Barry Presents: Whodunnit 2: The West Smithton Sagas GAME THREAD

[Tweet]

But na, no watcher / bg / cop exposed so

give your result please magic

I agree with this, we shouldn't be mass claiming yet.

 

[Tweet]

No. when i said they couldn’t kill me, that wasn’t entirely true, they can, but at the risk to their own life.

Oh okay, that's pretty much what I thought after reading your first few posts.

 

[Tweet]

I think Jeff being able to rep back in is more of an indication of your alignment to me than his death, Tweet.

Now that you say this... I'm not sure a dead Mason repping back in should even be allowed? Cause Jeffs second life shouldn't have any idea of what his first life and I talked about in private?

 

[Banez]

Except Smark never voted PHEN0M. He voted Poyser and never budged.

This is true, i read his post as voting but he never put on a vote.

vote phenom

no, wait

IF YOU INSIST

But you probably understand what i meant here.

 

[Tweet]

You're not above bussing, which has been beaten like a dead horse but stays relevant and is not something to town read you for. You also bounced around in regards to Banez.

Your play around a claimed VT will make sense at mass claim, even though we know who you both are? Colour me intrigued, because I'm genuinely confused as to what your motivations are with this.

Okay so you clearly can't keep sussing me for my flipflopping around Poyser and Mitch, so you're moving the goalposts to uphold your scum read on me anyway. Gotcha.

 

[RDK]

Mm mass claim would probably help me but also don't really wanna out those PR's

 

[Tweet]

And I am getting kinda annoyed at people excusing people's play on the assumption that they may be instructed to post a certain way in their QTs. I can't help but shake that Jeff's flip said THE town mason

Is your point here that you think Jeff was Masons with himself?

 

[RDK]

Are we assuming no vig or no sk? With 1 kill then 2 or just well placed BG?

 

[Comrade Khan]

^ or aky was the vig?

 

[Comrade Khan]

Sky**

 

[Comrade Khan]

Did i also read right that yhey 3x ninja and 2x jan? Godamn

 

[Tweet]

So here's something to think about.

Smark was a 2x Janitor but Jeff was killed without being janitored. This means that either Jeff was killed by non-scum (which is almost impossible), or they rolecopped Jeff n1.

OR, and this one is interesting to me, there is someone on the scum team who managed to figure out my mason partner from my play, and they decided to kill Jeff without a janitor shot cause they knew Jeff had a role that they couldn't claim if they janitored it. I won't deny that I've been so-so obvious about who my mason partner was, but there's only a handful of people in here who would actually put some thought into finding out who I'm masons with.

You guys think Smark figured it out on his own? Cause if not, that means one of the better players in this game is most likely scum.

 

[Lethal]

This is true, i read his post as voting but he never put on a vote.

But you probably understand what i meant here.

Thank you for providing the context. But you specifically said voted, not made a wise crack alluding to a vote. It's all about the details.

 

[Tweet]

Sky could very well have been the vig, but if so I think she woulda taken a shot n1 anyway which is nowhere to be found.

 

[Lethal]

Okay so you clearly can't keep sussing me for my flipflopping around Poyser and Mitch, so you're moving the goalposts to uphold your scum read on me anyway. Gotcha.

I also mentioned your flipping around Banez. You went Banez, unvote, Banez, me, Rugrat, Magic, Banez again, and finally Haza. Do you see what I am saying?