Barry Presents: Sergio Leone Mafia / Una Mafia Del West Game Thread

[Odo]

It was because sky was specifically (personally) asked not to do it, and then did it anyway

 

[Smart Marx]

The actual scope hasn’t broadened at all, just play the game properly rather than relying on cheap bullshit and all will be fine

Cheap bullshit also is well defined and anything can be considered cheap bllshit at the end of the day.

Hence I wanted clarification on this issue.

 

[NotBrutus]

Ffs, that Odo/Smark banter took up most of the posts. I’m getting a sense of deja vu, hasn’t Smark posted links to justify a role before, and he flipped scum? Smark more than likely is scum.

Smark/Odo has already been beaten to death. So I’ll move on and pick through the Phen0m wagon. Who Smark tried to throw shade at which I DID NOT like.

Also, any reason to believe Jeff is town? He keeps throwing shade at me towards Odo. Odo usually is the catalyst of my deaths in mafia games And if he were scum, I’m sure Chimp is scum with him.

 

[Smart Marx]

It was because sky was specifically (personally) asked not to do it, and then did it anyway

Fair enough.

 

[Odo]

Cheap bullshit also is well defined and anything can be considered cheap bllshit at the end of the day.

Hence I wanted clarification on this issue.

I mean if it helps, I’ll create actual rules - I don’t really want to go down that route as I feel we’re a good bunch but appreciate there is some grey in ‘cheap bullshit’

 

[Comrade Khan]

Ffs, that Odo/Smark banter took up most of the posts. I’m getting a sense of deja vu, hasn’t Smark posted links to justify a role before, and he flipped scum? Smark more than likely is scum.

Smark/Odo has already been beaten to death. So I’ll move on and pick through the Phen0m wagon. Who Smark tried to throw shade at which I DID NOT like.

Also, any reason to believe Jeff is town? He keeps throwing shade at me towards Odo. Odo usually is the catalyst of my deaths in mafia games And if he were scum, I’m sure Chimp is scum with him.

that's a bold lie. I've explained at nauseum my reason to press odo on it. Even answered you directly I believe.

 

[RDK]

Well I think it’s a rolecop screen, so basically use it on someone you guys aren’t killing

 

[Smart Marx]

I mean if it helps, I’ll create actual rules - I don’t really want to go down that route as I feel we’re a good bunch but appreciate there is some grey in ‘cheap bullshit’

I was always under the impression the host picked their rules and we just abide by that, but honestly I think Grim's OP is airtight.

 

[Odo]

I don’t really care how it’s done, I just want people to play mafia, not use-host-negligence-against-them-fia

 

[Smart Marx]

Fair enough.

 

[Comrade Khan]

If you think me pressing Odo for a read on a player he mentioned and asked questions to is scummy Brutus, than I would suggest you're missing the point. You do realize, once again, that me asking Odo about you is much more interrogating Odo about his motives than it is a shade at you.

 

[Smart Marx]

I just want people to play mafia

I do think scum lying about host answers and interaction is playing mafia hence my only question about that.

Now that that's resolved. WE're good.

 

[Comrade Khan]

fwiw, I see nothing wrong with pretending to ask the host something. while it's generally seen as a towny move, as long as the host doesn't directly reply in thread, I think that's perfectly acceptable lying?

 

[Smart Marx]

I'd think so.

 

[Odo]

As I said, if scum are going to fake a role, there’s a chance they are gonna have to fake a mod interaction too.

that isn’t cheating, that’s part of the game, it just requires care from the mod if there are follow up questions.

however using forum mechanics and leveraging the mods decision making to avoid suspicion is not what mafia is