Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Odo]

Apart from the other town reads I made, the Tweetdar says PHEN0M is vibing town as well.

on what basis?

 

[Lethal]

Actually it was Better Call Saul, where I called a Hider shot in this manner

See, you came through for us.

So on one occasion this happens, and now it's a tell?

Entertain this thought - if I were scum, how easy would it be for me to tunnel the shit out of you and have you be a prime mislynch candidate? It'd be easier than buttering toast of a morning.

You don't want to even remotely consider why I was suspicious of Tweets, you're just focused on why I didn't vote for Poyser (even though I justified that to Smark during our exchange)

 

[Tweet]

Early town read on Magic has dissolved into nothing by now, his hook line and sinker "this is what I gotta say to get town reads" shtick worked on me two games ago and him wanting to lynch Skybox no matter her alignment could be just that.

 

[Lethal]

I’m not even sure what I’m looking at

are you saying games where lethal doesn’t interact with you, he’s scum?

he didn’t interact with anyone til fairly recently tho?

From what I have gathered, my huge scum tell is NOT tunneling her :

 

[Tweet]

on what basis?

He doesn't seem to be making any of those token "look at me, I got towns best interest in mind" posts that he usually makes as scum.

 

[Leon TrotSky]

Entertain this thought - if I were scum, how easy would it be for me to tunnel the shit out of you and have you be a prime mislynch candidate? It'd be easier than buttering toast of a morning.

It wouldn't, because it'd just be "Same old silly town Lethal, doing his thing" and no one would take you seriously. You'd probably get vigged sooner rather than later.

Of course, that's hypothetical, because for whatever reason you have never actually done this

 

[Smart Marx]

See, you came through for us.

So on one occasion this happens, and now it's a tell?

Entertain this thought - if I were scum, how easy would it be for me to tunnel the shit out of you and have you be a prime mislynch candidate? It'd be easier than buttering toast of a morning.

You don't want to even remotely consider why I was suspicious of Tweets, you're just focused on why I didn't vote for Poyser (even though I justified that to Smark during our exchange)

Speaking of our exchange I am curious how you feel Poyser being scum affects your read of Sky since didn’t you say she wouldn’t engage Poyser as scum or was that only predicated on him being town?

 

[Leon TrotSky]

I’m not even sure what I’m looking at

are you saying games where lethal doesn’t interact with you, he’s scum?

he didn’t interact with anyone til fairly recently tho?

I'm saying Lethal gets his shots in when he wants, but as town he goes for the full tunnel, whereas scum Lethal pivots from his initial run, gives the town lean, and tries to stay away from saying meaningful things about me afterward

 

[RDK]

No flips?

 

[RDK]

No @Big Man ?

 

[Lethal]

It wouldn't, because it'd just be "Same old silly town Lethal, doing his thing" and no one would take you seriously. You'd probably get vigged sooner rather than later.

Of course, that's hypothetical, because for whatever reason you have never actually done this

So you wouldn't want to wash the paint away that stains you? Like, oh idk, you're once habit of voting Chimp every game? Got tiresome when people always sussed you for NOT doing it.

I haven't done it because I haven't had the opportunity to do so. You're barking up the wrong tree, but, enjoy the fresh air.

 

[Odo]

I'm saying Lethal gets his shots in when he wants, but as town he goes for the full tunnel, whereas scum Lethal pivots from his initial run, gives the town lean, and tries to stay away from saying meaningful things about me afterward

ok, that’s more clear

 

[Smart Marx]

As I said last night, even a broken clock is right twice a day. I was wrong about Poyser.

I would like to know that now given this flip, does it suit the direction @Broken God who said it would provide info about others. Did I miss this in my read back?

Most of that info was based Poyser asking me if I was wrong and he flipped town, what would that tell me.

He wasn’t so most of it can be discarded, but I do feel the stuff surrounding Sky and Tweet has more context.

Odo I feel better about as I don’t know if him and Poyser would bus each other on page 1 for no reason.

 

[Comrade Khan]

is it still night? reading back from page 58

 

[Leon TrotSky]

So you wouldn't want to wash the paint away that stains you? Like, oh idk, you're once habit of voting Chimp every game? Got tiresome when people always sussed you for NOT doing it.

I haven't done it because I haven't had the opportunity to do so. You're barking up the wrong tree, but, enjoy the fresh air.

You've had this game. And not taken the opportunity.