Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[PHEN0M]

I dont know if you're scum or not. Just saying that it would be funny if that would turn out to be the case.

I'm glad you are playing now. But i am surprised how strongly Lethal reads you as town after the little effort you put in, any thoughts on that?

Looking through Smark’s day two, his play around you and your wagon doesn’t make me feel great about you boyo

 

[PHEN0M]

@Darth Lethal i think I’d like you to claim

phenom, I’m assuming you’re a commuter?

No. when i said they couldn’t kill me, that wasn’t entirely true, they can, but at the risk to their own life.

 

[Tweet]

Absolutely. He was all in on a Poyser lynch, then backed up as soon as Mitch became viable, then straight back to the comfort of Poyser once the Mitch wagon was losing traction. Day 2 he starts on Banez, doing lots of flip/flops here and there, comes back onto Banez and then puts a vote on Haza when he's right near the end of his rope. I also dislike how he's not actual pushing anything like town Tweet would. He's choosing to play it safe and follow the lead of others so he can establish a safety net if he's wrong.

Ima comment on posts one by one as I catch up.

The timeline on Poyser there doesn't match reality, When I voted Mitch I was the second guy to do so after Poyser started it, and I unvoted rather quickly once I realized that Poyser was kinda just looking to create a diversion from himself. If anything you could accuse me of killng the momentum of the Mitch wagon, which would be a bad argument to make however since I unvoted Mitch in favour of voting someone who turned out to be scum, so there's nothing bad you could accuse me of there except for bussing.

My play around Banez is gonna make sense at mass claim.

And me not pushing stuff is a fair point, I'm playing another game next to this one on PerC and also got me a couple new games for my Switch that I spend a lot of time on so this game gets lost in the shuffle for a few hours at times.

 

[Tweet]

Chapter 4:
A Killer Killed and the Girlfriend Too
​

@Broken God was killed last night...​ Spoiler: Smark Raiden Haza - Smithton Killers Aligned 2x Janitor Raiden Haza is a local teacher at West Smithton High School and is one of the more respected people at the school. While the name may sound interesting, he waves it off as nothing but a funny joke by his parents. When the killings started, Haza grew into a protector of kids and has been known to be a practitioner of several defensive arts and survivalist studies. You are the Smithton Killers Aligned 2x Janitor. Each night you may choose to kill another player and hide their role from the rest of the Citizens. Their role will be revealed to only the Smithton Killers. You win when you control the majority or the Citizens can no longer lynch another Smithton Killer.

@Jeffatron was also killed.

Spoiler: Jeff

[/CENTER]
Tessa Smarkith - Citizen Aligned Mason

Tessa Smarkith is the girlfriend of Damien Odo. She was also one of Bob Steiner’s friends and is looking to find out who killed him. She’s smart and doesn’t back down from a fight; a pretty confident archetypal “final girl”, if there was one.

You are the Citizen Aligned Mason. You are able to communicate privately with Damien Odo (Mr. Tweetums). You win when all threats to the Citizens have been eliminated.

It is now DAY 3! With 12 players alive, it requires 7 to lynch. Day lasts 24 hours or until a lynch is made. Good luck.​

Muh GF

 

[Tweet]

Holy shit, Smark was maf? I had him pegged as town. Really sucks that Jeff was killed but at least Tweet is now a confirmed townie.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I see Mitch and Jeffv2 are having a discussion over this, but Mitch thinking that I'm confirmed town off of Jeffs flip seems like a noob town thing. Like if Mitch is scum I think people in his QT would have let shine through to some degree that my role doesn't confirm me and I'm still very very mislynchable. So him thinking I'm confirmed town off of Jeffs flip seems more like a conclusion he came to on his own.

 

[Lethal]

I do wanna point out that there's 1 thing that Poyser & Smark both did.

And that was to vote you when you said "scum come at me"

That's bold coz why would any scum do that?

Except Smark never voted PHEN0M. He voted Poyser and never budged.

 

[PHEN0M]

I think Jeff being able to rep back in is more of an indication of your alignment to me than his death, Tweet.

 

[Lethal]

He may be trying to appeal to me to help lighten my scum read on him.

Not at all. Just things have changed overnight, and of the 2 possibilities presented, I'm putting my faith in your being town as your posts push me that way.

 

[Lethal]

I think Jeff being able to rep back in is more of an indication of your alignment to me than his death, Tweet.

That's an interesting point

 

[Lethal]

@Darth Lethal i think I’d like you to claim

phenom, I’m assuming you’re a commuter?

Yeah, nah, I don't think I'd like to claim just now. You'll have to trust me and be patient.

 

[Lethal]

Ima comment on posts one by one as I catch up.

The timeline on Poyser there doesn't match reality, When I voted Mitch I was the second guy to do so after Poyser started it, and I unvoted rather quickly once I realized that Poyser was kinda just looking to create a diversion from himself. If anything you could accuse me of killng the momentum of the Mitch wagon, which would be a bad argument to make however since I unvoted Mitch in favour of voting someone who turned out to be scum, so there's nothing bad you could accuse me of there except for bussing.

My play around Banez is gonna make sense at mass claim.

And me not pushing stuff is a fair point, I'm playing another game next to this one on PerC and also got me a couple new games for my Switch that I spend a lot of time on so this game gets lost in the shuffle for a few hours at times.

You're not above bussing, which has been beaten like a dead horse but stays relevant and is not something to town read you for. You also bounced around in regards to Banez.

Your play around a claimed VT will make sense at mass claim, even though we know who you both are? Colour me intrigued, because I'm genuinely confused as to what your motivations are with this.

 

[Comrade Khan]

I see Mitch and Jeffv2 are having a discussion over this, but Mitch thinking that I'm confirmed town off of Jeffs flip seems like a noob town thing. Like if Mitch is scum I think people in his QT would have let shine through to some degree that my role doesn't confirm me and I'm still very very mislynchable. So him thinking I'm confirmed town off of Jeffs flip seems more like a conclusion he came to on his own.

Not sure i care much for this assessement, it was like 1 or 130 in the a.m , the thread was basically just me lethal and mitch at the time afaik. So the options of his scum team diverting him away from that line of thinking isn't really that feasable timeline wise

 

[Tweet]

Jeffv2s entrance is sorta townie as well. Him smelling a rat behind Mitch wanting to confirm me for Jeffv1s flip rather than interpreting it as a noobie take could be him having an agenda, but then he rather quickly accepts it when Mitch explains it to him so probably not an agenda then?

 

[Lethal]

And I am getting kinda annoyed at people excusing people's play on the assumption that they may be instructed to post a certain way in their QTs. I can't help but shake that Jeff's flip said THE town mason

 

[Lethal]

@Grim oh glorious host, could you please be a lad and do us a solid with an updated OP? That would be most awesome of you