Death Note Mafia - Game Thread

[Alco]

I like Tweet's posts, on the other hand. Odo worded it perfectly the other game: he looks like someone who's glad he drew town.

 

[JoeExotic]

@JoeExotic what do you think about the players so far?

Do you think you’re ready to make a reads list?

Not really... i dont really have any reads on anyone just yet... plus i got to catch up a bit im a few pages behind.

 

[Smart Marx]

Hard to put into words why but I'm less than impressed by Rugrat. I've read his seven posts just now and they are low-effort and lacking.. conviction?

Like the semi-new statement. I get where he's coming from sort of, but I feel like he's put more effort into the joke there to maybe score some easy points. Call it GUT

Rugrat is a hard one for me in the early game and honestly even later, but especially early on. Low effort definitely feels like Rugrat, but you may have something with the lack of conviction. I say never be afraid to follow your gut if you're town and have town's best interests.

I like Tweet's posts, on the other hand. Odo worded it perfectly the other game: he looks like someone who's glad he drew town.

I do think Tweet looks more comfortable here than the past few times I've seen him draw a scum role.

In fact I think he's been caught on day 1 the last couple of times unless I'm misremembering.

 

[Alco]

Rugrat is a hard one for me in the early game and honestly even later, but especially early on. Low effort definitely feels like Rugrat, but you may have something with the lack of conviction. I say never be afraid to follow your gut if you're town and have town's best interests.


I do think Tweet looks more comfortable here than the past few times I've seen him draw a scum role.

In fact I think he's been caught on day 1 the last couple of times unless I'm misremembering.

Last time he was lynched d1 he was actually town

But I just don't see anything here that should make me think he's scum.

 

[Alco]

Don't have time to read the entire thread, but took a look at some of CP's posts and they definitely look way better than what he produced last game.

Also is pinged by Brutus which is nice since that means we're aligned on that one.
Also thinks Chris and Smark are town. So yeah, similar thoughts, it's usually a good thing.

Only thing where we disagree would be how he views Tweet. @CraigPelton has that read evolved in any way since you're initial statement of think he looked "shook"?

 

[Alco]

Don't ask me why I read posts by some and not others, there's not really a method to this

 

[Alco]

Would vote: Brutus, Rugrat

Would not vote: Poyser, Smark, Tweet, Chris, CP

If another direction is taken, convince me why it's the right one, because i'll never have time to read all of this

 

[Poyser]

ISO OMB alco it’ll take you about 2 mins, you can skim all theme spec

 

[Roy Mustang]

Yeah the set up spec isn't that important now he has flipped though I'm curious post-game if it was his fake or he went into business for himself. Maybe ISO Brutus as well since you mentioned you're suss of him Alco

 

[Tweet]

breh why would you give reasons you think i'm town and then say you wouldn't mind a wagon on me tomorrow?

there are like 21 other people in the game and maybe half of them with no reason to read them town

What reasons to read you town have I given?

 

[JoeExotic]

Would vote: Brutus, Rugrat

Would not vote: Poyser, Smark, Tweet, Chris, CP

If another direction is taken, convince me why it's the right one, because i'll never have time to read all of this

Im on board with a vote against Rugrat... My reasoning being his beginning posts were dodgy as he voted me with no explanation and stuck with it. My personal opinion is he might be trying to hansel and gretel the new guy.

 

[NotBrutus]

I think it's kind of an easy backtrack to do when you see none of what you're selling is being bought. Do appreciate the honesty though, I guess.

What was I selling though? I mentioned people (and was wrong) but I didn’t even suss any of them. I could easily say I wasn’t buying your Banez sheep either... what would be your response?

 

[PHEN0M]

No night yet

 

[NotBrutus]

In my personal opinion that's a better direction for tomorrow.

I think there's been a few too many peeps gettign away with thoughts without reading back.

The backtracking isn't a particularly sexy look either.

Which peeps?

Im on board with a vote against Rugrat... My reasoning being his beginning posts were dodgy as he voted me with no explanation and stuck with it. My personal opinion is he might be trying to hansel and gretel the new guy.

What do you mean?

 

[Smart Marx]

Which peeps?



What do you mean?

You, Alco, Nom, Banez (rip), have all offered either thoughts or votes or both without reading back and I'm sure I've missed someone.