty McFourth]

Hey so I lied about shooting Chris and being blocked I shot at Poyser last night and he wasn’t killed so take that with a grain of salt


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

You think he's Bulletproof or that you were just blocked by scum?

 

[Poyser]

lying about shooting chris makes no sense, there’s no way scum blocked a vig that said he was out of shots and there’s no way I could have survived

guess this means my PoE is a bit wrong but I remember tweet randomly saying he believed the vig claim early on so probably those two together. Chevy might have been a Mason/vig which isn’t impossible at all

 

[Poyser]

Think Mitch was hoping we’d just go along with the narrative that he was blocked rather than not believing it which is probably why he’s changed his mind here

 

[Marty McFourth]

lying about shooting chris makes no sense, there’s no way scum blocked a vig that said he was out of shots and there’s no way I could have survived

guess this means my PoE is a bit wrong but I remember tweet randomly saying he believed the vig claim early on so probably those two together. Chevy might have been a Mason/vig which isn’t impossible at all

Doddsy lied about his role being done to pass me the screwdriver last night to keep it hidden from scum. I could totally see Mitch lying about being out of shots so maybe scum would not block him.

Nice try, though. I'll give Mitch some props if he has balls that big but

Well done, you played me well mate.

 

[Marty McFourth]

No reason for Mitch to make this up when you were still gonna probably get lynched as well, why make himself look terrible if you're town?

Makes zero sense.