Death on the Nile [A Detective Adventure Part II]

[Canadian Dragon]

The problem with the list is.

Mandos defense has been amazing in my opinion I'm buying everything he's selling. He's given reads, role (even though it's a shady role)

SA - It's not the exact role I thought he was saying but close.

Holt - complete unknown and we can't do anything with it.

If there is a strong scum read on individuals I'm willing to go there because if we hit town we're back to 50 50. We're likely going after SA or Mando. Say we pick one their town, next day train will be the other one but they could still be town. Holt not playing kinda makes the list irrelavant?

In a world where sa n mando r town, whos teaming w holt n lolling atm ?

 

[Sister Abigail]

I don’t like Ekko taking as much time as he did to paint out how a perfect town player should be acting in mine or SA’s situation and then SA acting exactly as Ekko described. Ekko buddying up to SA as well and backing him up makes that link even more prominent for me.

I’m happy to go with either of them.

But I mean, if you have info that one in three are bad, you should probably resolve that first, not just go on a random tour of all the other players. Ekko could be a Wolf but I'd still agree with his logic here 10/10 times. Do you think Jeff's info is bad?

 

[Mandalorian]

Lets work on teams too then, regardless what we choose to do, id like to work with you in ar tge very least establishing mafia mates .

Ur suggesting ekko/sis/pein atm yes? Do they have interactions between them that would make them unlikely? Sis/ekko i cant recall, pein/ekko had some interactions but ekko of the two acted buddying while pein now pushin him. Im strugglin w a pein/ekko pair

I think the main link is Ekko and SA being so close, and the point I made about Ekko describing his ideal town player in this position and SA being exactly that. It feels very forced.

I can’t recall Pein and Ekko interacting that much, but I don’t know if there’s a personality clash there or not and they purposely avoid each other. Pein though seems to not be considering SA at all and won’t budge from me.

My potential team has changed several times in the last 12 hours haha, but the more I think about it and piece things together in my head it’s looking possible with Lethal in there too. Probably not a coincidence that he’s hanging back and not pushing it through to offer a differing approach perhaps?

 

[Sister Abigail]

I certainly agree with this though, made me sick to my stomach n if they town wtf who plays like this lol

Don't you agree we should vote within your list before we do anything else? You said it's the logical move.

 

[Lethal]

The problem with the list is.

Mandos defense has been amazing in my opinion I'm buying everything he's selling. He's given reads, role (even though it's a shady role)

SA - It's not the exact role I thought he was saying but close.

Holt - complete unknown and we can't do anything with it.

If there is a strong scum read on individuals I'm willing to go there because if we hit town we're back to 50 50. We're likely going after SA or Mando. Say we pick one their town, next day train will be the other one but they could still be town. Holt not playing kinda makes the list irrelavant?

If we go, say, Mando, and he flips town, well we would hope that a vig could take a 50/50. But man that's a stretch on 2 days to lynch from a list.

 

[Sister Abigail]

Not suggesting that at all. I’m serious about finding mafia, as Ekko has said himself (to justify his vote on Lethal), there’s only one in the trio and several more outside of it.

You aren't serious, though. We know for sure there's someone within the list of three that's scum, yet you're still interested in going outside of the circle. You trust your reads more than the list? How come?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

Don't you agree we should vote within your list before we do anything else? You said it's the logical move.

Is that what my post said here?

 

[Canadian Dragon]

If we go, say, Mando, and he flips town, well we would hope that a vig could take a 50/50. But man that's a stretch on 2 days to lynch from a list.

We dont know if we have a vig or if they active if we do. Cant rely on much this game

 

[Canadian Dragon]

@Mandalorian curious, i dont get the impression lethal isnt offering alternatives. Whats your read on tweet again btw

 

[Sister Abigail]

Ooooh man the pandering here is burning my ears lol

I'm willing to offer my head, but it seems like Mando is trying everything in his power to save his. Don't you see that difference?

 

[Sister Abigail]

The problem with the list is.

Mandos defense has been amazing in my opinion I'm buying everything he's selling. He's given reads, role (even though it's a shady role)

SA - It's not the exact role I thought he was saying but close.

Holt - complete unknown and we can't do anything with it.

If there is a strong scum read on individuals I'm willing to go there because if we hit town we're back to 50 50. We're likely going after SA or Mando. Say we pick one their town, next day train will be the other one but they could still be town. Holt not playing kinda makes the list irrelavant?

What do you think about Mando's defense has been amazing?

 

[Mandalorian]

But I mean, if you have info that one in three are bad, you should probably resolve that first, not just go on a random tour of all the other players. Ekko could be a Wolf but I'd still agree with his logic here 10/10 times. Do you think Jeff's info is bad?

If you think that I think that, you’ve not actually been paying attention to what I’ve been saying. I didn’t at first but now I do. I think my thought process on that change has been clear and if someone wanted to they can see the pieces changing for me with regards to Jeff and the list.

A random tour of the players? Dude, I’ve been called out several times for not trying to solve or play the game and instead focusing on defending myself. Now you’re giving me shit for doing the opposite.

Regardless of the list, I think Ekko is mafia. My goal here is to vote out mafia. For that reason, I’d also be happy voting you out and surely because you’re on the list you wouldn’t have any issues with me pushing you as hard as you’re pushing me?

 

[Lethal]

We dont know if we have a vig or if they active if we do. Cant rely on much this game

This is true. Daykill as you said would be fucking mint right about now. I hope it's not Wang, Junk or Holt with the role (which I'm sadly coming around too cos any active player would be taking a shot)

 

[John McHenry]

In a world where sa n mando r town, whos teaming w holt n lolling atm ?

In this scenario We could have

Holt - Genuinely inactive though not lurking.

Ekko

Junkette - She comes in early gunning at Ekko. I agree to sus with her she immediately leaves him and jumps on me. Ekko brings this up, it makes Ekko look good. Later on he defends not going at her when a few eyeballs were on her as "don't want to lynch the top 6"

The fourth could be a few people I mean all inactives are possible, they could have been told to hold off. I mean someones ego would allow it.

 

[Sister Abigail]

I think the main link is Ekko and SA being so close, and the point I made about Ekko describing his ideal town player in this position and SA being exactly that. It feels very forced.

I can’t recall Pein and Ekko interacting that much, but I don’t know if there’s a personality clash there or not and they purposely avoid each other. Pein though seems to not be considering SA at all and won’t budge from me.

My potential team has changed several times in the last 12 hours haha, but the more I think about it and piece things together in my head it’s looking possible with Lethal in there too. Probably not a coincidence that he’s hanging back and not pushing it through to offer a differing approach perhaps?

From my POV, you or Holt are scum, that's a 50/50 chance. I believe Jeff's info is right. Tell me, with my thought process explained, how else should I be playing this?