Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Smart Marx]

is it still night? reading back from page 58

It is.

 

[Lethal]

Speaking of our exchange I am curious how you feel Poyser being scum affects your read of Sky since didn’t you say she wouldn’t engage Poyser as scum or was that only predicated on him being town?

Her newfound confidence surely enables her to be brash enough to try it as scum, but as a scum/scum pairing I don't see Poyser going for that play at all.

You were right on one thing, and for his flip, we get a scum revealed, and now I have 3 solid town reads (yourself, Odo and Sky). I'm also iffy on Tweets, but that's still from D1 and he's done nothing to shift that. Kinda popping in and out of the thread, not wanting to gain any traction here or there.

 

[Lethal]

You've had this game. And not taken the opportunity.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

You were right on one thing, and for his flip, we get a scum revealed, and now I have 3 solid town reads (yourself, Odo and Sky). I'm also iffy on Tweets, but that's still from D1 and he's done nothing to shift that. Kinda popping in and out of the thread, not wanting to gain any traction here or there.

Any read on Jeff? You might as well complete the set of consensus town reads

 

[Lethal]

Any read on Jeff? You might as well complete the set of consensus town reads

I do have a read

 

[Comrade Khan]

Well the last 6 pages were a colossal waste of time

 

[Comrade Khan]

@Odo can you run down your points about tweet to me?

 

[RDK]

Well the last 6 pages were a colossal waste of time

 

[Lethal]

Well the last 6 pages were a colossal waste of time

Jeff, my man. How would you react if I were to say I think you're a scum boy?

 

[Odo]

@Odo can you run down your points about tweet to me?

I think he’s the likeliest candidate to have co-ordinated distancing with Poyser, as I don’t think Poyser deliberately antagonises only town

also think his effort and outrage at being suspected are kinda phoney

play around Poyser doesn’t make sense, what was he testing?

the point about Brutus in bond mafia felt prepared, but then he acted like it wasn’t. Lots of little contradictions

 

[Comrade Khan]

Jeffatron
Big Man
Raidokken
Judas Iscariot
Mitch Perfect
Odo
PHEN0M
Showtime
Alco
Darth Lethal
Banez
Mr.Tweetums
V. Skybox
Uncle Larry
NotBrutus
Broken God

Loosely where I am. Smark town off poyser wagon/activity, Odo town for poyser wagon, same with Sky( so far). I put Brutus under town as well for 2 reasons, I didn't hate his analysis ( I also don't think he tries to save poyser on day 1, in fact ive never really seen him try to save a m8) and the fact that poyser tried a weak ass push on him.

Haza we've established why he could be scummy, Banez's posts have sucked balls imo, and Mitch's read list was dogshit imo (I know some people disagree, but I see over forced reads personally).

NULL on the rest at the moment.

 

[Comrade Khan]

Jeff, my man. How would you react if I were to say I think you're a scum boy?

I'd ask you why

 

[Comrade Khan]

I think he’s the likeliest candidate to have co-ordinated distancing with Poyser, as I don’t think Poyser deliberately antagonises only town

also think his effort and outrage at being suspected are kinda phoney

play around Poyser doesn’t make sense, what was he testing?

the point about Brutus in bond mafia felt prepared, but then he acted like it wasn’t. Lots of little contradictions

noted. I have some outside reasons to believe he may be town as well, but your bolded point has some legs and I agree that he would be the likeliest candidate for not only distancing, but a bus. My only concern would be the logic of bussing and tunelling poyser so damn early in the day when there wasn't much going on at the time, and I believe that originally, your poyser vote was without reasoning and you let it breathe for quite some time. Am I correct on that timeline?

 

[Odo]

I’d say I clarified it fairly quickly tbh

Tweet was the 4th vote on the wagon initially, then moved off

 

[RDK]

Jeffatron
Big Man
Raidokken
Judas Iscariot
Mitch Perfect
Odo
PHEN0M
Showtime
Alco
Darth Lethal
Banez
Mr.Tweetums
V. Skybox
Uncle Larry
NotBrutus
Broken God

Loosely where I am. Smark town off poyser wagon/activity, Odo town for poyser wagon, same with Sky( so far). I put Brutus under town as well for 2 reasons, I didn't hate his analysis ( I also don't think he tries to save poyser on day 1, in fact ive never really seen him try to save a m8) and the fact that poyser tried a weak ass push on him.

Haza we've established why he could be scummy, Banez's posts have sucked balls imo, and Mitch's read list was dogshit imo (I know some people disagree, but I see over forced reads personally).

NULL on the rest at the moment.

Is yellow like scum lean? Do you think any of the yellows wouldn't be teamed?