Barry Presents: WS Mafia 3 "The Revival" Game Thread

[Tommy Bedlam]

whats your read on gip

His time analysis post seems like a townie move. Before that I wasn’t totally sure on him.

what changed

When you can’t even consider that you may be wrong, I don’t think you have any interest in helping town. Unless you have a case where somebody slips or you get guaranteed cop info, I think you have to be willing to consider that you’re wrong.

Also you keep being so certain on people being mafia then going back on it, that’s not helping ya bud! Blaine is the only one who has stayed on your mafia list! What happens if we take your lead, go for Sky and then at the last second you suddenly take it back because now someone else is now 100% mafia but it’s too late because Skys been lynched! What happens then Tommy?

You want me to be 100% certain? Sorry pal. Things change as the game progresses. And I’m not leading the charge on Sky. I’m defending myself and recognizing that sky is trying to do something that will hurt town. Pendex mentioned voting sky before anyone else IIRC. You can vote with sky if that’s what you wanna do. I’m not trying to act like I’ve played a great game (I said town Tommy is Shit Tommy). But I’ve also had to spend the time I’ve been online defending myself from a mislynch.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Tommy says his case on me isn't OMGUS even though his central (and as far as I can tell only) point is "I claim to be town, Sky thinks I am scum, and townies are literally never wrong". Therefore voting me because I voted him. That's OMGUS

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Ok sky. You’re right. All of your intentions are guaranteed to be 100% genuine and I should trust you. You’re wanting to mislynch me because you honestly believe I’m scum.

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Jeff Valley Driver Who do you think is more likely to reach hammer with the current crop, Tommy or Mando? Need an answer to decide who I'm voting

ugh lol

 

[Comrade Khan]

At least one of Tommy or Sky are bad
Jeff too confident on a bad read
CP drilling into things too deep

I hope you are right old friend. but also this doesnt help today

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Ok sky. You’re right. All of your intentions are guaranteed to be 100% genuine and I should trust you. You’re wanting to mislynch me because you honestly believe I’m scum.

Good, you're learning. This game isn't a dichotomy between "agrees with me" and "scum".

That is of course assuming you're town and you're posting this from a genuine place which is like... basically 0% at this point

 

[CakeWalker]

this rally between Tommy and Sky looks very town on town. mhmmmm confused

 

[The Gipper]

You want me to be 100% certain? Sorry pal. Things change as the game progresses.

No, the problem is that you keep posting like you’re 100% certain that someone is mafia and then 10 posts later you’re like “Nevermind! I now trust them!” , how can we trust someone in this game when they can’t even make their own mind up. I don’t need you to be 100% certain, I need you to not flip flop for me bud.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Ok.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Ok. Saturday, so I’m not gonna be hanging out on here much. Sky will likely get me mislynched in the next day cycle. If you all don’t want to consider her (since apparently I shouldn’t suggest that she could be doing shit on purpose….), at least consider the fact that Blaine hasn’t said anything about Juice (if he did and I missed it, I’m sure somebody will jump on this), and Juice has said that blaine is the only person she would vote. I still think there’s 1-2 scum in those 3 names. When you guys off me and I flip town, maybe then you’ll consider listening to me.

this is very passive aggressive and I hate that it opens with saying SKY WILL GET ME MISLYNCHED

 

[CakeWalker]

Town prior: Pendex & Gipper

after the rally, id actually be confident in adding Tommy and also Sky in there for the moment, as slight town reads because seems a foolish engagement from mafia too do after a N1 NK.

UNVOTE

VOTE: JEFF

mafia hiding in plain sight and seems very comfortable with current seat at the table.

 

[Tommy Bedlam]

Sorry for not qualifying my statements by saying “I think X might.” If that’s really the problem here, then yea, I’m a royal fuck up on the townie side lol. Nobody is 100% certain of anything other than their own role unless you’re in the scum chat. So yea, when I read stuff, reread stuff, catch stuff I missed, I may have a different perception on people as the game continues. I’ve been consistently on Blaine, but there’s no interest in him. Why would I just keep harping on it?

this is very passive aggressive and I hate that it opens with saying SKY WILL GET ME MISLYNCHED

I’m fluent in passive aggressive. I had no reason to think she wouldn’t have me mislynched by now as she had almost pulled it off before that.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Tommy/Juice combo not exactly looking unlikely

 

[Comrade Khan]

Town prior: Pendex & Gipper

after the rally, id actually be confident in adding Tommy and also Sky in there for the moment, as slight town reads because seems a foolish engagement from mafia too do after a N1 NK.

UNVOTE

VOTE: JEFF

mafia hiding in plain sight and seems very comfortable with current seat at the table.

Juice, I think you were on the right track before. not so much here. you should ponder as to why our reads of gipper are aligned carefully. unless like I said, ive completely misjudged a certain post of yours.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Gip looks good for that huge time analysis post. Juice looks like she’s playing a slower, methodical game, which I like. I was on board with you and your suspicion of sky.

Blaine still looks like shit to me. I also think he and sky are distancing. Sky mentions him in posts as sus, but has no interest in targeting. Either puts him between other names or second to another, and he just doesn’t really say much of anything, but voted me and then bounced on d1.

im not sussing Jeff at this point, but I do think I may have town leaned him a tick early. I think there’s probably 1 scum out of him, CP, and TPein.

what happened to Juice being a lock scum?