Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Banez]

So er, what was the point of that conversation

Just for the fun of it

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

The "vote-list" is there so patterns can be observed. If you don't want to use it, that's your deal.

Yeah, OMB was riding Smark's dick hard but Smark was being town read from a lot of people, so maybe it was a bus of sorts in the event OMB got whacked which made Smark look even better?

As for PHEN0M, I have a very good reason to now read him town



So your rage has subsided now that you're off the block for a moment.

I have strong reasoning to buy PHEN0M as town.



Why are you introducing SK spec when that's not a priority atm? Seems needless distraction and scrambling.

if you think I am scum and going after half my team then dude you must really think I'm low hanging fruit. I am not scrambling I am basing it off the fact there was two kills last night and person who I think did it has not claimed it so it means a. They are a big with multiple shots. B. A SK and more then likely a indy. I know where my vote is going I am just having a discussion. I mean you haven't look great in this game it's why I rank you as #2 most likely scum

 

[Lethal]

Smark voted Poyser and never got off. Smark voted Haza and never went off. Mitch mirrored those votes.

Odo, your take on Jeff's PM saying THE town mason, not A town mason? Am I being stupid?

 

[Odo]

I imagine the serial killer killed smark cause they thought they were a threat / weren’t lynchable

 

[Odo]

Smark voted Poyser and never got off. Smark voted Haza and never went off. Mitch mirrored those votes.

Odo, your take on Jeff's PM saying THE town mason, not A town mason? Am I being stupid?

it’s a good spot but not something I want to bet the game on. But it was a good spot,you’re improving

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

I imagine the serial killer killed smark cause they thought they were a threat / weren’t lynchable

Healthy to have a discussion bout it but I do think it's more likely SK over vig like I said killing Smark was an interesting move I mean besides me no one really thought he was maf. Jeffatron dying is something to aswell.

 

[Lethal]

yep

tip: your reason isn’t as good as you think it is. Just think about it given the state of the game

do you have any other reads, other than me you feel this strong about?

Tweets being scum hasn't left my sights, but I don't want tunnel vision and I've outlined my reasoning for me thinking he is scum. I'm also strong on Banez being scum.

Magic hasn't offered much at all to read him, Rugrat is a mixed basket of eggs, Alco/KIF are nothing to go off (Jeff/Haza haven't put much in since the reps). Brutus screams scared coward scum, fits with his MO.

if you think I am scum and going after half my team then dude you must really think I'm low hanging fruit. I am not scrambling I am basing it off the fact there was two kills last night and person who I think did it has not claimed it so it means a. They are a big with multiple shots. B. A SK and more then likely a indy. I know where my vote is going I am just having a discussion. I mean you haven't look great in this game it's why I rank you as #2 most likely scum

So defensive for ? reasons? I said you MAY be scum, and are a lean on scum.

I've had a bad run of reads (Poyser/Smark) but I was right on Jeff. I'm trying to solve the game in my own stupid way. You've posted flimsy reasoning for your reads and now want to run the SK tangent. There's a possibility that the vig shot Smark too, so let's not go exposing anybody just yet. We wait to mass claim and see what transpires.

I imagine the serial killer killed smark cause they thought they were a threat / weren’t lynchable

If you had a choice between scum or SK today, who swings?

 

[Showtime]

@Showtime result pls

Also mass claim looking better and better, scum look very unlikely to have much to claim given the flips

Nah.

We should mass claim then I'll claim result

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Tweets being scum hasn't left my sights, but I don't want tunnel vision and I've outlined my reasoning for me thinking he is scum. I'm also strong on Banez being scum.

Magic hasn't offered much at all to read him, Rugrat is a mixed basket of eggs, Alco/KIF are nothing to go off (Jeff/Haza haven't put much in since the reps). Brutus screams scared coward scum, fits with his MO.



So defensive for ? reasons? I said you MAY be scum, and are a lean on scum.

I've had a bad run of reads (Poyser/Smark) but I was right on Jeff. I'm trying to solve the game in my own stupid way. You've posted flimsy reasoning for your reads and now want to run the SK tangent. There's a possibility that the vig shot Smark too, so let's not go exposing anybody just yet. We wait to mass claim and see what transpires.



If you had a choice between scum or SK today, who swings?

I never said to expose them. I am not being defensive I just think your play has been awful I think you and mitch game have been pretty awful.

 

[Kim Jong Umb]

Official Vote: Mitch

 

[Banez]

Fairly certain Jefferey is town, like 95%. Will be 100% when Banez flips scum.

Can't wait to see my flip and watch you go "oh.. still pretty bad game from him"

 

[Banez]

Odo/Tweetum/Mitch/Lethal though I think there might be one or two mafia in there and I haven't ruled out that possibility that smark is maf.

What made you think Smark was maf?

Coz everyone else was reading him town.

Especially that guy Lethal with solid blue.

 

[Odo]

Nah.

We should mass claim then I'll claim result

ill be claiming last in that case

 

[Odo]

But na, no watcher / bg / cop exposed so

give your result please magic

 

[Lethal]

I never said to expose them. I am not being defensive I just think your play has been awful I think you and mitch game have been pretty awful.

What has been awful? You throw it around but make no meaning. Get off the fence and pull the splinters out.